Table 2.
Advantages and limitations of different methods of exogenous DNA transfer. Single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA)
Category | Method | Advantages | Limitations |
Transformation | Natural | Deliver as ssDNA and technically simple | Necessary genes only possessed by a small number of bacteria |
Chemical | High transfer efficiency and technically simple | Delivered as dsDNA and may lyse recipient cell membrane | |
Electroporation | High transfer efficiency | Delivered as dsDNA and may lyse recipient cell membrane | |
Biolistic | Novel | Delivered as dsDNA and requires expensive equipment | |
Sonoporation | High transfer efficiency | Delivered as dsDNA | |
Tribos | Novel and technically simple | Delivered as dsDNA | |
Conjugation | Conjugative transposons | Delivered as ssDNA and wide host range | Cell numbers cannot be recovered prior to chromosomal insertion, often have preferred insertion sites |
Suicide plasmid vectors | Delivered as ssDNA and easily customised in well characterised donor | Cell numbers cannot be recovered prior to chromosomal insertion | |
Shuttle vectors | Delivered as ssDNA, easily customised in well characterised donor and transconjugant population recoverable | Can be difficult to eliminate from bacteria once established | |
Transduction | Very high transfer efficiency | Establishing for a new strain is very time consuming |