Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Dec 1.
Published in final edited form as: Artif Intell Med. 2023 Nov 1;146:102701. doi: 10.1016/j.artmed.2023.102701

Table 1:

Purpose of NLP/ML applications for analyzing PRO data among the 79 studies included in the systematic review*

Classifications Specific roles of NLP/ML tasks Task description N %
Information extraction/text identification 74 93.7
PRO content detection, identification, extraction Detect or identify PRO keywords or terminologies from free text 47 59.5
PRO annotation Perform semi-automated or manual annotation for PROs in free text 37 46.8
PRO affirmation/ negation Declare whether symptoms or symptom-related outcomes exist or equivalent expression or negative statement for having symptoms 38 48.1
Vocabulary mapping Map or assign PROs or PRO-related vocabulary words to appropriate indexes or labels 13 16.5
Classification/phenotyping/clustering 26 32.9
PRO classification Assign or classify extracted PROs into specific categories 16 20.3
PRO phenotyping Indicate specific characteristics of single or multiple PROs features 9 11.4
PRO clustering Identify two or more PROs that are related to each other or co-occur 5 6.3
Develop or validate NLP/ML pipelines 19 24.1
Development of NLP/ML pipelines Develop new NLP/ML pipelines or build NLP software 10 12.7
Evaluation/validation Evaluate and validate the performances of NLP system/pipeline 12 15.2
Risk prediction or stratification for clinical outcomes 25 31.6
Risk prediction Predict the risk of outcomes using extracted PROs based on unstructured narratives 22 27.8
Risk stratification Identify the right level of care and services for distinctive subgroups of patients. 3 3.8
Investigate associations between PROs and clinical outcomes 5 6.3
Relationship detection Detect semantic associations or relationships between unstructured PROs 5 6.3
*

Each study may include multiple study purposes and NLP/ML tasks.