Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 17;21(4):385–394. doi: 10.1016/j.jesf.2023.09.002

Table 1.

Exercise protocols of the studies included in the analysis.

Sijie (2012)50
  • -

    5x/week during 12 weeks.

  • -

    HIIT: 5x3-min interval running at the individualized HR of 85% of VO2 max which was intervened by a 3-min active break in between at the individualized HR of 50% of VO2 max.

  • -

    CAT: Continuous walking and/or jogging at the individualized HR of 50% of VO2 max for 40 min.

Gripp (2020)43
  • -

    2x/week during 8 weeks.

  • -

    The training programs were based on the maximum velocity achieved during the 20 m shuttle test (Vshuttle).

  • -

    After 4 weeks of training, participants performed a new 20 m shuttle test for the adjustment of the speed of the training program.

  • -

    HIIT: Participants ran 7–10x, 200 m at 85–100% of Vshuttle, during 14–19 min/session.

  • -

    CAT: Participants ran 3500–5000 m at 60–75% of Vshuttle, during 27–32 min/session.

Keating (2014)46
  • -

    3x/week (60–72 min/week total training time) during 12 weeks

  • -

    HIIT: exercise on the cycle ergometer at a power output designed to 120% of VO2 peak; they performed 4-6x in 30–60 s on work + 180-120 s of recovery at low intensity.

  • -

    CAT: continuous cycling on the ergometer 30–45 min at 50–65% VO2 peak.

Zhang (2017)51
  • -

    3x/week, during 12 weeks.

  • -

    A continuous 60 rpm during each training session in both groups was observed.

  • -

    HIIT: participants repeated 4-min cycling exercise bouts at an intensity of 90% VO2 max, followed by a 3-min passive recovery until the targeted 300 kJ of work was achieved.

  • -

    CAT: participants performed continuous exercise on a cycle ergometer at an intensity of 60% VO2 max until the targeted 300 kJ of work was achieved.

Cooper (2016)42
  • -

    3x/week, during 12 weeks.

  • -

    Exercise was performed in a cycle ergometer.

  • -

    HIIT active rest: the protocol is comprised of 4–10 intervals efforts with 1:6 (work:rest) cycles, via 30 s sprint efforts (120 rpm) followed by 3 min of passive recovery.

  • -

    HIIT passive rest: the protocol is comprised of 4–10 intervals efforts with 1:6 (work:rest) cycles, via 30 s sprint efforts (120 rpm), followed by 3 min of periods involving continued cycling at 60 rpm at a lightened resistance.

  • -

    CAT: the program consisted of cycle ergometry at ∼80–85% of age-predicted HR max, during 50–60 min/session.

Hornbuckle (2018)45
  • -

    3x/week, during 16 weeks.

  • -

    Treadmill walking with 4 weeks of adaptation period for both groups (20–25 min at 60–70% HR max).

  • -

    HIIT: the protocol is comprised of 7 × 1 min at 80–90% HR max +3 min at 60–70% HR max of recovery at low intensity.

  • -

    CAT: participants performed a continuous exercise at 60–70% HR max during 32 min.

Ram (2020)48
  • -

    3x/week during 6 weeks.

  • -

    All training was conducted on manual-resistance cycle ergometers.

  • -

    HIIT: the program consisted of 10 × 1 min intervals at ∼90% HR peak, with 1 min active recovery intervals at a low workload.

  • -

    CAT: the protocol consisted of 30 min of continuous exercise at 65–75% of HR peak.

Higgins (2016)44
  • -

    3x/week during 6 weeks.

  • -

    All sessions were performed on a friction-loaded stationary cycle ergometer.

  • -

    HIIT and CAT were performed with equal estimated energy expenditure during training.

  • -

    HIIT: 5–7 sprints of 30-s with “all out” intensity interspersed with 4 min of active recovery pedaling against minimal resistance at a low pedal frequency. This exercise stimulus equated to 2.5–3.5 min of near-maximal effort interspersed with 16–28 min of recovery.

  • -

    CAT: participants were instructed to cycle continuously at an intensity of 60–70% HR reserve for 20–30 min, with the duration of training sessions systematically increased to maintain equal estimated energy expenditure between groups.

Kong (2016)47
  • -

    4x/week during 5 weeks.

  • -

    All sessions were performed on a stationary cycle ergometer.

  • -

    HIIT: the participants performed 60x of 8 s cycling +12 s passive recovery for 20 min.

  • -

    CAT: the group performed a continuous cycling exercise at 65% of VO2 peak for 40 min. A cycling speed of 60 ± 5 rpm would be maintained throughout each training session.

Zhang (2021)52
  • -

    Four-cycle ergometer training regimens was performed during 12 weeks.

  • -

    HIIT 90: repeat 4-min exercise at 90% VO2 peak, followed by a 3-min passive recovery, until the targeted 200 kJ of work was achieved.

  • -

    HIIT 120: repeat 1-min exercise at 120% VO2 peak, followed by a 1.5-min passive recovery, until the targeted 200 kJ of work was achieved.

  • -

    All-HIIT: 40 bouts of 6 s at all-out effort, followed by a 9 s of passive recovery.

  • -

    CAT: continuous exercise at 60% VO2 peak until the targeted 200 kJ of work was achieved.

Rowley (2017)49
  • -

    3x/week during 12 weeks.

  • -

    The researchers worked with maximal speed that participants could maintain for the full 30 s and that would elicit a maximal or near maximal HR response.

  • -

    HIIT: participants completed 4 × 30 s sprints at a 3–5% grade on treadmill, and the sprints were paired with a 4 min walking recovery at 2.5 mph and 0% grade.

  • -

    CAT: participants walked or jogged continuously for 30–60 min (with an increase of 10 min every 3 weeks) on a treadmill at a 3–5% grade at an intensity of their individual 45–55% HR reserve.

HR, heart rate; VO2, oxygen consumption volume; HIIT, high-intensity interval training; CAT, continuous aerobic training.