Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 3;8(41):37991–38004. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.3c03484

Table 7. Efficacy of Different Treatments: A Comparative Analysis of the Efficacy of Different Treatments for the Successful Penaeus vannamei Culture in Inland Saline Watera.

parameters treatments attained value during the experiment recommended value for the successful Penaeus vannamei culture effective treatment
pH C 8.12a ± 0.02 7.8–8.5 T1, T2, T3, and T4
T1 8.31b ± 0.05
T2 8.33b ± 0.01
T3 8.26b ± 0.05
T4 8.47c ± 0.02
calcium/magnesium ratio C 1.00:1.96 1.00:3.00 T2, T3, and T4
T1 1.00:2.65
T2 1.00:3.85
T3 1.00:3.12
T4 1.00:4.12
potassium C 74.20a ± 0.46 for comparable survival at least greater than 76% of that in marine water. Actual requirement for 10 ppt water is 97.2 ppm T1, T2, T3, and T4 highest in T2
T1 88.68c ± 0.55
T2 101.10e ± 1.55
T3 85.81b ± 0.24
T4 96.58d ± 0.60
ammonium nitrogen C 1.72c ± 0.01 less than 1.00 ppm T1, T2, T3, and T4
T1 0.21a ± 0.00
T2 0.25a ± 0.01
T3 0.99b ± 0.01
T4 0.98b ± 0.03
specific growth rate (SGR) % day–1 of Penaeus vannamei C 2.23a ± 0.01   highest in T2
T1 2.29ab ± 0.02
T2 2.38b ± 0.05
T3 2.28a ± 0.02
T4 2.38b ± 0.01
weight gain percentage of Penaeus vannamei C 173.23a ± 0.73   highest in T2
T1 180.73ab ± 2.89
T2 191.75b ± 6.82
T3 178.54a ± 2.17
T4 191.70b ± 1.39
survival percentage of Penaeus vannamei C 72.5a ± 5.2   highest in T3
T1 86.3ab ± 7.1
T2 86.3ab ± 2.0
T3 96.1b ± 2.0
T4 84.3ab ± 2.0
a

Mean values (mean ± S.E.) in each column not sharing a common superscript are significantly different (P < 0.05). One-way ANOVA was used following Duncan’s multiple range test in SPSS-26.0. Control: no biochar; T1: paddy straw biochar (PSB) application in sediment; T2: sediment amended with KOH-activated PSB; T3: sugar cane bagasse biochar (SBB) application in sediment; T4: sediment amended with KOH-activated SBB.