Table 2.
Ref | Detection | Task | Data set | Accuracy | Sensitivity | Specificity |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kuresan et al. [45] | Speech signals | MFCC + WPT with HMM | 40 subjects | 95.16% | 93.55% | 91.67% |
Gürüler [54] | Speech signals |
KMCFW – CVANN tenfold CV |
23 PD,8 HC | 99.52% | – | – |
Benba [55] | Speech data | SVM-linear kernel | 17 PD,17 HC | 91.17% | – | – |
Devarajan et al. [49] | Speech disorder | Fog and FKNN-CBR | 23 PD, 8 HC | 94.87% | 97.28% | 87.50% |
Karaman et al. [48] | Speech signals | DenseNet 161 | mPower Voice database | 89.75% | 91.50% | – |
Senturk [58] | Speech signals | SVM | 23 PD, 8 HC | 93.84% | – | – |
Vikas [63] | Speech signals | Gradient Boosting (Ensemble Approach) | 147 PD, 48 HC | 97.43% | – | – |
Ouhmida [66] | Speech signals | KNN | 40 PD, 40 HC | 97.22% | 100% | 94.44% |
Thakur et al. [84] | Handwriting dynamics | RBM + MLP | 62 PD, 15 HC | 95.32% | – | – |
Drotár et al. [74] | Handwriting dynamics |
Mann–Whitney U Test. SVM along with tenfold CV |
37 PD, 38 HC | 81.3% | 87.4% | 80.9% |
Naseer A et al. [76] | Handwriting dynamics | AlexNet | 37 PD, 38 HC | 98.28% | – | – |
Gil-Martín et al. [69] | Handwriting dynamics | CNN architecture | 62 PD, 15 HC | 96.5% | – | – |
Kurt [78] | Handwriting dynamics | SVM (Static Spiral test) | 57 PD, 15 HC | 97.52% | – | – |
Kotsavaloglou [80] | Handwriting dynamics | Naïve Bayes | 24 PD, 20 HC | 91% | 88% | 95% |
Saravanan [83] | Handwriting dynamics | VGG19-Inception Model | 175 PD, 192 HC | 98.45% | – | – |
Kamran [85] | Handwriting dynamics | AlexNet (Fine Tuned) | HandPD, NewHandPD, Parkinson’s Drawing | 99.22% | – | – |
El Maachi et al. [96] | Gait movements | Deep 1D convnet | 93 PD, 73 HC | 98.7% | 98.1% | 100% |
Balaji et al. [89] | Gait movements |
Adam-LSTM (1) multi class (2) binary |
PhysioNet |
(1) 96.6% (2) 98.6% |
(1) 96.20 (2) 98.23 |
(1) 98.08 (2) 99.10 |
Richa [95] | Gait movements | Modified KNN | 93 PD, 73 HC | 99.60% | – | – |
Tong et al. [87] | Gait movements | PVI, persistent entropy of topological imprints, SVM, RF, Borderline-SMOTE | 29 PD, 18 HC | 98.08% | – | – |