Table 7.
Simulation results of BBPSO, DLSBBPSO, ETBBPSO, PBBPSO, TBBPSO and PBSO, to .
| Function | Data type | BBPSO | DLSBBPSO | ETBBPSO | PBBPSO | TBBPSO | PBSO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7 | Mean | 9.389E+02 | 8.513E+02 | 8.577E+02 | 8.988E+02 | 9.100E+02 | 7.912E+02 |
| STD | 1.910E+02 | 1.493E+02 | 1.266E+02 | 1.514E+02 | 1.313E+02 | 1.367E+02 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 6 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 1 | |
| 8 | Mean | 8.538E+02 | 7.789E+02 | 9.109E+02 | 9.793E+02 | 9.552E+02 | 7.330E+02 |
| STD | 1.678E+02 | 1.646E+02 | 1.674E+02 | 2.023E+02 | 1.655E+02 | 1.527E+02 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 3 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 5 | 1 | |
| 9 | Mean | 3.614E+04 | 3.030E+04 | 3.635E+04 | 4.016E+04 | 3.904E+04 | 2.887E+04 |
| STD | 6.494E+03 | 1.476E+04 | 1.451E+04 | 1.223E+04 | 1.155E+04 | 9.101E+03 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 3 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 5 | 1 | |
| 10 | Mean | 2.349E+04 | 3.019E+04 | 2.166E+04 | 3.136E+04 | 2.467E+04 | 1.641E+04 |
| STD | 9.064E+03 | 5.276E+03 | 8.357E+03 | 4.805E+03 | 5.289E+03 | 5.769E+03 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 3 | 5 | 2 | 6 | 4 | 1 | |
| 11 | Mean | 1.622E+03 | 6.155E+03 | 4.106E+03 | 6.668E+03 | 4.737E+03 | 4.984E+02 |
| STD | 3.266E+03 | 7.188E+03 | 3.390E+03 | 7.626E+03 | 5.101E+03 | 1.800E+02 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 2 | 5 | 3 | 6 | 4 | 1 | |
| 12 | Mean | 5.514E+07 | 6.026E+07 | 6.148E+07 | 6.217E+07 | 4.700E+07 | 9.332E+06 |
| STD | 2.463E+07 | 3.261E+07 | 2.723E+07 | 2.755E+07 | 2.981E+07 | 3.408E+06 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 2 | 1 | |
| 13 | Mean | 1.119E+04 | 1.124E+04 | 1.062E+04 | 7.701E+03 | 1.501E+04 | 9.243E+03 |
| STD | 1.324E+04 | 1.351E+04 | 1.586E+04 | 9.208E+03 | 1.881E+04 | 1.123E+04 | |
| Best | 6.060E−02 | 2.048E+00 | 6.230E+02 | 2.932E+01 | 2.250E+02 | 1.552E−01 | |
| Worst | 5.915E+04 | 5.297E+04 | 1.256E+05 | 5.966E+04 | 1.359E+05 | 9.351E+04 | |
| Rank | 4 | 5 | 3 | 1 | 6 | 2 |