Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 5;8(41):37685–37719. doi: 10.1021/acsomega.3c05285

Table 4. Literature Review for Sputtering Techniques.

    Physical parameters
                     
Material Type Temperature Pressure Crystal Structure Morphology Configuration Electrolyte Type PW SC ED PD Capacitive retention @ cycles Ref
RuO2 DC reactive   5 × 10–3 Torr Amorphous Smooth surface Solid state LixPOyNz Symmetric 0 to 2 656.57 F/g @     53% @ 500 (120)
MoO3 Magnetron   2 × 10–5 mbar Crystalline Nanocluster Liquid state (3 electrodes) 1 M Na2SO4   –1.0 to 1.0 70 F/g @ 10 mV/s     82% @ 1000 (121)
Graphene Magnetron 620 °C   Hexagonal Crumpled and folded   PVA-H3PO4 Symmetric 0 to 1.0 325 F/g @ 1 mV/s 13.9 Wh/kg 50 kW/kg 100% @ 5000 (122)
ZnO/CNT Reactive magnetron   2 × 10–5 mbar Crystalline Macroporous Liquid state (2 electrodes) 0.1 M TBAPC/DMF Symmetric –2.0 to 1.0 59 F/g @ 5 mV/s 13.1 Wh/kg 3.0 W/kg   (123)
CrN Reactive DC magnetron   3.5 Pa FCC Wormlike Liquid state (2 electrodes) 0.5 M H2SO4 Symmetric 0 to 0.8 6.5 mF/cm2 @ 1 mA/cm2 8.2 mWh/cm3 0.7 W/cm3 90% @ 20000 (124)
TiO2/FMWCNT Reactive magnetron   2 × 10–5 mbar   Nanoparticles Liquid state (2 electrodes) 0.5 M Na2SO4 Symmetric –1 to 1 110 F/g @ 5 mV/s     70% @ 500 (125)
Graphene Magnetron   3.0 Pa   Fluffy and corrugated Liquid state (3 electrodes) 6 M KOH   0.1 to 0.6 122 F/g @ 1 A/g     99% @ 1000 (126)
CuO Reactive RF magnetron   10–2 Torr Monoclinic Granular, porous morphology Liquid state (3 electrodes) 6 M KOH   0 to 0.5 272 F/g @ 5 mV/s     85% @ 3000 (127)
CuO2 Reactive RF magnetron   10–2 Torr Cubic Granular, porous morphology Liquid state (3 electrodes) 6 M KOH   0 to 0.5 215 F/g @ 5 mV/s     80% @ 3000 (127)
MnO2 DC magnetron   3 × 10–2 Torr Tetragonal Nanorods Liquid state (2 electrodes) 1 M Na2SO4 Symmetric 0 to 0.8 203 F/g @ 2 mV/s 4.2 Wh/kg 151 W/kg 89.83% @ 5000 (128)
Mo2N Reactive DC magnetron     FCC Spinous shape Liquid state (3 electrodes) 0.5 M Li2SO4   0.005 to 0.85 722 F/cm3 @ 5 mV/s     100% @ 2000 (129)
TiC   750 °C 10–2 mbar FCC   Liquid state (3 electrodes) 1 M H2SO4   –0.6 to 0.3 103 mF/cm2       (130)
TiN Reactive magnetron   2 Pa FCC   Liquid state (2 electrodes) 0.5 M H2SO4 Symmetric 0 to 0.8 27.3 mF/cm2 @ 1 mA/cm2 17.6 mWh/cm3 10.8 W/cm3 98.2% @ 20000 (131)
MoS2 DC magnetron 300 °C 5 × 10–3 Torr Hexagonal Nanoworms Liquid state (3 electrodes) 1 M Na2SO4   –0.2 to 0.6 138 F/g @ 1 A/g 12.26 Wh/kg 7.98 kW/kg 86% @ 5000 (132)
CrN Reactive DC magnetron 300 °C 3 × 10–2 Torr Cubic Columnar platelet Liquid state (3 electrodes) 1 M Na2SO4   0.0 to 1.2 41.6 F/g @ 5 mV/s     87% @ 2000 (133)
VN   450 °C 5 × 10–3 mbar Cubic Columnar Liquid state (2 electrodes) 1 M KOH Symmetric –1 to −0.4 40 mF/cm2 @ 9.5 mA/cm2 2 μWh/cm2 10 mW/cm2 80% @ 3000 (134)
W2N Reactive   10–2 Torr FCC Spherical grain Liquid state (2 electrodes) 1 M H2SO4 Symmetric 0 to 1.1 163 F/g @ 0.5 mA/cm2 9.36 Wh/kg 674 kW/kg 90.46% @ 10000 (135)
W2N Reactive magnetron   2.5 × 102 mbar Cubic Dense Liquid state (3 electrodes) 1 M KOH   –1.0 to −0.4 550 mF/cm2 @ 2 mV/s     100% @ 1600 (100)
Mn/MnOx @ graphite Reactive     Amorphous Needle-like Solid state Polypropylene carbonate Symmetric 0 to 2.2 11.71 mF/cm2 @ 0.03 mA/cm2 7.87 mWh/cm2 36.65 mW/cm2   (7)
Ag/NiCoP Magnetron   0.25 Pa Hexagonal Nanosheets Solid state PVA-KOH Symmetric 0 to 1.5 6150 mF/cm2 0.254 mWh/cm2 18.8 mW/cm2 73% @ 4000 (136)
Cu3N/MoS2 Magnetron     MoS2 (hexagonal) and Cu3N (cubic) Nanoflakes Liquid state (2 electrodes) 1 M Na2SO4   0 to 1.0 215.47 F/g @ 0.5 A/g 30 Wh/kg 138 W/kg 90% @ 2000 (137)