Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 15;13(11):e075588. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-075588

Table 1.

Strategies to minimise bias

Stage and type of bias Strategy implemented
Protocol development
Design bias Extensive international scientific, clinical and ethical input on the protocol; patient and family input to refine the patient-important bleeding outcome
Corporate conflicts of interest Peer-review funded trial; locally sourced pantoprazole
Procedural bias Standard operating procedures guide protocol implementation; central statistical monitoring is ongoing throughout the trial
Omission bias Eligibility criteria are broad; enrolment is in five continents
Surveillance bias Rigorous training of research personnel
Detection of ventilator-associated pneumonia (VAP) To avoid biased choice of VAP definition: VAP reporting has one main and several alternate definitions
Protocol implementation
Prognostic imbalance At point of randomisation, patients are stratified for prehospital acid suppression which may influence outcomes
Selection bias Allocation is concealed; research personnel screening, consenting, and enrolling patients are unaware of randomisation sequence
Detection and performance bias Patients, families, all clinical and research personnel are blinded
Measurement bias Primary efficacy outcome: Clinically important GI bleeding is centrally adjudicated by two physicians trained in study procedures, and blinded to allocation and centre
Loss to follow-up Primary Safety Outcome: for 90-day mortality status, multiple methods used for patients discharged alive before 90 days; all other outcomes are hospital based as recorded in medical charts
Missing data Each research record is reviewed and validated at least three times by Methods Center staff
Analysis
False claims of benefit A priori statistical approach is very conservative for stopping early for apparent benefit before full sample size reached
False claims of no difference A priori statistical approach does not include stopping early for futility before full sample size reached
Confirmation bias Analyst is blinded to allocation until after the final analysis
Analytic bias Analysis will adhere to the intention-to-treat principle
Dissemination
Reporting bias Trial reporting will adhere to trial registration (NCT03374800), protocol and statistical analysis plan
Publication bias Results will be disseminated through many knowledge translation strategies including peer-review journals

These are the strategies we protocolised to minimise bias in four different phases of the trial.