Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 15;23:865. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04837-6

Table 3.

Messick framework: sources of evidence, definitions and procedure

Source of evidence Definition Procedure
Content “the relationship between a test's content and the construct it is intended to measure [26].” Assessed as a part of development
Internal structure "The relationship among data items within the assessment and how these relate to the overarching construct [24]" Interrater reliability
Internal consistency
Observability
Relationships with other variables “The degree to which these relationships are consistent with the construct underlying the proposed test score interpretations [26]” Planned in further validations
Response process “The fit between the construct and the detailed nature of performance... actually engaged in [26]” Raters respond in questionnaire
Consequences “The impact, beneficial or harmful and intended or unintended, of assessment [27]” Evaluation of the possibility of minimal rater training