Table 3.
Evaluation of current diagnostic methods to assess liver fibrosis stage
Unaware of test | Not useful for fibrosis assessment | Use in clinical practice for fibrosis assessment but do not use | Useful for liver fibrosis assessment | |||||
2014–2015 | 2021 | 2014–2015 | 2021 | 2014–2015 | 2021 | 2014–2015 | 2021 | |
Clinical examination (n) | 0.9% (2) | 0.9% (1) | 49.8% (107) | 40.2% (45) | 47% (101) | 2.7% (3) | 1.9% (4) | 56.2% (63) |
LFTs (n) | 0.9% (2) | 0% (-) | 65.6% (141) | 66.1% (74) | 29.8% (64) | 4.5% (5) | 3.3% (7) | 28.6% (32) |
Synthetic function (n) | 0.9% (2) | 0.9% (1) | 37.2% (80) | 25.9% (29) | 59.5% (128) | 3.6% (4) | 1.9% (4) | 68.7% (77) |
APRI (n) | 15.3% (32) | 6.2% (7) | 5.6% (12) | 7.1% (8) | 43.7% (94) | 52.7% (59) | 34.9% (75) | 32.1% (36) |
FIB-4 (n) | 12.6% (27) | 0% (-) | 1.9% (4) | 0.9% (1) | 40.4% (87) | 14.3% (16) | 44.7% (96) | 83.0% (93) |
NAFLD Fibrosis Score (n) | 5.6% (12) | 2.8% (3) | 1.9% (4) | 0.9% (1) | 58.1% (125) | 33.9% (40) | 34.0% (73) | 60.7% (68) |
ELF (n) | 10.7% (23) | 2.8% (3) | 1.4% (3) | 2.8% (3) | 62.3% (134) | 49.1% (55) | 25.1% (54) | 43.7% (49) |
VCTE (n) | 0% (-) | 0% (-) | 0% (-) | 0% (-) | 13.0% (28) | 3.6% (4) | 86.5% (184) | 95.5% (107) |
ARFI (n) | 16.1% (18) | 2.8% (3) | 57.1% (64) | 18.7% (21) | ||||
Ultrasound (n) | 0% (-) | 16.1% (18) | 35.8% (77) | 2.8% (3) | 2.8% (6) | 57.1% (64) | 61.4% (132) | 18.7% (21) |
CT (n) | 0.5% (1) | 0% (-) | 40% (86) | 35.7% (40) | 16.7% (36) | 9.8% (11) | 60.9% (140) | 52.7% (59) |
MRI (n) | 0.9% (2) | 0% (-) | 29.8% (64) | 33.9% (38) | 25.1% (54) | 17.0% (19) | 42.3% (91) | 48.2% (54) |
Liver biopsy n) | 0% (-) | 0% (-) | 0 (-) | 20.5% (23) | 5.6% (12) | 28.6% (32) | 43.7% (94) | 50.0% (56) |
215 responses received from survey 1 in 2014–2015; 112 responses received from survey 2 in 2021. These were the denominators used for respective surveys. Not all participants responded to each modality stated in question.
ARFI, acoustic radio frequency impulse; ARPI, AST to Platelet Ratio Index; ELF, enhanced liver fibrosis test; FIB-4, Fibrosis-4 score; LFTs, liver function tests; VCTE, vibration controlled transient elastography.