Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 6;14:1228641. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2023.1228641

TABLE 3.

Results of the prediction-based metrics with or without prior observation.

Models Without prior observation With one prior observation
MDPE MAPE F20 F30 MDIPE MAIPE IF20 IF30
Serrano et al. (1999) 1.40 17.38 55.69 76.47 −2.62 9.46 71.70 90.57
Desoky et al. (2004) 11.25 24.28 43.53 57.25 0.47 10.64 69.81 83.02
Jiang et al. (2007) 66.84 66.84 12.94 20.39 10.98 12.07 66.04 81.13
Correa et al. (2008) 9.37 21.03 49.02 67.06 3.32 12.06 73.58 86.79
Williams et al. (2012) −25.92 27.70 31.76 54.51 −19.61 19.61 52.83 77.36
Ogusu et al. (2014) 8.84 19.90 50.20 68.63 −2.23 11.11 71.70 84.91
Ding et al. (2015) 30.24 32.14 34.51 47.06 9.24 17.14 64.15 88.68
Rodrigues et al. (2018) 26.13 29.36 36.08 50.98 −5.02 13.39 71.70 100
Gu et al. (2021) 4.35 18.74 51.76 67.06 −7.61 14.56 62.26 79.25
Teixeira-da-Silva et al. (2022) 1.34 19.80 50.20 67.06 −14.20 15.83 56.60 81.13
Impact of protein binding modeling strategy
One-binding site model 3.48 19.38 51.37 68.24 −3.05 16.29 61.70 85.11
Langmuir equation 0.82 20.49 47.84 67.45 −1.73 4.06 97.87 100
Dose-dependent maximum effect model −1.10 27.67 39.61 52.94 −4.43 5.47 97.87 97.87
Linear non-saturable binding equation −0.19 19.8 50.20 72.16 −2.51 5.51 97.87 100
The simple exponent model 1.50 17.68 56.47 72.94 −2.79 6.47 97.87 97.87

F 20 , F 30 , the percentages of prediction error within 20% and 30%, respectively; MAPE, median absolute prediction error; MDPE, median prediction error; IF 20 , IF 30 , the percentages of individual prediction error within 20% and 30%, respectively; MAIPE, median absolute individual prediction error; MDIPE, median individual prediction error.