Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 11;13:19684. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-47112-w

Table 2.

Benchmark results.

Variables (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
DID DID DID PSM-DID PSM-DID PSM-DID
TR − 0.516** − 0.881*** − 0.867*** − 0.283 − 0.612*** − 0.599***
(− 2.230) (− 3.770) (− 3.727) (− 1.221) (− 2.665) (− 2.616)
ln_UR − 7.404*** − 7.351*** − 8.732*** − 8.514***
(− 9.118) (− 8.979) (− 9.553) (− 9.081)
ln_SO2 0.894*** 0.887*** 0.929*** 0.872***
(6.034) (6.265) (5.795) (5.515)
ln_ST 0.261** 0.245** 0.313** 0.327***
(2.223) (2.150) (2.513) (2.666)
ln_TE 2.062* 5.369***
(1.851) (3.310)
ln_SD − 1.194 − 1.121
(− 1.515) (− 1.466)
ln_PR 0.005 0.128
(0.031) (0.751)
_cons 45.685*** 29.705*** 33.377*** 46.059*** 28.549*** 22.331***
(571.148) (20.219) (4.729) (565.708) (17.942) (2.940)
City-Fixed Effect Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Year-Fixed Effect Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Obs 3976 3976 3976 3841 3841 3841
R2 0.946 0.949 0.949 0.947 0.950 0.950

The t value in parentheses is calculated according to the robust standard error of clustering at the city-year level;

*, ** and ***denotes the significance levels of 10%, 5%, and 1%, respectively.