Table 2.
Case No. | Recruitment | Interview Source(s) | Age Decile at Death/Inclusion, y | Sex | Timing of Inclusiona | Request for PAD? | VSED Attempt? | Time Between Attempt and First Interview | Died During Attempt? | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patient | Relative | Physician | Nurse | |||||||||
Group 1: VSED to remain in control (n = 12) | ||||||||||||
2 | NVVE | x | 60s | M | After | Yes | Yes | 3 Months after | Yes | |||
4 | NVVE | x | x | 80s | M | During | No | Yes | Day 4 of attempt | Yes | ||
5 | NVVE | x | x | x | 90s | M | During | Yes | Yes | Day 8 of attempt | Yes | |
6 | Other | x | 80s | F | After | No | Yes | 2 Years after | Yes | |||
7 | NVVE | x | 80s | M | Before | Yes | No | … | NA | |||
10 | NVVE | x | 80s | M | After | Yes | Yes | 1 Year after | Yes | |||
11 | NVVE | x | 70s | F | Before | Yes | No | … | NA | |||
13 | NVVE | x | 90s | F | After | Yes | Yes | 2 Years after | Yes | |||
20 | Other | x | 70s | F | After | Yes | Yes | 4 Years after | Yes | |||
21 | Caregiver | x | 70s | F | Before | Yes | Yes | Day 1 of attempt | Yesb | |||
25 | NVVE | x | 70s | M | Before | Yes | Noc | (4 Months before PAD) | NA | |||
27 | Caregiver | x | 70s | M | After | Yes | Yes | 3 Weeks after | Yes | |||
Group 2: VSED to accelerate natural death (n = 11) | ||||||||||||
8 | NVVE | x | 90s | F | After | Yes | Yes | 8 Months after | Yes | |||
9 | NVVE | x | 70s | F | After | No | Yes | 8 Years after | No | |||
12 | NVVE | x | 80s | F | After | Yes | Yes | 15 Months after | Yes | |||
14 | Caregiver | x | x | x | 90s | F | During | Yes | Yes | Day 1 of attempt | Yes | |
15 | Internet | x | x | 80s | F | Before | Yes | Yes | 4 Months before | Yes | ||
17 | NVVE | x | 90s | M | After | No | Yes | 10 Months after | Yes | |||
18 | Caregiver | x | x | 90s | M | After | No | Yes | 7 Days after | Yes | ||
19 | Other | x | 90s | F | After | Yes | Yes | 2 Years after | Yes | |||
24 | NVVE | x | 80s | M | Before | Yes | No | … | NA | |||
28 | Internet | x | 90s | M | After | Yes | Yes | 4 Months after | Yes | |||
29 | Caregiver | x | x | x | 80s | F | Before | No | Yes | Day 9 of attempt | Yes | |
Group 3: VSED as a more acceptable suicide (n = 6) | ||||||||||||
1 | Caregiver | x | x | x | 60s | F | During | Yes | Yes | 2 Days before | Yes | |
3 | Other | x | 20s | F | After | Yes | Yes | 4 Days after ending VSED | No | |||
16 | NVVE | x | 80s | M | After | No | Yes | 9 Years after | Nob | |||
22 | NVVE | x | 30s | F | Before | Yes | No | … | NA | |||
23 | NVVE | x | 40s | F | After | No | Yes | 17 Months after | No | |||
26 | Internet | x | 30s | F | Before | Yes | Yes | 2 Months before | No |
F = female; M = male; NA = not applicable because VSED was not attempted; NVVE = Nederlandse Vereniging voor Vrijwillige Euthanasie (the Dutch Right-to-Die Association); PAD = physician-assisted dying; VSED = voluntary stopping of eating and drinking.
Relative to VSED attempt.
Died by suicide (ingestion of lethal substances).
Died by PAD.