Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 12;12:e82739. doi: 10.7554/eLife.82739

Table 1. Analytic conclusions in equation form for the different DP, NC, CA, and unified mechanisms models described in our work.

Predicted expressions for active RAF at baseline (no drug), active RAF, total RAF dimers, and analytic conditions for PA to occur are shown in the rows for each of the mechanism associated models. The columns show models corresponding to the PA mechanisms of drug-modulated conformational autoinhibition (CA model), drug-induced dimerization potentiation mechanism (DP model), negative cooperativity toward second drug binding (NC model), and a model that combines all these mechanisms (unified model). The lower part of the table is a key that presents the abbreviated expressions, which allow presentation into similar functional forms for corresponding model results.

Model type Conformational autoinhibition (CA) Dimer potentiation (DP) Negative cooperativity (NC) Unified model
Core model assumptions
  1. Monomeric RAF autoinhibits

  2. Non-autoinhibited RAF can dimerize and bind drug

  3. RAF dimers signal downstream

  1. RAF can dimerize and bind drug

  2. Drug binding reduces dissociation constant of RAF dimers.

  3. RAF dimers signal downstream

  1. RAF can dimerize and bind drug

  2. Singly bound RAF dimers resist drug binding at second site

  3. RAF dimers signal downstream

  1. CA model assumptions

  2. DP model assumptions

  3. NC model assumptions

Baseline active RAF (relative to total) (1 +(1 +E3))2E3 (1 +(1 + 8 RAFrel))28RAFrel (1 +(1 + 8 RAFrel))28RAFrel (1 +(1 +E3))2E3
Active RAF (relative to total) (E1E12+E2c)2E2c(1+drel) (E1dE1d2+E2d)2f (E1d+(1+f)f)E2d (E1d2+(1+f)f2) E1n(E1nE1n2+E2n)2g2E2n(g+2gdrel+drel2) (E1E12+E2u)2g(f+drel)E2u(fg+2gdrel+drel2)
Total RAF dimers (relative to active RAF) 12(1+drel) f+drel(2+drel)2(f+drel) g2g(1+drel)+drel fg+drel(2g+drel)2g(f+drel)
RAF PA conditions RAFrel<18(1+3KA)×(KA1)
(** necessary and sufficient)
drel<12f
8×RAFrel<(38f+4f2)
f<1/2
(* sufficient)
No PA possible g1
2f1+KA
8×RAFrel<4f28f(1+KA)+3(1+KA)2
(*sufficient)
Key E1d=(drel+1)f E1=(drel+1+KA)
E2d=8f×RAFrel(f+2drel+drel2) E2c=8RAFrel(1+2drel+drel2)
E1n=(drel+1) E3=(8RAFrel)/(1+KA)2
E2n=8RAFrel(g+2gdrel+drel2) E2u=8RAFrel(fg+2gdrel+drel2)/(fg)
*Sufficient: conditions that allow PA **Necessary and sufficient: The only conditions that allow PA.