Table 2.
Overview and categorization of the research works surveyed.
| Article | RS | Dataset(s) | Fairness measurement | Debiasing strategy | Sensitive attribute(s) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Algorithm | Definition(s) | Metric(s) | ||||
| Li et al. (2023) | Job | CF | Private | DP | UGF | Post | Gender (G) |
| Rus et al. (2022) | Job | CBF | Private | EO, DP | TPRP, SAT | Pre, In | G |
| Ntioudis et al. (2022) | Job | KB | Synthetic, private | — | — | Pre | Migrant |
| Zhang (2021) | Job | — | Synthetic | DP | SDR, LDR | — | G |
| Shishehchi and Banihashem (2019) | Job | KB | Private | — | UAT | Pre | Disability |
| Tang et al. (2017) | Job | — | Scraped | — | MWU | — | G |
| Scher et al. (2023) | Candidate | — | Synthetic | EO, DP | BGSD, CF, TNR | Post | — |
| Jourdan et al. (2023) | Candidate | CBF | BIOS | EO | TPRP | Pre, In | G |
| Delecraz et al. (2022) | Candidate | — | Private | EO | TPRP, DI, SP | — | Multi |
| Markert et al. (2022) | Candidate | CBF | Synthetic | IF | IFC | — | G, Marital status |
| Bei et al. (2020) | Candidate | Other | Synthetic | PF | Violations | Post | G, Region |
| Arafan et al. (2022) | Candidate | — | Synthetic, Private | DP | NDKL | Pre, Post | G |
| Tran et al. (2022) | Candidate | KB | ACI, TO, HR | — | — | Post | Disability |
| Syed and Shivendu (2022) | Candidate | — | — | EO, DP | TPRP | Pre | — |
| Burke et al. (2021) | Candidate | Other | SIOP2021 | EO | AIR | Post | — |
| Tran et al. (2021) | Candidate | KB | Synthetic, Private | — | — | Post | Disability |
| Wilson et al. (2021) | Candidate | — | Private | EO, DP | AIR, MWU, KWH | — | G, Ethnicity |
| Elbassuoni et al. (2020) | Candidate | — | Synthetic, Private | DP | EMD | — | G, Ethnicity |
| Elbassuoni et al. (2019) | Candidate | — | Private | DP | EMD | — | Multi |
| Geyik et al. (2019) | Candidate | — | Synthetic, Private | EO, DP | NDKL, MS, II, IC | Post | G, Age |
| Chen et al. (2018) | Candidate | — | Scraped | DP, IF | MWU, TDRC, EC | — | G |
| Amer-Yahia et al. (2020) | Both | — | Synthetic, Private | DP | KT, EMD, Exposure | — | G, Ethnicity, Nationality |
In RS Type, “Both” is used when both job recommender and candidate recommender are used, and for Sensitive Attribute(s), “Multi” is used when there are four or more attributes (e.g., Gender, Nationality, Age, Ethnicity, Language). The symbol “—” is used when the column is not applicable or cannot be inferred from the paper.