Table 1.
Therapeutic mechanism & application | siRNA | mRNA | tRNA | tRF |
Mechanism of action | Targets specific RNAs for degradation | Provides a functional mRNA | Functionally corrects/recodes endogenous mutation | Generally regulates biological pathways |
Control of target gene expression | Fully leverages endogenous control pathways | Encodes in the exogenous mRNA | Fully leverages endogenous control pathways | Fully leverages endogenous control pathways |
Addressable patient population for each medicine | Each disease target requires full development | Each disease target requires full development | Addresses entire class of mutations independent of nature of gene/protein | Depends on biological application |
Specifications | siRNA | mRNA | tRNA | tRF |
Drug substance/RNA optimization | Full scope of combinatorial sequence and modification exploration optimizes drug properties∗ | Primary sequence and higher order structure design restricts encoded protein sequence and translationally competent modifications | Full scope of combinatorial sequence and modification exploration optimizes drug properties | Full scope of combinatorial sequence and modification exploration optimizes drug properties∗ |
Size | Small (<25 nucleotides for single strand) | Hundreds to thousands of nucleotides | Relatively small (<100 nucleotides) | Small (<40 nucleotides) |
Synthesis | Chemical | Enzymatic | Chemical Enzymatic |
Chemical Enzymatic |
Delivery | Nanoparticle Viral Conjugation | Nanoparticle Viral | Nanoparticle Viral Conjugation |
Nanoparticle Viral Conjugation |
A comparison of the molecular mechanisms of action, addressable patient population, and modality design and delivery parameters across RNA modalities, namely siRNA, mRNA, tRNA, and tRFs.
With restrictions based on complementarity to target.