Skip to main content
. 2014 Sep 4;2014(9):CD006424. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006424.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Ahmedani 2012 Includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes and does not focus on ethnic group in Pakistan
Al‐Shookri 2012 Arab Omanis are not an ethnic minority
Alexander 2008 Not a randomised controlled trial (RCT)
Amano 2007 Not an ethnic minority group
Amaoko 2007 Not clearly defined diabetes health education
Amaoko 2008 Outcome assessed only at 6 weeks, not clearly defined diabetes health education
Andersen 2013 Excluded if have diabetes
Anderson 2010 Multi‐ethnic group
Arakaki 2009 No specific ethnic minority group
Arora 2012 Not an RCT, includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes
Barrera 2012 No outcomes from our protocol
Batik 2008 No health education
Blackwell 2011 No ethnic group; participants did not have type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM)
Bogner 2010 Not clearly defined health education
Bolin 2013 Not type 2 diabetes, mixed ethnic group
Borges 2007 Outcomes assessed at 1 month only
Boudreau 2011 No outcomes from our review
Bravis 2010 Appears participants were not randomly assigned
Bray 2013 Not an RCT
Brown 2007 No control group, not an RCT
Brown 2010 Not an RCT
Brown 2011 All received culturally appropriate health education (HE). Intervention group had nurse case manager
Calle 2009 No outcomes specified in our protocol
Calles‐Escandon 2010 Intervention not diabetes health education (HE)
Chan 2009 Not an ethnic minority group, intervention not culturally adapted
Choi 2012 Not an RCT, also this is a pilot study
Choudhury 2008 Qualitative study, not an RCT
Comellas 2010 No control group, not an RCT. Mutli‐ethnic group
Cramer 2007 Not specified by ethnic group
Crasto 2010 No specific ethnic minority group
Crasto 2011 No ethnic minority group
Davidson 2007 No control group, not an RCT
Davis 2009 Participants did not have type 2 diabetes
Davis 2009a Multi‐ethnic group, no clearly defined ethnic group
Davis 2009b Conference abstract for Diabetes Telecare Study (Davis 2009a)
Davis 2011 Not an RCT
Deitrick 2010 Qualitative study, not an RCT
Douglas 2013 Not type 2 diabetes, participants have "impaired glycaemia"
Eakin 2007 Any chronic condition, not just type 2 diabetes
Egede 2010 No results
Ell 2009 Just design, no results
Ezenwaka 2011 Not an ethnic minority group
Fatima 2011 Cohort study with purposive sampling
Fernandez 2011 No clearly defined outcome from protocol, assesses questionnaire validity
Gerber 2012 Trial design, plus mixed ethnic group
Gill 2010 No control group, not an RCT
Glasgow 2011 No specific ethnic minority group
Henderson 2012 Study not completed and cultural intervention not clear
Heudebert 2013 Abstract of conference only. Does not appear culturally adapted.
Hill‐Briggs 2007 Not an RCT
Hill‐Briggs 2011 Intervention not culturally adapted
Hotu 2010 No health education in intervention
Ivey 2012 Not an RCT
Jernigan 2011 Not an RCT
Jones 2008 Qualitative study, not an RCT
Kanaya 2012 Participants do not have type 2 diabetes
Katula 2011 Participants did not have type 2 diabetes
Klug 2008 Not an RCT
Latham 2009 No control group, not an RCT
Leeman 2008 No control group, not an RCT
Lenjawi 2012 Discussed with KH. Qatar not on list of selected countries and excluded, as study population is the national group not at a disadvantage
Levetan 2002 Study included only 86% of African Americans, and the intervention was not culturally relevant
Liang 2011 Participants did not all have type 2 diabetes plus did not receive not a culturally tailored intervention
Lunde 2012 Participants do not have type 2 diabetes
Martin 2011 Just about recruitment, not an RCT
McCloskey 2009 Not an RCT
Metghalchi 2008 Cohort study, not an RCT
Mohamed 2013 Arabs in Qatar not ethnic minority group
Murrock 2009 Not health education
Nam 2010 Cross‐sectional survey, not an RCT
Osuna 2011 Pilot study, not an RCT
Oyetayo 2011 Not an RCT
Palmas 2012 It is a protocol
Peña‐Purcell 2011 Not a randomised controlled trial
Phumipamorn 2008 Not an ethnic group, not culturally adapted
Powers 2009 This is a protocol
Prezio 2013 No clearly defined ethnic group
Raberg Kjollesdal 2011 Both type 1 and type 2 diabetes
Rosal 2009 No results, just design
Rothschild 2012 Study design paper
Ruelas 2009 Not clearly defined health education and unsure whether culturally adapted. Both groups had same number of visits
Ruggiero 2010 Multi‐ethnic group
Ruggiero 2010b No specific ethnic minority group
Ryan 2013 Not an RCT (feasibility study), no clearly defined ethnic group
Saha 2013 Protocol, not for diabetic individuals
Salto 2011 Not an RCT
Shea 2009 Type 1 and type 2 diabetes
Shenoy 2009 Not an ethnic group, not a culturally tailored intervention
Shenoy 2010 Not an ethnic group, intervention not culturally adapted
Shi 2010 Not an ethnic minority group
Skelly 2008 Not an RCT
Skoro‐Kondza 2009 Multi‐ethnic group, not health education
Sun 2012 Includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes
Tang 2010 Not an RCT
Tang 2011 Not an RCT
Tang 2012 Not an RCT
Trief 2013 Not clear whether only type 2, also mixed ethnic groups
Utz 2008 No control group, not an RCT
Vincent 2008 Qualitative data for same trial as Vincent 2007
Walker 2008 includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes and multi‐ethnic group
Walker 2010 Participants were not randomly assigned to intervention
Walker 2011 Mixed ethnic group
Wattana 2007 Not an ethnic minority group
Weinstock 2011 Type 1 and type 2 diabetes, multi‐ethnic group
Weinstock 2011b Participants had both type 1 and type 2 diabetes
Welch 2011 No clearly defined diabetes health education and both groups culturally adapted
West 2007 Mixed ethnic group and no diabetes health education
West 2008 Partcipants do not have type 2 diabetes
Wheeler 2012 Not an RCT
Williams 2013 For non‐diabetic individuals, trial design
Winston 2009 Conference abstract. No specific ethnic minority group

DM: diabetes mellitus; HE: health education; RCT: randomised controlled trial