Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 17;11:e47445. doi: 10.2196/47445

Table 1.

Comparison with similar review articles.

Review title Month and year Scope and coverage Comparison with our review
Vision transformers in Medical Computer Vision—A Contemplative Retrospection [20] March 2022
  • The title is specific to ViTa; however, the full text has a very broad scope with discussions on deep learning, CNNsb, and ViT.

  • It covers different applications in medical computer vision, including the classification of disease, segmentation of tissues, registration tasks in medical images, and image-to-text applications.

  • It does not provide much text on brain cancer applications of ViT.

  • Many recent studies of 2022 are left out as the preprint was released in March 2022.

  • It does not provide a comparative study on the computational complexity of ViT-based models.

  • Our review is also specific to ViT.

  • Our review is specific to brain cancer applications.

  • Our review includes more recent studies on ViT.

  • Our review provides a comparative study of the computational complexity of the ViT-based models.

Transformers in medical imaging: A survey [25] January 2022
  • It is specific to ViT.

  • It has a broad scope as different medical imaging applications are included.

  • It does not include many recent studies on ViT for brain cancer imaging (as the preprint was released in January 2022).

  • Our review is also specific to ViT.

  • Our review is specific to brain cancer applications.

  • Our review includes more recent studies on ViT.

Transformers in Medical Image Analysis: A Review [23] August 2022
  • It is specific to ViT.

  • It has broad scope as different medical imaging applications are included.

  • It provides a descriptive review of ViT techniques for different medical imaging modalities.

  • It does not provide a quantitative analysis of the computational complexity of ViT-based methods.

  • Our review is also specific to ViT.

  • Our review is specific to brain cancer applications.

  • Our review provides a comparative study of the computational complexity of the ViT-based models.

Brain Tumor Diagnosis Using Machine Learning, Convolutional Neural Networks, Capsule Neural Networks and Vision Transformers, Applied to MRIc: A Survey [22] July 2022
  • It covers applications specific to brain tumor segmentation.

  • It has a broad scope, as it includes studies on CNNs, capsule networks, and ViT.

  • It includes only 5 studies on ViT.

  • Many recent studies are left out as it covers only 4 studies from 2022.

  • It provides no quantitative analysis of computational complexity.

  • Our review is also specific to brain cancer and brain tumor.

  • Our review covers more recent studies.

  • Our review includes 22 studies on ViT for brain cancer application.

  • Our review provides a comparative study of the computational complexity of the ViT-based models.

A survey of brain tumor segmentation and classification algorithms [24] September 2021
  • It has a very broad scope as it covers traditional machine learning and deep learning methods.

  • It covers studies until early 2021 only.

  • Our review is specific to ViT.

  • Our review covers more recent studies.

Deep learning for brain tumor segmentation: a survey of state-of-the-art [21] January 2021
  • It has a broad scope as it covers different deep learning methods.

  • Many recent studies are left out.

  • Our review is specific to ViT.

  • Our review covers more recent studies.

aViT: vision transformer.

bCNN: convolutional neural network.

cMRI: magnetic resonance imaging.