Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 20;11:e47833. doi: 10.2196/47833

Table 1.

Baseline characteristics of BGa level-based studies (N=10).

First author (year), country Data source Sample size Demographic information Object; setting Model; PHb (minutes); input Performance metrics
Patients, n Data points, n
Pérez-Gandía (2010), Spain [20] CGMc device 15 728 d T1DMe; out Models: NNMf, ARMg PH: 15, 30 Input: CGM data RMSEh, delay
Prendin (2021) United States [21] CGM device Real (n=141) 350,000 Age T1DM; out ARM, autoregressive moving average (ARMA), autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA), SVMi, RFj feed-forward neural network (fNN), long short-term memory (LSTM) PH: 30 Input: CGM data RMSE, coefficient of determination (COD) sensibility, delay, precision F1 score, time gain
Zhu (2020) England [22] Ohio T1DM, UVA/Padova T1D Real (n=6), simulated (n=10) 1,036,800 T1DM; out DRNNk, NNM, SVM, ARM PH:30 Input: BG level, meals, exercise, meal times RMSE, mean absolute relative difference (MARD) time gain
D'Antoni (2020), Italy [49] Ohio T1DM 6 Age, sex ratio T1DM; out ARJNNl, RF, SVM, autoregression (AR), one symbolic model (SAX), recurrent neural network (RNN), one neural network model (NARX), jump neural network (JNN), delayed feed-forward neural network model (DFFNN) PH: 15, 30 Input: CGM data RMSE
Amar (2020), Israel [50] CGM device, insulin pump 141 1,592,506 Age, sex ratio, weight, BMI, duration of DM T1DM; in ARM, gradually connected neural network (GCN), fully connected (FC [neural network]), light gradient boosting machine (LCBM), RF PH: 30, 60 Input: CGM data RMSE, Clarke error grid (CEG)
Li (2020), England [51] UVA/Padova T1D Simulated (n=10) 51,840 T1DM; out GluNet, NNM, SVM, latent variable with exogenous input (LVX), ARM PH: 30, 60 Input: BG level, meals, exercise RMSE, MARD, time lag
Zecchin (2012), Italy [52] UVA/Padova T1D, CGM device Simulated (n=20), real (n=15) T1DM; out Neural network–linear prediction algorithm (NN-LPA), NN, ARM PH: 30 Input: meals, insulin RMSE, energy of second-order differences (ESOD), time gain, J index
Mohebbi (2020), Denmark [53] Cornerstones4Care platform Real (n=50 T1DM; in LSTM, ARIMA PH: 15, 30, 45, 60, 90 RMSE, MAE
Daniels (2022), England [54] CGM device Real (n=12) Sex ratio T1DM; out Convolutional recurrent neural network (CRNN), SVM PH: 30, 45, 60, 90, 120 Input: BG level, insulin, meals, exercise RMSE, MAE, CEG, time gain
Alfian (2020), Korea [55] CGM device Real (n=12) 26,723 SVM, k-nearest neighbor k-nearest neighbor (kNN), DTm, RF, AdaBoost, XGBoostn, NNM PH: 15, 30 Input: CGM data RMSE, glucose-specific root mean square error (gRMSE), R2 score, mean absolute percentage error (MAPE)

aBG: blood glucose.

bPH: prediction horizon.

cCGM: continuous glucose monitoring.

dNot applicable.

eT1DM: type 1 diabetes mellitus.

fNNM: neural network model.

gARM: autoregression model.

hRMSE: root mean square error.

iSVM: support vector machine.

jRF: random forest.

kDRNN: dilated recurrent neural network.

lARJNN: ARTiDe jump neural network.

mDT: decision tree.

nXGBoost: Extreme Gradient Boosting.