Skip to main content
. 2023 Sep 28;15(12):3065–3074. doi: 10.1111/os.13881

TABLE 3.

The heterogeneity and horizontal pleiotropy tests in the MR analysis.

Exposure Outcome Heterogeneity test Horizontal pleiotropy test
MR–Egger IVW
Cochran's Q p value Cochran's Q p value Egger‐intercept p value
SHBG Pathological fracture with osteoporosis 227.32 0.05 228.57 0.05 5.68E‐03 0.30
Fracture of lumbar spine and pelvis 258.76 1.10E‐03 261.32 9.05E‐04 −4.17E‐03 0.17
Fracture of ribs, sternum and thoracic spine 196.37 0.40 196.43 0.42 −5.36E‐04 0.81
Fracture of neck 184.06 0.63 184.15 0.65 −1.57E‐03 0.77
Fracture of skull and facial bones 234.90 0.02 235.21 0.02 1.36E‐03 0.62
Fracture of femur 219.85 0.08 222.01 0.07 −3.27E‐03 0.17
Fracture of lower leg, including ankle 251.94 2.39E‐03 252.44 2.60E‐03 1.04E‐03 0.54
Fracture of foot, except ankle 208.92 0.19 210.11 0.19 2.59E‐03 0.30
Fracture of shoulder and upper arm 251.79 2.44E‐03 252.46 2.60E‐03 1.55E‐03 0.48
Fracture of forearm 269.55 1.56E‐04 269.84 1.80E‐04 −8.09E‐04 0.65
Fracture at wrist and hand level 220.52 0.07 220.77 0.08 −9.68E‐04 0.64
BT Pathological fracture with osteoporosis 61.40 0.32 62.38 0.32 1.21E‐02 0.34
Fracture of lumbar spine and pelvis 79.09 0.03 79.13 0.03 1.16E‐03 0.88
Fracture of ribs, sternum and thoracic spine 65.80 0.20 66.04 0.22 2.56E‐03 0.65
Fracture of neck 54.12 0.58 56.95 0.51 2.14E‐02 0.10
Fracture of skull and facial bones 63.83 0.25 63.96 0.28 2.12E‐03 0.74
Fracture of femur 65.80 0.20 66.04 0.22 2.56E‐03 0.65
Fracture of lower leg, including ankle 64.03 0.24 67.67 0.18 −6.73E‐03 0.08
Fracture of foot, except ankle 58.98 0.40 59.78 0.41 −5.10E‐03 0.38
Fracture of shoulder and upper arm 86.36 7.29E‐03 86.76 8.56E‐03 2.90E‐03 0.61
Fracture of forearm 101.29 2.77E‐04 104.53 1.75E‐04 6.42E‐03 0.18
Fracture at wrist and hand level 85.58 8.48E‐03 86.03 9.85E‐03 3.10E‐03 0.59

Abbreviation: MR, Mendelian randomization.