Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 5;9(10):e20687. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e20687

Table 1.

Candidate indicators for evaluating the quality of English language teaching.

Major Indicator Minor indicator ID
Teaching Plan Proper and Scientific Instruction I1,1
Timely Presentation of Materials in Sessions I1,2
Prioritizing Topics and Adhering to the Syllabus I1,3
Referring to the Curriculum in Classes I1,4
Teaching Behavior Ability to Maintain Order I2,1
Mastery in Presenting Materials I2,2
Responding to Questions Raised in Sessions I2,3
Rate of English Language Use During Instruction I2,4
Avoidance of Tangential Issues During Instruction I2,5
Sustained Interaction Between Instructor and Learner I2,6
Teaching Environment Continued Interaction Outside the Classroom Through Online Tools I3,1
Use of Instructional Aids to Enhance Teaching I3,2
Instructor's Attention to (LSRW) Skills in Class I3,3
Standard Deviation of Students' Ages in the Class I3,4
Male-to-Female Ratio Among Learners I3,5
Availability of a Platform for Questions and Answers After Class I3,6
Teaching Tools Precise Instructor Responses to Questions Raised in Class I4,1
Teaching Based on Concrete Examples and Understandable Scenarios I4,2
Efforts to Improve Learners' LSRW Skills I4,3
Teaching Based on Surface-to-Deep Level Strategies I4,4
Class Performance Learner Participation Rate in Answering During Instruction I5,1
Response Rate to Questions by Learners in Sessions I5,2
Rate of English-to-Native Language Conversations by Learners I5,3
Learner Participation Rate in Instructional Discussions I5,4