Table 2.
Location of macroscopic cranial and postcranial osseous lesions attributed to infantile scurvy described in the primary paleopathological literature12,35–41,46,47,52.
| Skeletal features | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diagnostic strength | Lesion location | Lesion type and distribution | Anatomical connection: musculature (new features only) | Anatomical connection: vasculature (new features only) |
| Diagnostic | Cranial | |||
| Sphenoid bone: greater wings (lateral and cerebral surfaces) | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Sphenoid bone: lesser wings | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Sphenoid bone: body | SPNBF | |||
| Sphenoid bone: pterygoid fossae/plates | Bilateral and symmetrical Abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Sphenoid bone: foramen rotundum (cerebral surface of the greater wings) | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF | |||
| Sphenoid bone: foramen ovale (cerebral surface of the greater wings) | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF | Temporalis muscle (indirect) with masticatory function; Tensor veli palatini muscle (external) with deglutition function | Accessory meningeal artery and sphenoid emissary vein | |
| Sphenoid bone: foramen spinosum (cerebral surface of the greater wings) | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF | Tensor veli palatini muscle (external and indirect) with deglutition function | Middle meningeal artery and vein | |
| Occipital bone: external surface of partes laterales and pars basilaris | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF (except for pars basilaris) | Rectus capitis lateralis and rectus capitis posterior major muscles (partes laterales of the occipital bone); rectus capitis anterior and longus capitis muscles (pars basilaris of the occipital bone)—Postural muscles for flexion, rotation, extension of the head | Vertebral artery, occipital artery, ascending cervical artery, inferior thyroid artery | |
| Temporal bones: lateral surface of the squama | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Zygomatic bones (posteromedial, and lateral surface) | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and /or SPNBF | |||
| Zygomatic bones (orbital surface) | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and /or SPNBF | Extraocular muscles for internal eye movements | Lacrimal artery, ophthalmic artery, and infraorbital artery | |
| Maxilla: anterior surface/infraorbital foramina and posterior surface | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Maxilla and palatine processes: hard palate surface | Abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone extending markedly into the posterior portion of the palate with spiculated bone | |||
| Mandible: medial surface of the ramus/coronoid process | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Mandible mylohyoid line | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF | |||
| Mandible: superior and inferior mental spines | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF | Genioglossus muscle (superior spine); Geniohyoid muscle (inferior spine) for tong movements and deglutition | Lingual artery | |
| Post-cranial | ||||
| Scapula: supraspinous fossa and infraspinatus fossa | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | |||
| Scapula: axillary margins | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF | Teres major and subscapularis muscles (rotator cuff complex) | Subscapular artery branches of the axillary artery | |
| Ilium: gluteal and medial surface | Bilateral and symmetrical abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and/or SPNBF; vascular impressions | |||
| Highly consistent/typical | Cranial | |||
| Ectocranial surface of cranial vault (frontal bone, parietals and occipital bone) |
Bilateral (except for frontal bone) abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical with asymmetrical localized SPNBF§ (especially in correspondence of the bosses) and ABVI; no thickening of the diploe |
|||
| Frontal bone (orbital roof) | Bilateral abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone and asymmetrical localized SPNBF§§ (i.e., residual haematoma); vascular impressions; no thickening of the diploe | |||
| Post-cranial | ||||
| Ribs: costochondral joints | Flaring | |||
| Post cranial skeleton: metaphyseal of long bones | Abnormal porosity < 1 mm in diameter penetrating cortical bone extending beyond 10 mm from the plate | |||
| Long bones: diaphysis | Bilateral and symmetrical ossified haematomas | |||
| Consistent with | Cranial | |||
| Endocranial surface | PADM; ABVI | |||
| Post-cranial | ||||
| Ribs: shaft | SPNBF | |||
| Long bones: diaphysis | Bilateral and symmetrical SPNBF | |||
| Long bones: metaphyseal enlargement | ||||
| Radiographic features | ||||
| White line of Fränkel | ||||
| Scurvy line (or Trümmerfeld zone) | ||||
| Pelkan spur | ||||
| Corner sign of Park | ||||
| Long bones groundglass osteopenia | ||||
| Postcranial skeleton: diaphysis long bones (upper and lower limbs) | Bilateral and symmetrical pathological SPNBF (> 2 mm in thickness) | |||
| Metaphyseal enlargment | ||||
Details on lesion type and distribution are provided. Further macroscopic skeletal features with details about vasculature and musculature connection and derived from the present study are in italics. Proposed diagnostic strength was established according to the modified Istanbul protocol48. Radiological findings of the long bones evaluated in clinical practice are also included21,24,32–34,49,50.
SPNBF, subperiosteal new bone formation.
ABVI, abnormal blood vessel impressions120,121.
PADM, periosteal apposition of the dura madre121.
§The connective tissue is the pericranium.
§§The connective tissue is the periorbita.