Skip to main content
. 2022 Dec;82:101758. doi: 10.1016/j.arr.2022.101758

Table 1.

Characteristics of Included studies of pharmacological treatments (donepezil, galantamine, and memantine) for dementia severity and global function.

Study Sample and setting Outcomes Treatment Follow-up time points
Black 2007 n = 343 (F=241; M=102)
Mean age: 78.0; Mean MMSE: 7.45
Diagnosis: AD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    SIB

  • 2.

    CIBIC-Plus

Secondary outcomes
  • 3.

    MMSE

  • 4.

    ADCS-ADL-sev

  • 5.

    NPI

  • 6.

    CBQ

  • 7.

    RUSP

Donepezil 10 mg/day
(n=176)
Placebo
(n=167)
  • -

    8, 16, and 24 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    MMSE ≤ 12

  • 2.

    FAST ≥ 6

  • 3.

    Modified HIS ≤ 6

  • 4.

    Carer with contact ≥ 4 hours per day

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE ≤ 12 and FAST score ≥ 6
Community
  • -

    98 centers in USA, Canada, France, UK, & Australia

Burns 2009 (SERAD study) n = 407 (F=329; M=78)
Mean age: 83.6; Mean MMSE: 8.95
Diagnosis: AD and AD with CVD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    SIB

  • 2.

    MDS-ADL (7 items)

Secondary outcomes
  • 3.

    Sub items of SIB

  • 4.

    MDS-ADL (11-items)

Galantamine 24 mg/day
(n=207)
Placebo
(n=200)
  • -

    8, 12, and 26 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    MMSE 5-12

  • 2.

    History of cognitive decline

  • 3.

    CT/MRI scan 3 years before enrolment

  • 4.

    Sufficient vision & hearing

  • 5.

    Resident for ≥ 6 months

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE 5-12
57 Nursing homes
  • -

    10 European countries

Feldman 2005 (MSAD study) n = 145 (F=86; M=59)
Mean age: 73; Mean MMSE: 8.94
Diagnosis: AD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    CIBIC-Plus

Secondary outcomes
  • 2.

    sMMSE

  • 3.

    SIB

  • 4.

    DAD

  • 5.

    IADL

  • 6.

    PSMS

  • 7.

    NPI

Donepezil 10 mg/day
(n = 72)
Placebo
(n = 73)
  • -

    4, 8, 12, 18, and 24 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    FAST ≥ 6

  • 2.

    MMSE 5-12

  • 3.

    Available carer

Definition of severe dementia:
sMMSE 5-12
Community/assisted living facilities
  • -

    Canada, Australia, & France

Hannestad 2021 n = 26 (F=16; M=10)
Mean age= 73.5; Mean MMSE: 5.4
Diagnosis: AD
Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    Aged 65-90 years

  • 2.

    MMSE ≤ 10

Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    MMSE

  • 2.

    SIB

  • 3.

    ADCS-ADL-sev

  • 4.

    NPI

GRF6019 intravenous infusions of 250 mL IV over 5 days
(n=18)
Placebo
(n=8)
  • -

    9 weeks (primary endpoint)

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE 0 -10
Community and 4 nursing homes/ long-term care facilities
  • -

    United States

Homma 2008b n = 302 (F=245; M=57)
Mean age: 78.2; Mean MMSE: 7.76
Diagnosis: AD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    SIB

  • 2.

    CIBIC-Plus

Secondary outcomes
  • 3.

    ADCS-ADL-sev

  • 4.

    BEHAVE-AD

Donepezil 5 mg/day
(n = 101)
Donepezil 10 mg/day
(n =96)
Placebo
(n = 105)
  • -

    24 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    Aged ≥ 50 years

  • 2.

    HIS ≤ 6

  • 3.

    FAST ≥ 6

  • 4.

    MMSE 1-12

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE 1-12 and FAST score ≥ 6
Community
  • -

    Japan

Jia 2017 n = 313 (F=266; M=110)
Mean age: 70.8; Mean MMSE: 7.3
Diagnosis: AD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    SIB

Secondary outcomes
  • 2.

    CIBIC-Plus

  • 3.

    MMSE

Donepezil 10 mg/day
(n=157)
Placebo
(n=156)
  • -

    24 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    Aged 50-90 years

  • 2.

    SIB 10 – 90

  • 3.

    MMSE 1-12

  • 4.

    Carer with contact ≥ 4 hours per day

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE 1-12 and SIB scores of 10 – 90
Hospitals
  • -

    China

Reisberg 2003ª n = 252 (F=170; M=82)
Mean age: 76.1; Mean MMSE: 7.9
Diagnosis: AD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    GCI-C

  • 2.

    ADCS-ADLsev

Secondary outcomes
  • 3.

    SIB

  • 4.

    MMSE

  • 5.

    FAST

  • 6.

    GDS

  • 7.

    NPI

Memantine 20mg
(n=126)
Placebo
(n=126)
  • -

    12, and 28 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    Aged ≥ 50 years

  • 2.

    GDS 5 or 6

  • 3.

    MMSE 3-14

  • 4.

    FAST ≥ 6

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE 1-10
Community
  • -

    32 centers, USA

Winblad 1999 n = 166 (F=96; M=70)
Mean age: 68.4; Mean MMSE: 6.3
Diagnosis: Dementia (not further specified)
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    GCI-C

  • 2.

    BGP

Secondary outcomes
  • 3.

    Ferm’s D-test

Memantine 10mg
(n=82)
Placebo
(n=84)
  • -

    12 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    Aged 60-80 years

  • 2.

    GDS 5-7

  • 3.

    MMSE <10

  • 4.

    Dementia duration > 12 months

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE <10 and GDS score 5-7
1 psychiatric hospital and 6 nursing homes
  • -

    Latvia

Winblad 2006 n = 248 (F=190; M=58)
Mean age: 84.9; Mean MMSE: 6.1
Diagnosis: AD
Primary outcomes
  • 1.

    SIB

  • 2.

    ADCS-ADL-sev

Secondary outcomes
  • 3.

    GCI-C

  • 4.

    MMSE

  • 5.

    NPI

Donepezil 10 mg/day
(n=128)
Placebo
(n=120)
  • -

    12, and 24 weeks (primary endpoint)

Inclusion criteria:
  • 1.

    Aged ≥ 50 years

  • 2.

    Ability to walk alone

  • 3.

    FAST 5-7c

  • 4.

    MMSE 1-10

Definition of severe dementia:
MMSE 1 -10 and FAST score 5-7c
50 nursing homes
  • -

    Sweden

Note: MMSE: Mini-Mental State Examination; FAST: Functional Assessment Staging; HIS: Hachinski Ischemic Score; SIB: Severe Impairment Battery; CIBIC-Plus: Clinician’s Interview-Based Impression of Change-Plus; ADCS-ADL-sev: Alzheimer's Disease Cooperative Study-Activities of Daily Living inventory modified for Severe Patients; NPI: Neuropsychiatric Inventory; CBQ: Caregiver Burden Questionnaire; RUSP: Resources Utilisation for Severe Alzheimer's Disease; CVD: Cerebrovascular disease; MDS-ADL: Minimum Data Set Activities of Daily Living; sMMSE: Severe Mini-Mental State Examination; DAD: Disability Assessment for Dementia; IADL: Instrumental Activities of Daily Living; PSMS: Physical Self-Maintenance Scale; BEHAVE-AD: Behavioral pathology in Alzheimer's disease; GDS: Global Deterioration Scale; GCI-C: Clinical Global Impression of Change; BGP: Behavioral Rating Scale for Geriatric Patients

ªData in people with severe dementia are reported but are not extractable from the primary paper

bData extracted were based on the safety population as reported in the original paper