1. Overview of study populations.
Characteristic | Intervention(s) and comparator(s) | Sample sizea | Screened/eligible [N] | Randomised [N] | Safety [N] | Finishing study [N] | Randomised finishing study [%] | Follow‐upb |
(1) Agurs Collins 1997 | I: individual and group sessions | 40 | 87 | 32 | 30 | 93.8 | 6 mo | |
C: 1 class and info leaflet | 40 | 32 | 25 | 78.1 | ||||
total: | 64 | 55 | 90.6 85.9 |
|||||
(2) Anderson 2005 | I: group sessions | ‐ | ‐ | 125 | ‐ | ‐ | 3 mo | |
C: usual care plus feedback on baseline bloods | 114 | ‐ | ‐ | |||||
total: | 239 | 194 | 81.2 | |||||
(3) Babamoto 2009 | I1: individual sessions plus telephone calls | ‐ | 1352/354 | 106 | 60 | 56.6 | 6 mo | |
I2: case management | 106 | |||||||
C: usual care | 106 | 54 | 50.9 | |||||
total: | 318 | 189 | 59.4 | |||||
(4) Baradaran 2006 |
I1: group sessions | ‐ | 299 | 59 | 44 | 74.6 | 6 mo | |
C1: usual care—South Asian | 59 | 36 | 61.0 | |||||
C2: usual care—White Caucasian | 27c | 21 | 77.8 | |||||
total: | 118 | 101 | 85.6 | |||||
(5) Bellary 2008 | I: treatment protocols and extra clinics plus link workers | 16‐18 clusters of 80‐100 participants | 3571/2426 | 868 | 747 | 86.1 | 24 mo | |
C: treatment protocols only | 618 | 531 | 85.9 | |||||
total: | 1486 | 1278 | 86.0 | |||||
(6) Brown 2002 | I: group sessions | ‐ | ‐ | 126 | 89 | 70.6 | 12 mo | |
C: usual care—wait‐listed control group | 126 | 89 | 70.6 | |||||
total: | 252 | 178 | 70.6 | |||||
(7) Carter 2011 | I: Internet and videoconferencing with nurse | ‐ | ‐ | ‐ | 26 | ‐ | 9 mo | |
C: usual care | ‐ | 21 | ‐ | |||||
total: | 74 | 47 | 63.5 | |||||
(8) Crowley 2013 | I: individual sessions via telephone | 200 | 2153/1508 | 182 | 166 | 91.2 | 12 mo | |
C: usual care + leaflet | 177 | 164 | 92.7 | |||||
total: | 359 | 329 | 91.6 | |||||
(9) D'Eramo Melkus 2010 |
I: group sessions | 129 | 236/119 | 57 | 40 | 70.2 | 24 mo | |
C: conventional (not culturally appropriate) group sessions | 52 | 37 | 71.2 | |||||
total: | 109 | 77 | 70.6 | |||||
(10) DePue 2013 | I: Nurse‐led self‐management education and medication management facilitation components | 362 | 406/312 | 104 | 95 | 91.3 | 12 mo | |
C: usual care | 164 | 148 | 90.2 | |||||
total: | 268 | 243 | 90.7 | |||||
(11) Gary 2009 |
I: individual visits to CHW and nurse following culturally appropriate clinical algorithms | ‐ | 2450/955 | 269 | 235 | 87.4 | 24 mo | |
C: telephone calls and information leaflets | ‐ | 273 | 253 | 92.7 | ||||
total: | 542 | 488 | 90.0 | |||||
(12) Gucciardi 2007 |
I1: group sessions | ‐ | 233 | 41 | 25 | 61.0 | 3 mo | |
I2: individual sessions | 46 | 36 | 78.3 | |||||
total: | 87 | 61 | 70.1 | |||||
(13) Hawthorne 1998 |
I: individual session with CHW—flashcards | 100 | ‐/201 | 112 | 106 | 94.6 | 6 mo | |
C: usual care in clinics | 100 | 89 | 86 | 96.6 | ||||
total: | 201 | 192 | 95.5 | |||||
(14) Kattelmann 2009 |
I: group sessions | 57 | ‐ | 57 | 51 | 89.5 | 6 mo | |
C: standard dietary education and health care | 57 | 57 | 53 | 92.9 | ||||
total: | 114 | 104 | 91.2 | |||||
(15) Keyserling 2002 |
I1: individual and group sessions | 210 | 219 | 66 | 54 | 81.8 | 12 mo | |
I2: individual—not included in meta‐analysis | 67 | 59 | 88.1 | |||||
C: usual care | 67 | 58 | 86.6 | |||||
total: | 200 | 171 | 85.5 | |||||
(16) Khan 2011 |
I: individual computer‐based | ‐ | 146/129 | 67 | 53 | 79.1 | 3 mo | |
C: brochure with crossword puzzle | 62 | 47 | 75.8 | |||||
total: | 129 | 100 | 77.5 | |||||
(17) Kim 2009 |
I: group sessions and telephone calls | 40 | 224/83 | 41 | 40 | 97.6 | 30 wk | |
C: usual care (wait‐listed) | 40 | 42 | 39 | 95.1 | ||||
total: | 83 | 79 | 95.2 | |||||
(18) Lorig 2008 |
I: group sessions | ‐ | ‐ | 219 | 179 | 81.7 | 6 mo | |
C: usual care (wait‐listed) | 198 | 173 | 87.4 | |||||
total: | 417 | 352 | 84.4 | |||||
(19) Lujan 2007 |
I1: group sessions, telephone calls and inspirational postcards | 75 | ‐/160 | 75 | 70 | 93.3 | 6 mo | |
C1: usual care—individual sessions and info leaflets | 75 | 75 | 71 | 94.7 | ||||
total: | 150 | 143 | 95.3 | |||||
(20) Middelkoop 2001 |
I: group sessions | ‐ | ‐ | 53 | 53 | 100 | 6 mo | |
C: usual care (wait‐listed) | 60 | 60 | 100 | |||||
total: | 113 | 113 | 100 | |||||
(21) O'Hare 2004 |
I: treatment protocols plus extra diabetes clinics and link workers | 64 | 401 | 180 | 165 | 91.7 | 12 mo | |
C: treatment protocols only | 64 | 181 | 160 | 88.4 | ||||
total: | 361 | 325 | 90.0 | |||||
(22) Osborn 2010 |
I: individual education session | ‐ | ‐/129 | 59 | 48 | 81.4 | 3 mo | |
C: usual care—access to monthly support group facilitated by Puerto‐Rican worker | 59 | 43 | 72.9 | |||||
total: | 118 | 91 | 77.1 | |||||
(23) Philis‐Tsimikas 2011 | I: group education sessions and support group | 210 | ‐/961 | 104 | 56 | 53.8 | 10 mo | |
C: usual care | 103 | 72 | 69.9 | |||||
total: | 207 | 156 | 75.4 | |||||
(24) Rosal 2005 |
I: individual and group sessions | ‐ | 54 | 15 | ‐ | ‐ | 6 mo | |
C: usual care plus feedback of test results | 10 | ‐ | ‐ | |||||
total: | 25 | ‐ | 92 | |||||
(25) Rosal 2011 |
I: individual and group sessions | 250 | 592/276 | 124 | 106 | 85.5 | 12 mo | |
C: usual care | 128 | 105 | 82.0 | |||||
total: | 252 | 211 | 83.7 | |||||
(26) Rothschild 2012 | I: home visits | ‐ | 343/‐ | 73 | 58 | 79.5 | ??? | |
C: mailed information leaflets | 71 | 61 | 85.9 | |||||
total: | 144 | 119 | 82.6 | |||||
(27) Samuel‐Hodge 2009 |
I: individual, group and telephone calls | 280 | 284/260 | 117 | 101 | 86.3 | 12 mo | |
C: minimal intervention: leaflets and newsletters | 84 | 69 | 82.1 | |||||
total: | 201 | 170 | 84.6 | |||||
(28) Sixta 2008 |
I: group sessions | ‐ | 734/135 | 63 | 6 mo | |||
C: usual care (wait‐listed) | 68 | |||||||
total: | 131 | 60 | 45.8 | |||||
(29) Skelly 2005 |
I: home visits | 20 | 52 | ‐ | 23 | ‐ | 12 wk 12 wk |
|
C: usual care plus telephone call (wait‐listed) | 20 | ‐ | 18 | ‐ | ||||
total: | 47 | 41 | 87.2 | |||||
(30) Skelly 2009 |
I1: home visits—symptom focused | ‐ | 308/180 | 60 | 60 | 100 | 9 mo | |
I2: home visits with booster (not used in the meta‐analysis) | 60 | 55 | 91.7 | |||||
C1: nurse home visits—non‐symptom focused | 60 | 59 | 98.3 | |||||
total: | 180 | 174 | 96.7 | |||||
(31) Spencer 2011 | I: group meetings, home visit and accompanied clinic visit | ‐ | 1719/183 | 84 | 59 | 70.2 | 6 mo | |
C: usual care (wait listed) | 99 | 77 | 77.8 | |||||
total: | 164 | 136 | 82.9 | |||||
(32) Toobert 2011 |
I: group meetings | ‐ | 4045/680 | 142 | ‐ | 24 mo | ||
C: usual care | 138 | ‐ | ||||||
total: | 280 | ‐ | 61.4 | |||||
(33) Vincent 2007 |
I: group sessions | ‐ | 60/30 | 10 | 9 | 90 | 3 mo | |
C: usual care | 10 | 8 | 80 | |||||
total: | 20 | 17 | 85 | |||||
Grand total | All interventions | N/A | ||||||
All comparators | ||||||||
All interventions and comparators | 7453 |
aAccording to power calculation in study publication or report. bDuration of intervention and/or follow‐up under randomised conditions until end of study. cNot used in the meta‐analysis.
"‐" denotes not reported.
C: comparator; CHW: community health worker; I: intervention; ITT: intention‐to‐treat; mo: month; N/A: not applicable; wk: weeks