mRNA
|
Synthetic, non-infectious, and free from cellular or egg proteins. |
Sensitive to pH and degradation by enzymes. |
[71,123,124] |
Short development and manufacturing time. |
Inability to penetrate mucus barriers. |
Produces high systemic antibody titers. |
Adjuvants are required to break mucosal immune tolerance. |
Transient expression. |
Poor mucosal immune response. |
Cannot modify host genome. |
Ultra-low cold chain required for storage. |
Protein Subunit
|
Can be lyophilized for good environmental stability. |
High antigen requirement. |
[71,123] |
Can be used regardless of age or immunocompromised status |
Sensitive to pH and degradation by enzymes. |
Cannot modify host genome. |
Inability to penetrate mucus barriers. |
|
Adjuvants are required to break mucosal immune tolerance. |
|
Poor mucosal immune response. |
|
Complex manufacturing requirements (conjugation chemistry). |
|
Difficult to isolate the most relevant antigens. |
Live Viral
|
Well-established technology. Better stability than mRNA vaccines. |
Complex manufacturing and safety requirements. |
[71,123,125] |
Naturally capable of penetrating mucus barriers, tolerating high/low pH, and infecting target cells. |
Cannot be given to immunocompromised patients. |
Induces strong mucosal and systemic immune responses. |
Small chance of reverting to a pathogenic form and causing disease. |
May not need adjuvants |
Takes time to develop. |
Simple to manufacture. |
|
Viral Vector
|
Induces strong mucosal and systemic immune responses. |
Concerns for host genome modification/integration. |
[71,123,126] |
Naturally capable of penetrating mucus barriers, tolerating high/low pH, and infecting target cells. |
Complex manufacturing and safety requirements. |
May not need adjuvants. Better stability than mRNA vaccines. |
Response reduced due to pre-existing immunity against the vector. |
Simple to manufacture. |
Takes time to develop. |
Cannot cause diseases like live attenuated viruses. |
|