Table 2.
Simulation results of AVOA, DBO, GTO, GWO, HHO and PBSO, to .
| Function | Data tpye | AVOA | DBO | GTO | GWO | HHO | PBSO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Mean | 4.170E+01 | 6.806E+01 | 7.445E+01 | 2.586E+01 | 7.577E+01 | 3.839E+01 |
| STD | 4.373E+00 | 9.030E+00 | 1.479E+01 | 4.981E+00 | 3.419E+00 | 8.915E+00 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 3 | 4 | 5 | 1 | 6 | 2 | |
| 7 | Mean | 2.123E+03 | 1.521E+03 | 1.745E+03 | 1.022E+03 | 2.730E+03 | 7.912E+02 |
| STD | 1.690E+02 | 3.473E+02 | 2.712E+02 | 1.131E+02 | 1.220E+02 | 1.367E+02 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 5 | 3 | 4 | 2 | 6 | 1 | |
| 8 | Mean | 8.978E+02 | 1.158E+03 | 8.368E+02 | 5.404E+02 | 1.037E+03 | 7.330E+02 |
| STD | 8.606E+01 | 1.868E+02 | 1.680E+02 | 6.259E+01 | 7.166E+01 | 1.527E+02 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 4 | 6 | 3 | 1 | 5 | 2 | |
| 9 | Mean | 2.177E+04 | 3.655E+04 | 5.218E+04 | 2.088E+04 | 2.932E+04 | 2.887E+04 |
| STD | 1.385E+03 | 1.019E+04 | 2.116E+04 | 9.788E+03 | 3.416E+03 | 9.101E+03 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 2 | 5 | 6 | 1 | 4 | 3 | |
| 10 | Mean | 1.523E+04 | 1.711E+04 | 2.656E+04 | 1.339E+04 | 1.745E+04 | 1.641E+04 |
| STD | 1.747E+03 | 2.183E+03 | 6.264E+03 | 1.336E+03 | 1.580E+03 | 5.769E+03 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 2 | 4 | 6 | 1 | 5 | 3 | |
| 11 | Mean | 1.241E+03 | 1.100E+04 | 9.393E+04 | 3.726E+04 | 1.923E+03 | 4.984E+02 |
| STD | 2.125E+02 | 1.175E+04 | 1.453E+05 | 9.118E+03 | 2.395E+02 | 1.800E+02 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 2 | 4 | 6 | 5 | 3 | 1 | |
| 12 | Mean | 1.129E+07 | 4.880E+08 | 3.921E+08 | 4.746E+09 | 2.729E+08 | 9.332E+06 |
| STD | 4.803E+06 | 2.824E+08 | 1.840E+08 | 2.502E+09 | 6.969E+07 | 3.408E+06 | |
| Best | 2.622E+00 | 7.918E+05 | 6.702E+08 | 1.511E+10 | 1.483E+08 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 3.062E+04 | 1.658E+08 | 6.911E+09 | 4.236E+10 | 2.589E+08 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 2 | 5 | 4 | 6 | 3 | 1 |