Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 10;5(45):1012–1016. doi: 10.46234/ccdcw2023.190

Table S2. Characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis*.

Study No. of participants Age (years) Endpoints (no. of cases) Follow-up period Exposure and assessment method (exposure) Outcome assessment Daily consumption (exposure) Year of recruitment Covariates in fully adjusted model Quality score
Abbreviation: CHNS=China Health and Nutrition Survey (China); CKB=China Kadoorie Biobank (China); SW(M)HS=Shanghai Women’s (Men’s) Health Study (China); KoGES=Korean Genome Epidemiology Study (Republic of Korea); SCHS=Singapore Chinese Health Study (Singapore); JPHC=Japan Public Health Center-based Prospective Study (Japan). DM=diabetes mellitus; T2DM=type 2 diabetes mellitus; FFQ=food frequency questionnaire; g=grams; Q=quartile; SD=standard deviation; NA=not applicable.
Liu et al. (2021) CHNS, China (9) 16,117 Mean: 43.0 (SD: 15.2) DM
(1,088)
Median: 9.0 years; 158,018 person-years Three consecutive 24-hour dietary recalls (unprocessed red meat, processed meat) Self-reported Median: 58.9 g (unprocessed red meat); median: 0 g (processed meat) 1997 Age, sex, BMI, waist circumference, smoking and drinking status, systolic blood pressure, diastolic blood pressure, education, region, occupation, physical activity, urban residence, as well as total energy, and 12 food groups were mutually adjusted. 6
Du et al. (2020) CKB, China (8) 461,036 Mean: 51.2 (SD: 10.5);
35–74 years
DM (14,931) Mean: 9 years; 4.5 million person-years Laptop-based FFQ (total red and processed meat) Linkages with chronic disease registries and national health insurance claim databases Mean: 55.1 g (total red and processed meat) 2004–2008 Age, sex, region, education, income, smoking, alcohol consumption, physical activity, family history of diabetes, and fresh fruit consumption, two main dietary exposure variables, and BMI. 9
Yu et al. (2018) SWHS & SMHS, China (10) 64,802 Women and
53,117 men
40–74 years T2DM (6,111) Mean: 11.5 years (13.6 years for women; 8.8 years for men). Semiquantitative FFQ (unprocessed red meat, processed meat) Self-reported diagnosis NA 1996–2000 (women); 2002–2006 (men) Total energy intake, education, income, smoking, alcohol drinking, leisure-time exercise, family history of diabetes, history of hypertension, history of dyslipidemia, and, in women, menopausal status, BMI, and all eight food groups were mutually adjusted. 6
Son et al. (2018) KoGES, Republic of Korea (11) 8,618 40–69 years T2DM (668) 62,130 person-years Semiquantitative FFQ (processed meat) Self-reported interviews Median: 0 g (processed meat) 2001–2002 and 2005–2006 Age, sex, educational level, monthly household income, and residential area, smoking, physical activity, BMI, alcohol intake, energy intake, consumption levels of dietary fat, crude fiber, sodium, fruit and vegetable, current use of antihypertensive and antihyperlipidemic medications. 7
Talaei et al. (2017) SCHS, Singapore (6) 45,411 Mean: 55.2 (SD: 7.6);
45–74 years
T2DM (5,207) Mean: 10.9 years; 494,741 person-years Semiquantitative FFQ (total red and processed meat, unprocessed red meat, processed meat) Self-reported interviews Median of Q1–Q4 (total red and processed meat): 12.3 g, 24.2 g, 33.4 g, 48.8 g; median of Q1–Q4 (unprocessed red meat): 10.5 g, 20.7 g, 29.0 g, 43.5 g; median of Q1–Q4 (processed meat): 0 g, 1.4 g, 2.57 g, 5.39 g 1993–1998 Age, sex, dialect, year of interview, and educational level, BMI, physical activity level, smoking status, alcohol use, baseline history of self-reported hypertension, adherence to the vegetable-, fruit-, and soy-rich dietary pattern, and total energy intake, heme iron intake 8
Kurotani et al. (2013) JPHC, Japan (7) 63,849 45–75 years T2DM (1,178) Max: 5 years Self-administered FFQ (total red and processed meat, unprocessed red meat, processed meat) Self-reported interviews Men: median of Q1–Q4 (total red and processed meat): 17.9 g, 36.5 g, 56.4 g, 94.9 g; median of Q1–Q4 (unprocessed red meat): 15.1 g, 31.4 g, 49.0 g, 82.7 g; median of Q1–Q4 (processed meat): 0 g, 2.4 g, 5.6 g, 14.6 g; women: median of Q1–Q4 (total red and processed meat): 15.2 g, 32.0 g, 49.5 g, 82.9 g; median of Q1–Q4 (unprocessed red meat): 12.3 g, 26.9 g, 42.4 g, 72.2 g; median of Q1–Q4 (processed meat): 0 g, 2.4 g, 5.6 g, 13.5 g 1990 and 1993 Age, public health center area, BMI, smoking status, alcohol consumption, total physical activity, the history of hypertension, coffee consumption, the family history of diabetes, Mg intake, Ca intake, rice intake, fish intake, vegetable intake, soft drink consumption and energy intake 6
Villegas et al. (2006) SWHS, China (12) 70,609 Mean: 51.7 (SD: 8.97);
40–70 years
T2DM (1,972) Mean: 4.6 years; 326,625 person-years FFQ (unprocessed red meat, only for dose-response) Self-reported type 2 diabetes identified through the baseline and follow-up surveys Median: 42.6 g (unprocessed red meat) 1997–2000 (women) Age, energy intake, BMI, WHR, smoking, alcohol consumption, physical activity, vegetable intake, income level, education level, occupation status, hypertension, and chronic disease 6