Skip to main content
. 2023 Oct 23;3(11):100621. doi: 10.1016/j.crmeth.2023.100621

Table 1.

The comparison of Mol-GDL with SOTAs on seven commonly used datasets, which contain only classification tasks on molecular properties

Dataset BACE BBBP ClinTox SIDER tox21 HIV MUV
No. molecules 1,513 2,039 1,478 1,427 7,831 41,127 93,087
No. average atoms 65(19) 46(21) 50.58(31) 65(93) 36(23) 46(24) 43(10)
No. tasks 1 1 2 27 12 1 17
D-MPNN36 0.809(0.006) 0.710(0.003) 0.906(0.006) 0.570(0.007) 0.759(0.007) 0.771(0.005) 0.786(0.014)
AttentiveFP37 0.784(0.022) 0.643(0.018) 0.847(0.003) 0.606(0.032) 0.761(0.005) 0.757(0.014) 0.766(0.015)
NGramRF38 0.779(0.015) 0.697(0.006) 0.775(0.040) 0.668(0.007) 0.743(0.004) 0.772(0.001) 0.769(0.007)
NGramXGB38 0.791(0.013) 0.691(0.008) 0.875 0.655(0.007) 0.758(0.009) 0.787(0.004) 0.748(0.002)
PretrainGNN39 0.845(0.007) 0.687(0.013) 0.726(0.015) 0.627(0.008) 0.781(0.006) 0.799(0.007) 0.813(0.021)
GROVEbase40 0.826(0.007) 0.700(0.001) 0.812(0.030) 0.648(0.006) 0.743(0.001) 0.625(0.009) 0.673(0.018)
GROVElarge40 0.810(0.014) 0.695(0.001) 0.762(0.037) 0.654(0.001) 0.735(0.001) 0.682(0.011) 0.673(0.018)
GEM41 0.856(0.011) 0.724(0.004) 0.901(0.013) 0.672(0.004) 0.781(0.001) 0.806(0.009) 0.817(0.005)
Mol-GDL 0.863(0.019) 0.728(0.019) 0.966(0.002) 0.831(0.002) 0.794(0.005) 0.808(0.007) 0.675(0.014)

Note that the subindex indicates standard deviation values. For instance, the element 65(19) means the number of average atoms in BACE is 65, with 19 as its standard deviation. Bolding indicates best results.