Table 2. Inclusion and exclusion criteria.
Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
---|---|
For both reviews | |
Moderate or severe wasting or edema and dehydration, by current or previous WHO definitions | No raw numbers or effect estimates reported |
Written in English, French, and Spanish | Written in other languages |
Published any time | |
For the diagnosis of dehydration review only | |
Age 0–5 years | Studies do not include report findings among individuals in this age range |
Studies that compare any clinical symptom/sign/test to named reference standard for dehydration | Does not use a relevant reference standard for dehydration. |
Includes a dehydration reference standard of at least one of: reported difference in pre-post rehydration weight, electrolyte imbalance, renal function test, metabolic acidosis, or an established criterion | Study included fewer than 5 children meeting with diarrhea and wasting |
Reported raw numbers, proportions, and/or sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value comparing signs/symptoms/test to dehydration reference standard | |
For the management of dehydration review only | |
Age 6-months to 10 years | Studies do not include report findings among individuals in this age range |
Reported proportions, OR, RR, or HR | Contains only data relevant to intravenous rehydration (e.g., shock), or cholera/profuse watery diarrhea. Or, it is impossible to disaggregate these data from the desired data. |
Comparison of ReSoMal and WHO low-osmolarity ORS | Used neither of the solutions or only of the solutions without comparison to another product. |
Reported mortality and/or adverse outcomes (including electrolyte disturbances) | Reported other outcomes excluding mortality or adverse outcomes (including electrolyte disturbances) |
*Papers that were done in a different population or reported a different outcome but have relevance to the study findings were archived and included in the formal discussion.