Table 1.
Description of Reviews Included in the CBT for SUD Treatment Evaluation
| Study | Intervention(s) | Number of Studies | Population | Setting | Comparison Condition | Outcome | Time Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dutra et al., 2008 | Psychosocial treatments for SUDs, including CBT and RP | 18 (13 CBT; 5 RP) | Adults with illicit SUDs, including cannabis (n = 4), cocaine (n = 4), opioids (n = 4), polysubstance (n = 6); also included participants with co-occurring borderline personality disorder, bipolar disorder, and posttraumatic stress disorder | Non-intensive outpatient treatment | Inactive or active treatment | Self-reported or biologically-verified substance use | Post-treatment |
| Irvin et al., 1999 | RP (individual, group, or couples format; with or without an adjunctive treatment) | 26 | Alcohol (n = 10), smoking (n = 8), or other substance use, including polysubstance use (n = 5) and cocaine use (n = 3) | Inpatient; outpatient | Pre-post change within person; waitlist or no-additional treatment control; active intervention | Self-reported or biologically-verified substance use; psychosocial adjustment | Post-treatment; 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-months post-treatment |
| Magill & Ray, 2009 | CBT, RP, or coping-skills training (individual or group format; with or without an adjunctive treatment) | 53 | Adults with SUDs, including alcohol (n = 23), cocaine/stimulants (n = 11), polydrug (n = 11), cannabis (n = 6), opioids (n = 2); “…64% of studies allowed nonsubstance-related co-occurring diagnoses (exclusive of suicidal or homicidal ideation and active psychosis)” (p. 520) | NS | Active treatment; passive treatment or usual service; no treatment; no CBT adjunct | Self-reported or biologically-verified substance use | Post-treatment to 4 months post-treatment; 6–12 months post-treatment |
| Magill et al. 2019 | CBT or RP (individual or group format) | 30 (across 32 study sites) | Adults with SUDs or problematic use, including alcohol (n = 15), cannabis (n = 3), opioids (n = 2), stimulants (n = 6), and polydrug (n = 6) | Community sample; specialty substance use or mental health clinic; Medical setting; College setting; Criminal legal setting; Other setting | Minimal treatment; Non-specific therapy; Other specific therapy | Self-reported or biologically-verified substance use | Early (1–6 months) post-treatment; Late post-treatment (8+ months) |
| Windsor et al., 2015 | CBT (individual, group, or combined) | 16 | Adults (≥70% White or Black and/or Hispanic) with substance use, including cocaine (n = 3), cannabis (n = 3), alcohol (n = 6), alcohol + other drugs (n = 4) | NS | Comparison treatment; pre-post change within person | Substance use | Post-treatment; Average follow-up from baseline (1–24 months) |
Note. CBT = Cognitive Behavioral Therapy; RP = Relapse Prevention; SUD = Substance Use Disorder; NS = not specified. 734