Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 18;10:e47186. doi: 10.2196/47186

Table 1.

Medication-assisted treatment (MAT) standards 1 to 5 mapped against telemedicine-delivered medication for opioid use disorder (TMOUD) models of care.

Scottish MAT standards and what to measure Mapping against TMOUD models of care Implications for TMOUD quality
Standard 1: same-day access

Time from first contact with any partner in the multiagency partnership within an episode of care to the commencement of MOUDa
  • TMb 1.0: inclusion health focus

  • TM 1.1: places of safety

  • TM 1.3: low threshold

  • TM 3.1: multidisciplinary and multisectoral care

Same-day access is made possible by low thresholds for treatment initiation (TM 1.3). Multidisciplinary and multisectoral care (TM 3.1) increases opportunity for people to be seen where they feel safe (TM 1.1).

Number of people started on MOUD
  • TM 1.3: low threshold

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

Higher numbers in treatment are a measure of treatment threshold (TM 1.3) and may be an outcome measure required by a service adopting TMOUD (TM 4.0).
Standard 2: choice

The number of people in treatment taking methadone or sublingual buprenorphine at the appropriate dose and with opportunities to change their choice
  • TM 1.2: trauma informed

  • TM 3.3: education and empowerment

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

  • TM 4.3: coproduced clinical pathways

Choice in treatment is a principle of trauma-informed care (TM 1.2), and people with opioid use disorder may need to be empowered to demand these choices (TM 3.3). Services need to have time and resources (TM 4.0) and appropriate clinical pathways (TM 4.3) to respond to demand.

The number of people in treatment receiving injectable buprenorphine
  • TM 1.0: inclusion health focus

  • TM 3.3: education and empowerment

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

Some groups may be excluded from being offered injectable buprenorphine (TM 1.0) or may not have knowledge of it (TM 4.0). Services must adapt to introduce injectable buprenorphine, and adopting TMOUD may increase the capacity to do so (TM 4.0).

The number of people receiving HATc
  • TM 1.0: inclusion health focus

  • TM 3.0: complexity of care needs

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

HAT is a relatively novel intervention, potentially benefiting marginalized populations (TM 1.0) with complex care needs (TM 3.0). It is a resource-heavy intervention, and TMOUD may be used to free up capacity to deliver it (TM 4.0).
Standard 3: assertive outreach and anticipatory care

Duration from when first identified as at risk to initial contact and assessment; number of people followed up with and for whom an initial assessment is performed
  • TM 2.0: transition through care

  • TM 2.1: patient journey mapping

  • TM 2.2: process mapping and risk mitigation

This measure may provide empirical data to test service understandings of the patient journey (TM 2.1) and processes that may increase or decrease risk (TM 2.2) during transitions in care (TM 2.0).

Proportion of people by age, gender, and race identified as at risk by source of risk event (service that identified and actioned the risk); identification and outcome of the intervention
  • TM 1.0: inclusion health focus

  • TM 1.1: places of safety

  • TM 2.0: transition through care

  • TM 2.2: process mapping and risk mitigation

Disaggregation of data by age, gender, race, and other characteristics measures the extent to which inclusivity is improved (TM 1.0), what services are favored by specific groups (TM 1.1), and whether risk mitigation (TM 2.2) during care transitions (TM 2.0) reaches all affected groups equally.
Standard 4: harm reduction

Proportion of MOUD services offering BBVd testing and vaccination, naloxone and overdose awareness, wound care, assessment of injecting risk and injecting equipment provision, and virtual supervised injecting services
  • TM 3.0: complexity of care needs

  • TM 3.2: flexibility to tailor interventions

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

  • TM 4.3: coproduced clinical pathways

This measure quantifies the extent to which TMOUD services the complexity of the needs of people with opioid use disorder (TM 3.0) and the extent to which it can innovate or adapt to address gaps (TM 3.2). Furthermore, services may introduce telemedicine (TM 4.0) and coproduce pathways to integrate harm reduction and MOUD provision.
Standard 5: retention

Attrition rate: number of people currently on MOUD treatment and number of people discharged within a set time by setting, age, gender, and race
  • TM 2.0: transition through care

  • TM 2.1: patient journey mapping

  • TM 2.2: process mapping and risk mitigation

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

  • TM 4.3: coproduced clinical pathways

This directly measures the service’s ability to support continuity through transitions in care (TM 2.0) and provides empirical data to test mapping and risk mitigation (TM 2.1 and 2.2). TMOUD may be adopted to improve retention in treatment (TM 4.0) through specific clinical pathways (TM 4.3).

Reason for discharge (eg, planned or unplanned)
  • TM 3.0: complexity of care needs

  • TM 3.2: flexibility to tailor interventions

  • TM 4.0: service resilience and quality

  • TM 4.2: predefined intake criteria

Services designed to meet complex needs (TM 3.0) develop interventions to match these needs (TM 3.2) and, theoretically, will have low unplanned discharges. Services introducing TMOUD to increase efficiency (TM 4.0) may set high-threshold intake criteria (TM 4.2), which excludes some groups.

aMOUD: medication for opioid use disorder.

bTM: TMOUD model.

cHAT: heroin-assisted treatment.

dBBV: blood-borne virus.