Table 3. Safety Results of the Included Studies .
| Reference | Results |
| Salama and El-Sawy20 | # CK activity increased insignificantly after 5-minute LED treatment. # Both SMI and SHCC remained stable after the treatment for 10 min. |
| Espey et al21 | # No significant changes in the DFI were detected after therapy. # The pattern of CD46 expression confirmed the maintenance of acrosomal integrity after therapy. |
| Salman Yazdi et al22 | # The results of SCD and HOS tests in the 10 J/cm2 group were not significantly different compared to the control group. |
| Safian et al23 | # Both the Red and Red + NIR lasers at 0.6, 1.2 and 2.4 J/cm2 significantly decreased viability and increased DFI. However, this difference was not significant between NIR and control groups. |
| Allameh et al15 | In this study, the safety of PBM in motility was not assessed and only motility tests were done. |
| Safian et al24 | # DFI and LPL were significantly reduced in group 2 compared to group 1. # Early apoptosis and necrotic cells decreased significantly in group 2 compared to either group. # The expression levels of PRM1, PRM2, and ADD1 were not significantly different among the study groups. # PBM therapy prior to cryopreservation has a significant protective role against cryo-damage. |
| Frangez et al25 | In this study, the safety of PBM in motility was not assessed and only motility tests were done. |
| Safian et al26 | # No significant differences were observed in the morphological features. # PBM treatment before cryopreservation significantly increased the concentration of viable spermatozoa. # PBM before cryopreservation significantly increased the number of high MMP sperms and decreased the number of low MMP sperms post-thawing. # The PBM-preconditioning significantly decreased the intracellular ROS level and LPL. |
| Zupin et al27 | # An increase in the Na + content was detected after PBM, suggesting that this change could be vital in the enhancement of sperm movement. |
| Gabel et al28 | # SCSA assay revealed no increase in DFI from the very high doses of both laser and LED therapy. |
| Saeed et al29 | In this study, the safety of PBM in motility was not assessed and only motility tests were done. |
| Firestone et al30 | # DFI was not significantly different. |
| Shahar et al31 | # ROS was produced after 1–3 min of light irradiation, while there was a significant reduction in ROS in the presence of SOD or azide. # Mitochondrial respiration is the main source of ROS produced by light therapy in sperms. # HAM in DCF loaded cells was enhanced by light. # Azide caused complete inhibition of the light effect on HAM. # Light therapy did not affect DFI. # Intracellular Ca2 + concentration increased significantly after PBM. |
| Fekrazad et al32 | In this study, the safety of PBM in motility was not assessed and only motility tests were done. |
| Highland et al33 | # The sperm viability significantly decreased in both groups after exposure to NIR which was higher in group 2 compared to group 1. # A significant decrease in the number of swollen spermatozoa was observed after NIR exposure in both groups as compared to pre-treated samples. # Percent of apoptotic cells increased more significantly after NIR exposure in both groups as compared to pre-treated groups. This increase was significantly higher in group 2 compared to group 1 post-treatment. # Toroid disruption increased insignificantly after NIR exposure in group 1, but group 2 showed a highly significant increase. # The number of sperms with normal chromatin dispersion decreased significantly in groups 1 and 2 after NIR exposure as compared to the pre-treated samples. # SOD activity diminished significantly after NIR exposure in both groups. # LPL increased significantly after NIR exposure in groups 1 and 2. |
Abbreviations: SMI, sperm membrane integrity; HOS, hypo osmotic swelling test; SHCC, sperm head chromatin condensation; ANBS, aniline blue staining; DFI, DNA Fragmentation Index; LPL, lipid peroxidation level; PRM, gene expression levels of protamine; ADD1, adducin 1 alpha; MMP, mitochondrial membrane potential; ROS, reactive oxygen species; SCSA, sperm chromatin structure assay; SOD, super oxide dismutase.