Table 3.
Possible virus detection methods: how can we detect extraterrestrial viruses?
Virus detection method | Advantages | Challenges |
---|---|---|
Infection | Highly specific for virus identification and host response | 1. Requires correct host 2. Requires suitable conditions |
Virion detection | Unique structures enable direct detection | 1. Virions may not represent active viruses 2. Could produce false positives |
Metagenome sequencing | Very broad net theoretically allowing any virus to be identified |
1. Sequences may not resemble known viruses 2. Nucleic acid may be hard to purify or amplify 3. Exoviruses may not contain nucleic acids |
Virus effects on hosts | May be detectable remotely | 1. May be difficult to differentiate between infected and uninfected hosts 2. No detectable hosts In environment |
Microscopy indicators (SEM, TEM, AFM) | Provide potential indication of viruses to be confirmed by methods above | 1. Typical virion size is small 2. Very high resolution is necessary 3. Morphologies may be indistinct |
Of the currently known methods for virus detection, those suitable for astrobiology applications are challenging to imagine but we can leverage off the suite of methods already in use on Earth.