Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 30;11:420. doi: 10.1186/s40359-023-01317-w

Table 2.

Results of a test of the combined effect of different types of sport skill exercise on executive function interventions

Categories Outcome variables Heterogeneity test Combined effects test
I 2 P SMD 95%CI Z P
Open skills Inhibitory control 91.8% < 0.001 -0.942 (-1.290, -0.594) 5.30 < 0.001
Working memory 93.0% < 0.001 -0.833 (-1.220, -0.447) 4.22 < 0.001
Cognitive flexibility 94.1% < 0.001 -1.116 (-1.658, -0.575) 4.04 < 0.001
Closed skills Inhibitory control 94.9% < 0.001 -0.524 (-0.957, -0.091) 2.37 0.018
Working memory 96.5% < 0.001 -0.539 (-1.158, 0.080) 1.71 0.088
Cognitive flexibility 94.8% < 0.001 -0.854 (-1.353, -0.356) 3.36 0.001
Continuous skills Inhibitory control 97.2% < 0.001 -0.450 (-1.203, 0.303) 1.17 0.242
Working memory 97.6% < 0.001 -0.048 (-1.002, 0.905) 0.10 0.921
Cognitive flexibility 96.3% < 0.001 -1.124 (-1.863, -0.384) 2.98 0.003
Sequential skills Inhibitory control 88.3% < 0.001 -0.834 (-1.090, -0.578) 6.39 < 0.001
Working memory 92.0% < 0.001 -0.889 (-1.224, -0.554) 5.20 < 0.001
Cognitive flexibility 94.1% < 0.001 -0.903 (-1.375, -0.403) 3.76 < 0.001