Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 4;18(12):e0294356. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0294356

Table 1. Characteristics of participating women according to each MHT use.

Non-MHT Tibolone Combined Estrogen plus progestin by the manufacturer Oral Estrogen Combined Estrogen plus progestin by the physician Topical estrogen Total
Nunber of women 1,004,034 192,671 128,168 52,404 6,427 2,041 1,385,745
Median age (years) 58 [52–64] 53 [50–57] 52 [50–56] 53 [49–57] 54 [51–59] 53 [50–57] 56 [52–62]
Age at inclusion (years)
 40~49 84,417 (8.4) 33,788 (17.5) 29,306 (22.9) 13,632 (26) 1,123 (17.5) 430 (21.1) 162,696 (11.7)
 50~59 484,104 (48.2) 125,909 (65.3) 85,192 (66.5) 29,244 (55.8) 3,795 (59) 1,250 (61.2) 729,494 (52.6)
 60~69 301,557 (34.7) 29,170 (15.4) 12,598 (9.9) 7,794 (15.4) 1,313 (21.1) 326 (16.3) 352,758 (28.3)
 70~ 133,956 (13.3) 3,804 (2) 1,072 (0.8) 1,734 (3.3) 196 (3) 35 (1.7) 140,797 (10.2)
Median BMI (kg/m2) 24 [22.1–26.1] 23.5 [21.8–25.4] 23.1 [21.5–25] 23.7 [22–25.7] 23.3 [21.6–25.3] 23.7 [21.9–25.6] 23.8 [21.9–25.9]
BMI (kg/m2)
 <18.5 18,791 (1.9) 3,309 (1.7) 2,568 (2) 764 (1.5) 133 (2.1) 45 (2.2) 25,610 (1.9)
 18.5–22.9 337,118 (34.3) 77,308 (40.5) 57,623 (45.3) 19,199 (37) 2,663 (41.8) 760 (37.5) 494,671 (36.3)
 23–24.9 260,332 (26.5) 52,950 (27.8) 34,153 (26.8) 14,541 (28) 1,765 (27.7) 534 (26.4) 364,275 (26.7)
 25–29.9 325,102 (33) 52,386 (27.5) 30,410 (23.9) 15,690 (30.2) 1,669 (26.2) 629 (31) 425,886 (31.3)
 ≥30 42,479 (4.3) 4,828 (2.5) 2,512 (2) 1,762 (3.4) 146 (2.3) 58 (2.9) 51,785 (3.8)
SES
 Mid~high SES 960,866 (95.7) 185,728 (96.4) 124,928 (97.5) 50,919 (97.2) 6,266 (97.5) 1,982 (97.1) 1,330,689 (96)
 Low SES 43,168 (4.3) 6,943 (3.6) 3,240 (2.5) 1,485 (2.8) 161 (2.5) 59 (2.9) 55,056 (4)
Region
 Urban area 294,903 (29.4) 59,839 (31.1) 43,287 (33.8) 16,458 (31.4) 3,244 (50.5) 921 (45.1) 418,652 (30.2)
 Rural area 709,131 (70.6) 132,832 (68.9) 84,881 (66.2) 35,946 (68.6) 3,183 (49.5) 1,120 (54.9) 967,093 (69.8)
CCI
 0 656,540 (65.4) 130,604 (67.8) 90,490 (70.6) 36,399 (69.5) 4,416 (68.7) 1,327 (65) 919,776 (66.4)
 1 199,130 (19.8) 37,813 (19.6) 23,407 (18.3) 9,649 (18.4) 1,219 (19) 383 (18.8) 271,601 (19.6)
 ≥2 148,364 (14.8) 24,254 (12.6) 14,271 (11.1) 6,356 (12.1) 792 (12.3) 331 (16.2) 194,368 (14)
Parity (years)
 0 or not respond 164,289 (16.4) 29,963 (15.6) 16,060 (12.5) 10,997 (21) 1,267 (19.7) 449 (22) 223,025 (16.1)
 1 59,267 (5.9) 16,739 (8.7) 13,332 (10.4) 4,005 (7.6) 471 (7.3) 160 (7.8) 93,974 (6.8)
 2 659,839 (74.7) 128,551 (73.4) 89,322 (75.2) 32,210 (68.2) 4,030 (69.9) 1,229 (66.9) 915,181 (74.3)
 ≥3 120,639 (12) 17,418 (9) 9,454 (7.4) 5,192 (9.9) 659 (10.3) 203 (9.9) 153,565 (11.1)
Age at menarche (years)
 <13 156,222 (15.6) 27,914 (14.6) 18,258 (14.3) 9,606 (18.6) 1,193 (18.7) 379 (18.8) 213,572 (15.5)
 ≥13 843,102 (84.4) 163,242 (85.4) 109,174 (85.7) 42,125 (81.4) 5,179 (81.3) 1,637 (81.2) 1,164,459 (84.5)
Age at menopause (years)
 40–44 120,211 (12) 23,115 (12) 14,382 (11.2) 11,294 (21.6) 821 (12.8) 402 (19.7) 170,225 (12.3)
 45–49 289,518 (28.8) 62,716 (32.6) 42,933 (33.5) 18,587 (35.5) 2,049 (31.9) 738 (36.2) 416,541 (30.1)
 50–54 506,064 (55.3) 92,258 (51.8) 62,335 (52.1) 19,965 (40.1) 3,039 (51.4) 777 (40.5) 684,438 (53.8)
 55- 88,241 (8.8) 14,582 (7.6) 8,518 (6.6) 2,558 (4.9) 518 (8.1) 124 (6.1) 114,541 (8.3)
Smoking
 Never 915,250 (96.4) 173,854 (93.8) 116,024 (93.5) 47,863 (95) 5,923 (95.6) 1,876 (96.3) 1,260,790 (95.7)
 Past 9,652 (1) 3,162 (1.7) 2,264 (1.8) 703 (1.4) 85 (1.4) 30 (1.5) 15,896 (1.2)
 Current 24,678 (2.6) 8,380 (4.5) 5,801 (4.7) 1,813 (3.6) 185 (3) 43 (2.2) 40,900 (3.1)
Alcohol (per week)
 None 814,065 (85.4) 144,807 (77.6) 94,626 (75.8) 40,485 (79.7) 5,160 (82.7) 1,627 (82.3) 1,100,770 (83.2)
 ~2/week 119,064 (12.5) 35,528 (19) 25,781 (20.7) 8,948 (17.6) 951 (15.2) 310 (15.7) 190,582 (14.4)
 3~6/week 14,736 (1.6) 4,853 (2.6) 3,523 (2.8) 971 (1.9) 90 (1.5) 30 (1.5) 24,203 (1.8)
 Daily 5,325 (0.6) 1,492 (0.8) 900 (0.7) 375 (0.7) 39 (0.6) 10 (0.5) 8,141 (0.6)
Physical exercise (per week)
 None 626,662 (65.6) 110,995 (59.5) 74,801 (59.9) 30,285 (59.7) 3,563 (57.1) 1,036 (52.7) 847,342 (63.9)
 1~2 156,356 (16.4) 35,585 (19.1) 24,376 (19.5) 9,746 (19.2) 1,220 (19.6) 426 (21.7) 227,709 (17.2)
 3~4 86,645 (9.1) 21,377 (11.5) 14,543 (11.6) 5,609 (11.1) 804 (12.9) 289 (14.7) 129,267 (9.8)
 5~6 28,987 (3) 7,032 (3.8) 4,764 (3.8) 1,785 (3.5) 239 (3.8) 84 (4.3) 42,891 (3.2)
 Daily 56,123 (5.9) 11,570 (6.2) 6,361 (5.1) 3,316 (6.5) 410 (6.6) 131 (6.7) 77,911 (5.9)
Period from menopause to inclusion (years)
 <5 388,428 (38.7) 111,808 (58) 87,230 (68.1) 27,330 (52.2) 3,306 (51.4) 1,039 (50.9) 619,141 (44.7)
 5~9 209,061 (20.8) 44,237 (23) 25,390 (19.8) 13,075 (25) 1,541 (24) 538 (26.4) 293,842 (21.2)
 10~ 406,545 (40.5) 36,626 (19) 15,548 (12.1) 11,999 (22.9) 1,580 (24.6) 464 (22.7) 472,762 (34.1)

BMI, Body mass index, CCI, Charlson comorbidity index; MHT, menopausal hormone therapy; SES, socioeconomic status

Data are expressed as the number (%) or median [25th percentile, 75th percentile].