Table 2.
Performance of intestinal ultrasound in the assessment of disease activity in inflammatory bowel disease
Performance of IUS | Sensitivity %[95%CI] | Specificity %[95%CI] | PPV %[95%CI] | NPV %[95%CI] | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|||||||||
Total | UC | CD | Total | UC | CD | Total | UC | CD | Total | UC | CD | |
vs EAI | ||||||||||||
Overall | 66.7 [41,86] | 50.0 [17,83] | 80.0 [44,97] | 97.0[83,100] | 100 [81,100] | 91.7[60,100] | 92.3[62,100] | 100[40,100] | 88.9 [51,99] | 84.2 [68,93] | 84 [63,95] | 84.6 [54,97] |
Per parameters | ||||||||||||
BWT | 72.2 [46,89] | 33.3 [2,88] | 80.0 [44,97] | 75.8 [57,88] | 65.4 [44,82] | 75.0 [43,93] | 61.9 [39,81] | 10.0 [1,46] | 72.7 [39,93] | 83.3 [65,94] | 89.5 [66,98] | 81.8 [48,97] |
LWS | 61.1 [36,82] | 33.3 [2,88] | 70.0 [35,92] | 93.9 [78,99] | 84.6 [64,95] | 91.7[60,100] | 84.6 [54,97] | 20.0 [1,70] | 87.5 [47,99] | 81.6 [65,92] | 91.7 [72,99] | 78.6 [49,94] |
MFP | 50.0 [27,73] | 33.3 [2,88] | 60.0 [27,86] | 100 [87,100] | 92.3 [73,99] | 100 [70,100] | 100 [63,100] | 33.3 [2,88] | 100[52,100] | 78.6 [63,89] | 92.3 [73,99] | 75.0 [47,92] |
IV | 50.0 [27,73] | 33.3 [2,88] | 60.0 [27,86] | 97.0[83,100] | 92.3 [73,99] | 91.7[60,100] | 90.0[54,100] | 33.3 [2,88] | 85.7 [42,99] | 78.0 [62,89] | 92.3 [73,99] | 73.3 [45,91] |
Per-bowel segment | ||||||||||||
Terminal ileum | 40.0 [14,73] | 0.0 [0,95] | 44.4 [15,77] | 97.6[86,100] | 96.4[80,100] | 100 [72,100] | 80.0 [30,99] | 0.0 [0,95] | 100[40,100] | 87.0 [73,95] | 96.4[80,100] | 72.2 [46,89] |
Right colon | 70.0 [35,92] | 0.0 [0,95] | 77.8 [40,96] | 100 [89,100] | 100 [85,100] | 100 [72,100] | 100 [56,100] | - | 100[56,100] | 93.2 [80,98] | 96.6[80,100] | 86.7 [58,98] |
Transverse colon | 100 [60,100] | 100[31,100] | 100[46,100] | 95.3 [83,99] | 100 [84,100] | 88.2 [62,98] | 80.0 [44,97] | 100[31,100] | 71.4 [30,95] | 100 [89,100] | 100 [84,100] | 100[75,100] |
Left colon | 61.1 [36,82] | 45.5 [18,75] | 85.7 [42,99] | 100 [87,100] | 100 [78,100] | 100 [75,100] | 100 [68,100] | 100[46,100] | 100[52,100] | 82.5 [67,92] | 75.0 [53,89] | 93.8[68,100] |
Rectum | 42.1 [21,66] | 36.4 [12,68] | 50.0 [17,83] | 93.8 [78,99] | 94.4[71,100] | 92.9[64,100] | 80.0 [44,97] | 80.0 [30,99] | 80.0 [30,99] | 73.2 [57,85] | 70.8 [49,87] | 76.5 [50,92] |
Correlation | r=0.698 (P<0.01) | r=0.648 (P<0.01) | r=0.726 (P<0.01) | |||||||||
vs CAI | ||||||||||||
Overall | 70.0 [35,92] | 33.3 [2,88] | 85.7 [42,99] | 85.4 [70,94] | 88.5 [69,97] | 80.0 [51,95] | 53.8 [26,80] | 25.0 [1,78] | 66.7 [31,91] | 92.1 [78,98] | 92.0 [73,99] | 92.3[62,100] |
Correlation | r=0.504 (P<0.01) | r=0.192 (P=0.317) | r=0.623 (P=0.002) | |||||||||
vs biomarkers | ||||||||||||
Faecal calprotectin | r=0.489 (P=0.001) | r=0.461 (P=0.018) | r=0.511 (P=0.025) | |||||||||
C-reactive protein | r=0.604 (P<0.01) | r=0.475 (P=0.009) | r=0.647 (P=0.001) | |||||||||
vs CT/MRI | ||||||||||||
Correlation | r=0.661 (P=0.007) | - | r=0.745 (P=0.002) |
IUS=intestinal ultrasound, PPV=positive predictive value, NPV=negative predictive value, CI=confidence interval, UC=ulcerative colitis, CD=Crohn’s disease, vs=versus, EAI=endoscopic activity index, BWT=bowel wall thickening, LWS=loss of wall stratification, MFP=mesenteric fatty proliferation, IV=increased vascularity, r=Pearson’s correlation coefficient, CAI=clinical activity index, CT=computed tomography, MRI=magnetic resonance imaging