Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Ahmedani 2012 | Includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes and does not focus on ethnic group in Pakistan |
Al‐Shookri 2012 | Arab Omanis are not an ethnic minority |
Alexander 2008 | Not a randomised controlled trial (RCT) |
Amano 2007 | Not an ethnic minority group |
Amaoko 2007 | Not clearly defined diabetes health education |
Amaoko 2008 | Outcome assessed only at 6 weeks, not clearly defined diabetes health education |
Andersen 2013 | Excluded if have diabetes |
Anderson 2010 | Multi‐ethnic group |
Arakaki 2009 | No specific ethnic minority group |
Arora 2012 | Not an RCT, includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes |
Barrera 2012 | No outcomes from our protocol |
Batik 2008 | No health education |
Blackwell 2011 | No ethnic group; participants did not have type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) |
Bogner 2010 | Not clearly defined health education |
Bolin 2013 | Not type 2 diabetes, mixed ethnic group |
Borges 2007 | Outcomes assessed at 1 month only |
Boudreau 2011 | No outcomes from our review |
Bravis 2010 | Appears participants were not randomly assigned |
Bray 2013 | Not an RCT |
Brown 2007 | No control group, not an RCT |
Brown 2010 | Not an RCT |
Brown 2011 | All received culturally appropriate health education (HE). Intervention group had nurse case manager |
Calle 2009 | No outcomes specified in our protocol |
Calles‐Escandon 2010 | Intervention not diabetes health education (HE) |
Chan 2009 | Not an ethnic minority group, intervention not culturally adapted |
Choi 2012 | Not an RCT, also this is a pilot study |
Choudhury 2008 | Qualitative study, not an RCT |
Comellas 2010 | No control group, not an RCT. Mutli‐ethnic group |
Cramer 2007 | Not specified by ethnic group |
Crasto 2010 | No specific ethnic minority group |
Crasto 2011 | No ethnic minority group |
Davidson 2007 | No control group, not an RCT |
Davis 2009 | Participants did not have type 2 diabetes |
Davis 2009a | Multi‐ethnic group, no clearly defined ethnic group |
Davis 2009b | Conference abstract for Diabetes Telecare Study (Davis 2009a) |
Davis 2011 | Not an RCT |
Deitrick 2010 | Qualitative study, not an RCT |
Douglas 2013 | Not type 2 diabetes, participants have "impaired glycaemia" |
Eakin 2007 | Any chronic condition, not just type 2 diabetes |
Egede 2010 | No results |
Ell 2009 | Just design, no results |
Ezenwaka 2011 | Not an ethnic minority group |
Fatima 2011 | Cohort study with purposive sampling |
Fernandez 2011 | No clearly defined outcome from protocol, assesses questionnaire validity |
Gerber 2012 | Trial design, plus mixed ethnic group |
Gill 2010 | No control group, not an RCT |
Glasgow 2011 | No specific ethnic minority group |
Henderson 2012 | Study not completed and cultural intervention not clear |
Heudebert 2013 | Abstract of conference only. Does not appear culturally adapted. |
Hill‐Briggs 2007 | Not an RCT |
Hill‐Briggs 2011 | Intervention not culturally adapted |
Hotu 2010 | No health education in intervention |
Ivey 2012 | Not an RCT |
Jernigan 2011 | Not an RCT |
Jones 2008 | Qualitative study, not an RCT |
Kanaya 2012 | Participants do not have type 2 diabetes |
Katula 2011 | Participants did not have type 2 diabetes |
Klug 2008 | Not an RCT |
Latham 2009 | No control group, not an RCT |
Leeman 2008 | No control group, not an RCT |
Lenjawi 2012 | Discussed with KH. Qatar not on list of selected countries and excluded, as study population is the national group not at a disadvantage |
Levetan 2002 | Study included only 86% of African Americans, and the intervention was not culturally relevant |
Liang 2011 | Participants did not all have type 2 diabetes plus did not receive not a culturally tailored intervention |
Lunde 2012 | Participants do not have type 2 diabetes |
Martin 2011 | Just about recruitment, not an RCT |
McCloskey 2009 | Not an RCT |
Metghalchi 2008 | Cohort study, not an RCT |
Mohamed 2013 | Arabs in Qatar not ethnic minority group |
Murrock 2009 | Not health education |
Nam 2010 | Cross‐sectional survey, not an RCT |
Osuna 2011 | Pilot study, not an RCT |
Oyetayo 2011 | Not an RCT |
Palmas 2012 | It is a protocol |
Peña‐Purcell 2011 | Not a randomised controlled trial |
Phumipamorn 2008 | Not an ethnic group, not culturally adapted |
Powers 2009 | This is a protocol |
Prezio 2013 | No clearly defined ethnic group |
Raberg Kjollesdal 2011 | Both type 1 and type 2 diabetes |
Rosal 2009 | No results, just design |
Rothschild 2012 | Study design paper |
Ruelas 2009 | Not clearly defined health education and unsure whether culturally adapted. Both groups had same number of visits |
Ruggiero 2010 | Multi‐ethnic group |
Ruggiero 2010b | No specific ethnic minority group |
Ryan 2013 | Not an RCT (feasibility study), no clearly defined ethnic group |
Saha 2013 | Protocol, not for diabetic individuals |
Salto 2011 | Not an RCT |
Shea 2009 | Type 1 and type 2 diabetes |
Shenoy 2009 | Not an ethnic group, not a culturally tailored intervention |
Shenoy 2010 | Not an ethnic group, intervention not culturally adapted |
Shi 2010 | Not an ethnic minority group |
Skelly 2008 | Not an RCT |
Skoro‐Kondza 2009 | Multi‐ethnic group, not health education |
Sun 2012 | Includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes |
Tang 2010 | Not an RCT |
Tang 2011 | Not an RCT |
Tang 2012 | Not an RCT |
Trief 2013 | Not clear whether only type 2, also mixed ethnic groups |
Utz 2008 | No control group, not an RCT |
Vincent 2008 | Qualitative data for same trial as Vincent 2007 |
Walker 2008 | includes both type 1 and type 2 diabetes and multi‐ethnic group |
Walker 2010 | Participants were not randomly assigned to intervention |
Walker 2011 | Mixed ethnic group |
Wattana 2007 | Not an ethnic minority group |
Weinstock 2011 | Type 1 and type 2 diabetes, multi‐ethnic group |
Weinstock 2011b | Participants had both type 1 and type 2 diabetes |
Welch 2011 | No clearly defined diabetes health education and both groups culturally adapted |
West 2007 | Mixed ethnic group and no diabetes health education |
West 2008 | Partcipants do not have type 2 diabetes |
Wheeler 2012 | Not an RCT |
Williams 2013 | For non‐diabetic individuals, trial design |
Winston 2009 | Conference abstract. No specific ethnic minority group |
DM: diabetes mellitus; HE: health education; RCT: randomised controlled trial