Table 3.
Comparative table between characteristics of ILs, DESs, and NADESs.
IL | DES | NaDES | |
---|---|---|---|
Formed by | Organic cation and organic/inorganic anion | Hydrogen bond acceptor (HBA) and hydrogen bond donor (HBD) (amide compounds, inorganic salts, and quaternary ammonium salts) | HBA and HBD from natural sources |
Solubilization Ability | Good solubilizing capacity of a number of organic compounds | High | High solubilization for a wide range of metabolites with low to medium polarity, as well as macromolecules such as DNA, proteins, and polysaccharides |
Extraction Ability | High | High | High |
Formulation/Synthesis Facility | Low, demand solvent use | High, but higher melting points of many DES, however, can hamper their application as a green solvent at room temperature | High |
Can be Recycled | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Biodegradability | Mean | High | High |
Toxicity | Toxicity towards diverse organisms and ecosystems | Some formulations may contain metallic salts, which are known for their innate toxicity | Low, but the inclusion of organic acids in NaDESs can increase their overall toxicity |
ECO Friendly | Potential environmental pollution through release via wastewater effluents | Lack of waste generation, but not entirely sustainable due to the presence of metal salts in some formulations | Yes |
Cost | High | Low cost of their starting materials | Low |