Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Jan 12.
Published in final edited form as: J Comput Graph Stat. 2023 Jan 12;32(3):1131–1144. doi: 10.1080/10618600.2022.2149540

Table 4.

Comparison of mean (sd) of ARI and CSA in 100 replicates between clusterMLD and funHDDC.

ARI CSA
Uniform Normal Uniform Normal
η = 3 η = 6 η = 3 η = 6 η = 3 η = 6 η = 3 η = 6
clusterMLD (Gapb)
N=200
S0 0.924(0.110) 0.934(0.098) 0.935(0.086) 0.886(0.084) 0.990(0.009) 0.988(0.007) 0.986(0.009) 0.968(0.014)
S1 0.954(0.076) 0.967(0.031) 0.944(0.086) 0.883(0.086) 0.984(0.047) 0.993(0.006) 0.989(0.007) 0.950(0.071)
S2 0.901(0.179) 0.893(0.178) 0.948(0.06) 0.876(0.123) 0.991(0.008) 0.980(0.059) 0.989(0.008) 0.970(0.014)
N=400
S0 0.980(0.030) 0.972(0.049) 0.971(0.043) 0.917(0.053) 0.993(0.004) 0.992(0.004) 0.991(0.006) 0.972(0.011)
S1 0.981(0.017) 0.98(0.045) 0.976(0.022) 0.928(0.048) 0.994(0.005) 0.990(0.041) 0.993(0.005) 0.972(0.036)
S2 0.939(0.129) 0.959(0.086) 0.971(0.020) 0.918(0.053) 0.993(0.009) 0.993(0.005) 0.991(0.005) 0.977(0.008)
clusterMLD (CH)
N=200
S0 0.839(0.210) 0.773(0.216) 0.633(0.206) 0.429(0.072) 0.991(0.008) 0.989(0.007) 0.988(0.009) −(−)
S1 0.751(0.202) 0.707(0.196) 0.609(0.148) 0.550(0.088) −(−) −(−) −(−) −(−)
S2 0.711(0.215) 0.753(0.184) 0.781(0.161) 0.738(0.130) 0.918(0.148) 0.902(0.175) 0.861(0.193) 0.971(0.024)
N=400
S0 0.919(0.166) 0.857(0.212) 0.656(0.176) 0.440(0.063) 0.993(0.004) 0.993(0.004) 0.994(0.005) −(−)
S1 0.717(0.198) 0.679(0.189) 0.599(0.131) 0.545(0.052) −(−) −(−) −(−) −(−)
S2 0.791(0.188) 0.801(0.181) 0.835(0.146) 0.741(0.107) 0.991(0.019) 0.992(0.003) 0.923(0.173) −(−)
funHDC
N=200
S0 0.483(0.068) 0.479(0.067) 0.498(0.077) 0.465(0.067) −(−) −(−) −(−) −(−)
S1 0.458(0.186) 0.505(0.178) 0.446(0.167) 0.432(0.113) 0.854(0.058) 0.876(0.059) 0.842(0.064) 0.837(0.072)
S2 0.419(0.213) 0.400(0.217) 0.399(0.200) 0.347(0.182) 0.519(0.034) 0.509(0.035) 0.498(0.038) 0.499(0.045)
N=400
S0 0.488(0.059) 0.499(0.071) 0.488(0.062) 0.463(0.059) −(−) 0.625(0.025) −(−) −(−)
S1 0.457(0.140) 0.459(0.152) 0.445(0.138) 0.390(0.096) 0.878(0.057) 0.919(0.030) 0.917(0.026) 0.916(0.027)
S2 0.360(0.201) 0.370(0.189) 0.342(0.176) 0.321(0.198) 0.512(0.040) 0.492(0.028) 0.500(0.035) 0.486(0.024)

Note: CSA was only reported when there were at least two cases in 100 repetitions that resulted in K^=4.