Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 29;15(10):e47919. doi: 10.7759/cureus.47919

Table 2. Study characteristics of the included studies.

HA: hyaluronic acid; HHS: Harris hip score; HMW: high molecular weight; Lp PRP: leukocyte poor PRP; LMW: low molecular weight; Na: sodium; NR: not reported; OARSI: Osteoarthritis Research Society International; PRP: platelet-rich plasma; RCT: randomized controlled trial; VAS: visual analog scale; WOMAC: Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Arthritis Index

Authors Country Study design Number of participants Average age (years) Intervention Duration Outcomes measured
Dallari et al. [21] Italy RCT 80 (PRP = 44, HA = 36) NR Autologous PRP (5 mL) versus HA (30 mg/2 mL) 12 months Therapeutic efficacy of autologous PRP; therapeutic efficacy of HA
Di Sante et al. [22] Italy RCT 43 (PRP = 21, HA = 22) PRP = 71.37±6.03, HA = 73.62±7.87 Na-HA (30 mg/2 mL) versus PRP (3 mL) 16 weeks Pain reduction was measured by VAS; pain reduction was measured by WOMAC pain scale
Kraeutler et al. [24] USA Double-blind, randomized pilot study 31 (PRP = 18, HA = 13) PRP = 53.3±8.4, HA = 53.6±7.6 Lp PRP (1-2 mL) versus LMW HA (2.5 mL) 12 weeks Efficacy of intra-articular injection of Lp PRP; efficacy of intra-articular injections of LMW HA
Villanova-López et al. [26] Spain Phase III double-blinded, controlled trial 74 (PRP = 38, HA = 36) PRP = 61.2±9.72, HA = 61.1±12.3 PRP (6 mL) versus HA (60 mg/6 mL) 12 months Pain was assessed using VAS score; HHS score was used as functional score; WOMAC score was used as functional score; analgesia, adverse events, cellular components in peripheral blood, cellular components in PRP, and clinical response were assessed using OARSI criteria
Nouri et al. [25] Iran RCT with three parallel groups 70 (PRP = 35, HA = 35) PRP = 58.22±5.10, HA = 60.93±4.54 PRP 5 mL versus HMW HA 50 mg/2.5 mL Two injections within two weeks' interval VAS; WOMAC; Lequesne questionnaire
Doria et al. [23] Italy Prospective double-blinded RCT 80 (PRP = 40, HA = 40) PRP = 67.3±5.8, HA = 68±4.6 PRP 5 mL versus HA (15 mg/mL) 12 weeks VAS; WOMAC
Battaglia et al. [20] Italy RCT 100 (PRP = 50, HA = 50) PRP = 51±12, HA = 56±12 Autologous PRP (5 mL) versus HMW HA (30 mg/2 mL) 12 months HHS; VAS