Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 8;28(22):7477. doi: 10.3390/molecules28227477

Table 2.

The effect of propolis ethanolic extract on the production of selected cytokines, i.e. IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-15, TNF-α and EEP in LPS, EEP in IFN-α, as well as EEP in LPS + IFN-α stimulated HGF-1 cells (n = 3). Statistical significance was analyzed using Fisher’s LSD test. Results marked in bold are statistically significant in Fisher’s LSD test. Multivariate tests of significance (F = 12.91, p < 0.05).

Sample IL-1β IL-6 IL-8 IL-15 TNF-α
AVG SD p AVG SD p AVG SD p AVG SD p AVG SD p
Control baseline (EEP) 1.224 3.410 1.360 1256.310 4.070
Control DMSO (EI) 3.261 1.778 109.283 8.940 27.600 6.946 1482.840 156.863 11.330 7.335
Control LPS (ELI) 1.315 0.079 131.800 23.512 41.693 4.151 1439.930 373.413 3.642 0.214
Control IFN-α (EI) 2.153 1.374 105.797 21.038 24.810 5.595 1730.793 161.382 7.222 6.018
Control LPS + IFN-α (ELI) 1.156 0.068 139.400 27.655 27.477 4.218 1534.390 32.684 3.427 0.742
EEP 25 µg/mL 3.603 2.178 87.747 33.217 42.423 1.686 1505.647 44.126 7.294 5.959
EEP 50 µg/mL 1.315 0.079 114.503 25.121 40.233 6.905 1539.677 248.184 3.642 0.214
EEP 25 µg/mL + LPS 1.224 0.000 0.9442 85.727 35.643 0.9941 48.643 13.891 0.9889 1450.367 116.122 0.9178 3.856 0.214 0.9736
EEP 50 µg/mL + LPS 1.088 0.118 0.8611 143.770 67.882 0.9985 87.427 53.326 0.9271 1470.890 87.826 0.7596 5.251 2.416 0.8040
EEP 25 µg/mL + IFN-α 1.315 0.079 0.5182 392.797 35.264 0.9633 608.307 204.011 0.2460 1711.937 53.431 0.8521 4.965 2.663 0.7277
EEP 50 µg/mL + IFN-α 1.269 0.079 0.4960 371.620 27.279 0.9660 422.833 164.744 0.4271 1386.310 86.914 0.0012 3.356 0.539 0.5514
EEP 25 µg/mL + LPS + IFN-α 1.156 0.118 1.0000 408.203 35.695 0.9656 870.680 139.463 0.0959 1483.853 134.711 0.6177 7.080 6.164 0.5736
EEP 50 µg/mL + LPS + IFN-α 2.811 1.610 0.2050 449.213 54.085 0.9604 1209.220 246.153 0.0212 1581.167 42.413 0.6440 10.259 8.171 0.2943

AVG: average; SD: standard deviation; p-value: probability value.