Table 3. Insurance and financial challenges in the Family Physician Program (FPP) of Iran based on systematic review of the publications.
Theme |
Subtheme |
---|---|
Budget and funding |
Lack of clear and stable financial resources for the FPP |
|
Injustice in funding |
|
Insufficient financial resources |
|
Delayed budgeting |
|
Underestimation of the required funds for the plan |
|
Spending the allocated budget for other purposes |
|
Weak financial processes |
|
Lack of a pooled fund |
Insurance system |
Multiple policies, fragmented health insurance system and lack of coordination among insurance organisations |
|
Lack of a public insurance scheme |
Tariffs |
No rational medical tariffs based on the relative value of health services, inflation, educational level and hardship of work |
Lack of a national policy for tariff | |
Payment per capita instead of performance-based payment to health teams | |
Payments |
Single payment for levels 2 and 3 |
Insufficient infrastructure for a performance-based payment system | |
Inadequate criteria for per capita payment | |
Individual-centred payments instead of salaries | |
Clinical and treatment approaches of managers who pay family physicians | |
Lack of a health-oriented vision of insurance organisations | |
Delayed reimbursements by health insurances to family physicians | |
Unclear methods of payment | |
Lack of a backup software for methods of payment | |
High insurance deductibles | |
Financial accountability |
Lack of trained and experienced inspectors with the required expertise to evaluate the FPP |
Lack of proper supervision structure in health insurance organisations | |
Difficulties in supervision owing to diverse payment methods in the FPP | |
Lack of criteria and scientific tools, such as valid and reliable checklists for FPP assessment | |
Top-down monitoring approach instead of an educational approach, which can enhance the FPP | |
Inequity |
Unjust payments to members of family physician teams |
Difference in tariffs set for urban and rural physicians | |
Lower wages for family physicians than for other medical specialists | |
Discrimination between those insured by social security and health insurance organisations and those insured by other organisations to access physicians |