Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 18;66:102309. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2023.102309

Table 2.

Descriptions of intervention and control groups.

Study Intervention purpose mHealth delivery mode mHealth component Other components Behaviour change technique category (from BCTTv1)a Theory Comparison groups
Targeted adults from the general population
Ahtinen 2013 Stress management App (Oiva)
  • 1.

    Text and audio exercises for healthy body and mind with immediate graphical feedback

  • 2.

    Progress tracking

  • 3.

    Diary writing to encourage self-reflection and emotional awareness

Not reported
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviours

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 9.

    Comparison of outcomes

  • 10.

    Reward and threat

  • 11.

    Regulation

Acceptance and commitment therapy theory None
Van Drongelen 2014; 2016 Sleep improvement and fatigue reduction App (More energy);
Project website
  • 1.

    App: personalised advice on physical activity, diet, and sleep based on flight schedule characteristics

  • 2.

    Project website: educational videos and audio files

Not reported
  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported Project website
Du 2016 Healthy lifestyle promotion App (Fittle)
  • 1.

    Team or individual challenges on physical activity, diet, and stress with progress tracking

  • 2.

    Feedback on daily activities provided by an automated conversational agent

Not reported
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 6.

    Shaping knowledge

Theory of planned behaviour;
Social cognitive theory
  • 1.

    ePaper solo condition: a PDF version of the wellness programme

  • 2.

    ePaper Team condition: a pdf version of the programme and grouped participants into 3 teams

Zhang 2017 Coronary heart disease prevention App (Care4Heart);
SMS
  • 1.

    App: educational content on heart disease, physical activity, diet, smoking, and stress; tools including BMI and daily caloric-intake calculation, and 10-year coronary heart disease risk prediction; demonstrative relaxation video clips

  • 2.

    SMS: educational content on coronary heart disease prevention

Not reported
  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 7.

    Association

  • 11.

    Regulation

Health belief model Website links for health information
Comulada 2017; 2018 Healthy lifestyle promotion App (Ohmage)
  • 1.

    Four daily Ecological Momentary Assessment prompts for diet, physical activity, sleep, and mood self-monitoring

  • 2.

    Food photo diaries

Face-to-face support from researchers to review the progress at 3 and 6 months
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported None
Ashton 2017 Healthy lifestyle promotion Website;
App (UP);
Wearables (JAWBONE);
Social media (Facebook)
  • 1.

    Website: educational content on physical activity, diet, and stress

  • 2.

    Wearables and the associated app: goal setting and physical activity, diet, sleep, and mood self-monitoring; motivational messages and educational content to improve step counts and sleep patterns

  • 3.

    Social media: weekly interactions with other participants and the research team

Weekly face-to-face support from reseachers and physical education teachers on tailored dietary goals and physical activity;
Resistance training band;
Dinner disc, a visual guide to assists in controlling the portion size of food
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviours

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 10.

    Reward and threat

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalization

Self-cognitive theory;
Self-determination theory
Wait-list control
Baek 2018 Stress management App
  • 1.

    Personalised psychoeducation content and behavioural techniques based on mental health status, stress level, and lifestyles (smoking, physical activity, diet, and sleep)

  • 2.

    Daily mood and lifestyle self-monitoring

  • 3.

    Forum function for anonymous sharing of problems and discussion of topics related to common stressors among employees

  • 4.

    A tool for nearby mental health professionals;

  • 5.

    Voice-guided relaxation training

Not reported
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviours

  • 5.

    Natural consequences

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported None
Podina 2018 Weight management App (SIGMA);
Wearable (Pedometer)
  • 1.

    App: psychoeducational content on diet, physical activity, and weight; games for coping strategies; breathing exercise; feedback report based on self-monitoring data and progress

  • 2.

    Pedometer: physical activity and diet tracking

Not reported
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalisation

  • 18.

    Gamification

Cognitive behavioural therapy’s cognitive ABC model (Antecedents—Beliefs—Consequences) None
Gleen 2019 Alzheimer’s disease prevention App (Nuerotrack MHP)
  • 1.

    Psychoeducational content on lifestyle behaviours related to cognitive decline and general behaviour change concepts

  • 2.

    Physical activity and diet self-monitoring

  • 3.

    Audio-guided meditation instructions: mindfulness, stress, and sleep

  • 4.

    In-app chat with a health coach for participants' inquiries

Not reported
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 11.

    Regulation

Not reported None
Jiang 2019 Coronary heart disease prevention App (Care4Heart);
SMS
  • 1.

    App: educational content on heart disease, physical activity, diet, smoking, and stress; tools including BMI and daily caloric-intake calculation, and 10-year coronary heart disease risk prediction; demonstrative relaxation video clips

  • 2.

    SMS: educational content on coronary heart disease prevention

Not reported
  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 7.

    Association

  • 11.

    Regulation

Health belief model None
Mhurchu 2019 Healthy lifestyle promotion App (OL@-OR @);
Website
  • 1.

    App: personalised goal setting and physical activity, diet, and sleep self-monitoring; in-app notifications for behaviour change reminders and culturally tailored messages on physical activity, diet, stress, sleep, weight, and smoking; referrals to friends-family members to join the programme

  • 2.

    Website

Not reported
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 17.

    Personalisation

  • 18.

    Gamification

Theoretical domain framework Sham control: a control version of the OL@-OR@ app for data collection
Oftedal 2019 Healthy lifestyle promotion App (Balanced);
SMS
  • 1.

    App: educational content and goal setting on physical activity, diet, and sleep with immediate feedback; physical activity, diet, sleep, and weight self-monitoring

  • 2.

    SMS: weekly educational content on weight loss

Participant handbook;
Weekly email summaries based on app entries
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 11.

    Personalization

Self-cognitive theory;
Self-regulatory theory
Wait-list control
Brindal 2019 Weight management App (MotiMate)
  • 1.

    Weight, diet, physical activity self-monitoring with immediate feedback

  • 2.

    Weekly summaries of self-monitoring data in terms of success and areas for improvement

  • 3.

    Mood monitoring with a workshop feature to develop relevant coping skills

Phone support from registered dietitian and/or psychologists if participants classified as weight gain and/or highly negative mood
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Conservation of resources; Self-regulation theory Sham control: a control version of MotiMate app with limited feedback and no encouraging features
Lyzwinski 2019 Weight management App (My Student Mindfulness)
  • 1.

    Educational content on stress, healthy lifestyles, mindfulness, breathing, and meditation

  • 2.

    Daily informal mindfulness practice and journaling

  • 3.

    Games for stress reduction

  • 4.

    App notifications during eating times to maximise mindful eating opportunities

Not reported
  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviours

  • 7.

    Association

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 11.

    Regulation

Not reported
  • 1.

    An electronic diary for self-monitoring

  • 2.

    Website links to the World Health Organization's guidelines on physical activity and diet

Torres 2020 Employee wellness promotion Wearables (Fitbit);
Website (Qualtrics)
  • 1.

    Wearable: physical activity and sleep tracking

  • 2.

    Website: daily meal logging

Not reported
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

Not reported None
Bonn 2022 Healthy lifestyle promotion App (Health Integrator)
  • 1.

    Six domains: diet, physical activity, sleep, stress, alcohol, and tobacco use

  • 2.

    Weekly personalised goal setting with health coaching and progress tracking

  • 3.

    Free offers for different apps based on different domain topics

Phone support from a health coach every 4 weeks throughout the intervention
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported Wait-list control
Cantisano 2022 Healthy lifestyle promotion Social media (WhatsApp, YouTube channel);
App (Headspace, Insight timer, Fabulous)
  • 1.

    WhatsApp: reminders, challenges, or continuation messages on physical activity, diet and psychological wellbeing

  • 2.

    YouTube channel: informative capsules or videos on healthy eating and physical activity

  • 3.

    Apps: options including healthy eating, mindfulness, and physical activity

Three sessions of mindful practice via Zoom
  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 7.

    Association

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

Not reported None
Yuan 2022 Healthy lifestyle promotion App (My Wellness Coach)
  • 1.

    Personalised goal setting for lifestyle behaviour change

  • 2.

    Educational content on physical activity, diet, spirituality, resilience, relationships, sleep, and environment

Five people used the app in the group setting led by a health coach; 36 people used the app individually with one onboarding session and one Q&A session
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Health belief model; Theory of planned behaviour;
Transtheoretical model
None
Wilson 2023 Cardiovascular disease prevention App (TeamBuildr)
  • 1.

    Personalised physical activity programme by a novel evidence-based allocation algorithm.

  • 2.

    Weekly education content on healthy eating, physical activity, and sleep hygiene

  • 3.

    Daily goal setting for healthy eating and sleep hygiene

Not reported
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported Wait-list control
Targeted people at risk ofnon-communicable diseases and mental disorders
Napolitano 2013 Weight management Social media (Facebook);
SMS;
Wearables (Pedometer)
  • 1.

    Social media: education content on self-monitoring, physical activity, diet, stress, social support and relapse prevention; healthy activity event invitations

  • 2.

    SMS: diet, physical activity, and weight self-monitoring with immediate feedback; educational content on high risk behaviours; weekly personalised feedback report on weight, calories intake, and physical activity

  • 3.

    Wearables: physical activity tracking

Face-to-face support from researchers on weight loss;
Weekly support from support buddy to boost self-monitoring compliance
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported Wait-list control
Norton 2015; Hartin 2016; Schiwal 2020 Alzheimer’s disease prevention App (The Grey Matters);
Wearables
(Nike monitor);
Website
  • 1.

    App: educational content and daily self-report on physical activity, diet, social, sleep, cognitive, and stress; feedback on performance

  • 2.

    Wearables: physical activity tracking

  • 3.

    Website: educational content as the app provided and supporting materials for the use of study technologies

Weekly email or text message support from a health coach (student intern)
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 5.

    Natural consequences

  • 10.

    Reward and threat

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalisation

  • 18.

    Gamification

Transtheoretical model of change Wait-list control
Block 2015 Diabetes prevention Website (Alive-PD);
SMS;
App (Alive-PD)
  • 1.

    App and website: weekly personalised goals setting and progress tracking on diet, physical activity, and psychosocial; interactions with other participants by sending motivational and personalised messages or inviting them to receive weekly emails with educational content

  • 2.

    SMS: bi-weekly educational content with quizzes covering physical activity, diet, stress, and sleep

Interactive Voice Response technology: personalised phone coaching every 2 weeks;
Personalised education materials
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviour

  • 10.

    Reward and threat

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalization

  • 18.

    Gamification

Learning theory;
Models centreing on cues and triggers;
Social cognitive theory;
Theory of planned behaviour;
Behavioural economics;
Positive psychology
Wait-list control
Lin 2015 Weight management SMS
  • 1.

    Goal setting on physical activity and diet

  • 2.

    Educational content on cognitive, behaviours, and emotions

  • 3.

    Daily interactive messages for self-reporting current weight, motivation level, or a specific health behaviour with immediate feedback

Face-to-face support from registered dietitian-physicians (baseline and at 6 months) on weight control plan, feedback, or health status
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 7.

    Association

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Health belief model;
Transtheoretical model of change;
Self-regulation theory
Standard care: two dietitian visits and one study physician visit; education materials; a digital pedometer
Mattila 2016; Jarvela- Reijonen 2018; Jarvela- Reijonen 2020 Psychological flexibility improvement App (Oiva)
  • 1.

    Text and audio exercise on healthy body and mind with immediate graphical feedback

  • 2.

    Progress tracking

  • 3.

    Diary writing to encourage self-reflection and emotional awareness

Not reported
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviours

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 9.

    Comparison of outcomes

  • 10.

    Reward and threat

  • 11.

    Regulation

Acceptance and commitment therapy theory After intervention, one group session about acceptance and commitment therapy and Internet-based lifestyle coaching programme
Stahl 2020 Depression prevention App (diary-like app)
  • 1.

    Personalised goals on physical activity, diet, and sleep

  • 2.

    Physical activity, diet, and sleep self-monitoring with feedback

Weekly phone support from researchers to boost confidence and intrinsic motivation;
Printed educational materials
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 8.

    Repetition and substitution

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported Standard care: medical or grief specialty care as needed
Puntpanich 2020 Cardiovascular disease prevention App (Chicken LOF) Physical activity, mood, sleep, and diet self-monitoring via a virtual chick Face-to-face support from physicians at baseline to provide personalised advice on diet and physical activity
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 11.

    Regulation

Not reported Standard care: general physical consultation on diet and physical activity
Duncan 2020;
Fenton 2021
Weight management App (Balanced);
Wearables (Fitbit);
SMS;
Calorie counting platform
  • 1.

    App: educational content and goal setting on physical activity, diet, sleep with immediate feedback; physical activity, diet, sleep, and weight self-monitoring

  • 2.

    SMS: weekly educational content on weight loss (other intervention group only had contents on physical activity and diet)

Face-to-face support from registered dietitian at baseline to get personalised dietary advice;
Body weight scale;
Participant handbook;
Weekly email summaries
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 7.

    Association

  • 11.

    Personalisation

Self-cognitive theory;
Self-regulatory theory
Wait-list control
Nezami 2021 Weight management App (PATH, Fitbit);
Wearable (Fitbit);
SMS
  • 1.

    App: educational content on physical activity, diet, sedentary behaviour, stress management, and relapse prevention; daily self-monitoring data with goal tracking and automated feedback

  • 2.

    Wearable: physical activity and diet goal setting and tracking

  • 3.

    SMS: motivation, feedback, and reminders (3–4 times per week)

Body weight scale
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 10.

    Reward and threat

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Social cognitive theory Shame control: the only difference, compared to intervention group was the dietary self-monitoring tool
Drew 2021; Young 2021; Drew 2022 Weight management Website (SHED-IT);
SMS;
App (MyFitness Pal) ∗ optional
  • 1.

    Website: educational content on weight, physical activity, diet, sleep, and cognitive behaviour therapy-based mental fitness

  • 2.

    SMS: weekly educational messages related to website content

Phone support from registered psychologists if they had symptom exacerbation or any suicidal ideation (7 times maximum);
Programme handbook;
Logbook for recoding the progress
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Social cognitive theory Wait-list control
Napolitano 2021 Weight management App (BeFAB);
Social media (Facebook);
SMS
  • 1.

    App: educational content and in-app messages on physical activity, diet, weight, stress; weight self-monitoring with feedback; weekly goal setting on physical activity and diet

  • 2.

    Social media: interactions with other participants and the research team

  • 3.

    SMS: weekly motivational messages and reminders on educational content or weekly goal update

Not reported
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 6.

    Comparison of behaviours

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 18.

    Gamification

Not reported Standard care: educational materials on healthy behaviours and weight monitoring
Didehban 2022 Metabolic syndrome prevention SMS Daily messages on physical activity, diet, or stress Not reported
  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 5.

    Natural consequences

Not reported No-intervention
Nakata 2022 Weight management App (CALO mama Plus)
  • 1.

    Daily tracking of weight, diet, exercise, mood, and sleep quality with graphic trends and app feedback

  • 2.

    Weight-loss courses and auto-set weight-loss goals and targets of energy, nutrient, and physical activity based on user data.

  • 3.

    Meal logging with AI detection and nutrient calculation.

Not reported
  • 1.

    Goals and planning

  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

  • 17.

    Personalisation

Not reported Wait-list control
Thorgeirsson 2022 Weight management App (Sidekick)
  • 1.

    Gamification tasks in diet, physical activity, and stress management

  • 2.

    Visual representation of the users’ performance and progress

  • 3.

    Social interactions with the group members

Weekly or bi-weekly fitness coaching and monthly nutrition and health education class
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 6.

    Demonstration of the behaviour

  • 11.

    Regulation

  • 18.

    Gamification

Not reported Standard care: weekly or bi-weekly fitness coaching and monthly nutrition and health education class
Jensen 2023 Weight management SMS
  • 1.

    Self-monitoring: # of servings of red foods consumed, # of servings of green foods consumed, mins of physical activity engagement, current weight, hours of sleep

  • 2.

    Four messages per day on diet, physical activity, and sleep utilising motivational interviewing principles

Face-to-face support from a clinical psychology doctoral student and a clinician at baseline to provide motivational interviewing and skills of weight control and sleep improvement
  • 2.

    Feedback and monitoring

  • 3.

    Social support

  • 4.

    Shaping knowledge

Not reported Sham control: the only difference, compared to the intervention group, was the control group did not receive any content on sleep component.
a

The numbers in the "Behavior Change Technique Category" column correspond to the categories defined in the Behavior Change Technique Taxonomy version 1 (BCTTv1) with two supplementary categories: personalisation and gamification.