Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 29;12(19):3622. doi: 10.3390/foods12193622

Table 2.

Relationship between learning levels and political economy.

Collective/Individual Learning Levels Instrumental Learning Communicative Learning Emancipatory Learning
Who learns? Nutritionists,
public managers,
government organizations,
farmers,
cooperatives
Nutritionists,
public managers,
farmers,
cooperatives,
government organizations,
union leaders,
outsourced companies that provide services for school meals
A few public managers,
nongovernmental organizations that promote organic and agroecological
traditional communities,
cooperatives of organic and agroecological products
Why do they learn? Act 11,947,
FNDE resolutions,
regional acts and regulations
Sectorial councils that involve Secretariats, EMATER, farmers, CAE and nutritionists, which adapt Act 11,947 and FNDE resolutions to the municipality’s demand Need to introduce sustainable consumption, favoring healthier and quality food, in addition to encouraging organic and agroecological farmers
How do they learn? Following Act 11,947,
FNDE resolutions,
regional laws and regulations
They meet with representatives of sectoral groups to discuss improvements to Act 11,947 and regional regulations They meet with public managers and EMATER to introduce organic and agroecological foods in school meals
What is learned? Following PNAE regulations and complying with Act 11,947 by purchasing 30% of products from family farming They organize a food system that exceeds the minimum standards required by Act 11,947, promoting the local economy Demanding means for organic and agroecological products to be introduced into the food system promoted by the PNAE
Political Economy
Who owns what? Public managers have power and responsibility for the execution of the PNAE
Farmers have their production to meet the PNAE
Students have the right to school meals
Public managers participate in the sectoral council and have the power to execute the PNAE and direct the local food system
Farmers have incentives to produce more
Students have the right to school meals
A few public managers and
nongovernmental organizations are aware of the need to introduce organic and agroecological foods in school meals
Farmers have their property and organic or agroecological production
Traditional communities have their lands and traditions
Students have the right to school meals
Who does what? Nutritionists, public managers and government organizations implement act 11,947 and FNDE resolutions
Farmers deliver their produce
Public managers and the sectoral council implement strategies to expand the PNAE and local development
Farmers seek to expand their production
A few public managers
and nongovernmental organizations seek to create mechanisms to introduce organic and agroecological foods in the PNAE
Farmers seek to guarantee organic production conditions
Who gets what? Public managers receive the maintenance of sending resources
Farmers are compensated for their products
Students receive school meals
The municipality exceeds the target established by Act 11,947, reaching 100% of products from family farming
Farmers are able to expand their production, serving the PNAE and other markets Farmers have production to meet the PNAE, other programs and other markets
Students receive a diversified school meal
A few public managers
and nongovernmental organizations manage to guide consumption in the municipality towards organic and agroecological foods
Organic and agroecological farmers are able to sell their products at a fair price
Students receive healthy, pesticide-free school meals
What they do with that? Public managers execute the PNAE
Farmers drive the local economy
Students have at least 15% of their dietary needs met
Public managers and the sectoral council foster local development
Farmers, with more resources, expand their properties and production and move the local economy
Students have at least 15% of their dietary needs met
A few public managers and nongovernmental organizations consolidate the production of organic and agroecological products in the municipality
Organic and agroecological farmers obtain certifications
Students have at least 15% of their dietary needs met

Source: Authors’ own work.