Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 6;13:21472. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-48462-1

Table 5.

Evaluation results of CEC 2017 test suite.

Peoa Rsa Mpa Tsa Woa Mvo Gwo Tlbo Gsa Pso Ga
C17-F1 Mean 1.00 e+02 8.75 e+09 4.15 e+07 1.50 e+09 1.68 e+07 1.13 e+07 8.68 e+07 1.37 e+08 1.13 e+07 1.13 e+07 2.14 e+07
Best 1.00 e+02 7.59 e+09 1.31 e+04 3.19 e+08 4.99 e+06 1.11 e+04 2.73 e+04 5.63 e+07 3.65 e+03 3.86 e+03 9.27 e+06
Worst 1.00 e+02 1.04 e+10 1.51 e+08 3.25 e+09 4.51 e+07 4.11 e+07 3.15 e+08 3.04 e+08 4.11 e+07 4.11 e+07 5.24 e+07
Std 0.00 e+00 1.38 e+09 7.90 e+07 1.40 e+09 2.05 e+07 2.15 e+07 1.65 e+08 1.22 e+08 2.15 e+07 2.15 e+07 2.25 e+07
Median 1.00 e+02 8.49 e+09 7.60 e+06 1.22 e+09 8.60 e+06 2.08 e+06 1.59 e+07 9.44 e+07 2.07 e+06 2.08 e+06 1.20 e+07
Rank 1 11 7 10 5 4 8 9 2 3 6
C17-F3 Mean 3.00 e+02 8.65 e+03 1.60 e+03 9.98 e+03 1.88 e+03 6.55 e+02 3.02 e+03 1.02 e+03 9.17 e+03 6.55 e+02 1.30 e+04
Best 3.00 e+02 5.21 e+03 8.77 e+02 4.41 e+03 7.55 e+02 4.57 e+02 1.51 e+03 6.04 e+02 5.75 e+03 4.57 e+02 4.48 e+03
Worst 3.00 e+02 1.13 e+04 2.93 e+03 1.37 e+04 3.05 e+03 1.02 e+03 5.79 e+03 1.46 e+03 1.23 e+04 1.02 e+03 2.04 e+04
Std 0.00 e+00 2.99 e+03 1.02 e+03 4.28 e+03 1.22 e+03 2.78 e+02 2.14 e+03 4.07 e+02 2.91 e+03 2.78 e+02 9.04 e+03
Median 3.00 e+02 9.06 e+03 1.30 e+03 1.09 e+04 1.85 e+03 5.73 e+02 2.39 e+03 1.00 e+03 9.30 e+03 5.73 e+02 1.36 e+04
Rank 1 8 5 10 6 3 7 4 9 2 11
C17-F4 Mean 4.00 e+02 1.22 e+03 4.07 e+02 5.53 e+02 4.23 e+02 4.04 e+02 4.12 e+02 4.09 e+02 4.05 e+02 4.19 e+02 4.14 e+02
Best 4.00 e+02 7.84 e+02 4.03 e+02 4.67 e+02 4.08 e+02 4.02 e+02 4.06 e+02 4.09 e+02 4.04 e+02 4.01 e+02 4.12 e+02
Worst 4.00 e+02 1.64 e+03 4.13 e+02 6.50 e+02 4.64 e+02 4.05 e+02 4.28 e+02 4.11 e+02 4.08 e+02 4.61 e+02 4.17 e+02
Std 0.00 e+00 3.94 e+02 5.28 e+00 9.75 e+01 2.94 e+01 1.61 e+00 1.18 e+01 1.06 e+00 2.00 e+00 3.06 e+01 2.03 e+00
Median 4.00 e+02 1.22 e+03 4.06 e+02 5.46 e+02 4.10 e+02 4.05 e+02 4.06 e+02 4.09 e+02 4.05 e+02 4.07 e+02 4.14 e+02
Rank 1 11 4 10 9 2 6 5 3 8 7
C17-F5 Mean 5.01 e+02 5.65 e+02 5.13 e+02 5.57 e+02 5.37 e+02 5.22 e+02 5.13 e+02 5.31 e+02 5.48 e+02 5.26 e+02 5.26 e+02
Best 5.01 e+02 5.52 e+02 5.09 e+02 5.39 e+02 5.22 e+02 5.10 e+02 5.08 e+02 5.26 e+02 5.44 e+02 5.11 e+02 5.22 e+02
Worst 5.02 e+02 5.77 e+02 5.18 e+02 5.85 e+02 5.68 e+02 5.34 e+02 5.20 e+02 5.35 e+02 5.58 e+02 5.46 e+02 5.32 e+02
Std 5.37e−01 1.59 e+01 5.32 e+00 2.21 e+01 2.34 e+01 1.07 e+01 5.46 e+00 4.30 e+00 6.98 e+00 1.78 e+01 4.88 e+00
Median 5.01 e+02 5.65 e+02 5.12 e+02 5.53 e+02 5.29 e+02 5.22 e+02 5.12 e+02 5.32 e+02 5.46 e+02 5.23 e+02 5.25 e+02
Rank 1 11 2 10 8 4 3 7 9 5 6
C17-F6 Mean 6.00 e+02 6.35 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.22 e+02 6.20 e+02 6.02 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.06 e+02 6.15 e+02 6.07 e+02 6.09 e+02
Best 6.00 e+02 6.33 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.13 e+02 6.07 e+02 6.00 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.04 e+02 6.03 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.06 e+02
Worst 6.00 e+02 6.39 e+02 6.02 e+02 6.35 e+02 6.39 e+02 6.04 e+02 6.02 e+02 6.09 e+02 6.31 e+02 6.17 e+02 6.13 e+02
Std 0.00 e+00 3.15 e+00 7.63e−01 1.03 e+01 1.48 e+01 1.66 e+00 5.01e−01 2.29 e+00 1.44 e+01 7.61 e+00 3.15 e+00
Median 6.00 e+02 6.35 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.19 e+02 6.18 e+02 6.02 e+02 6.01 e+02 6.06 e+02 6.13 e+02 6.04 e+02 6.09 e+02
Rank 1 11 3 10 9 4 2 5 8 6 7
C17-F7 Mean 7.11 e+02 7.94 e+02 7.25 e+02 8.15 e+02 7.57e+02 7.30e+02 7.26e+02 7.49e+02 7.18e+02 7.32e+02 7.35e+02
Best 7.11e+02 7.85e+02 7.20e+02 7.82e+02 7.47e+02 7.17e+02 7.17e+02 7.45e+02 7.15e+02 7.25e+02 7.26e+02
Worst 7.12e+02 8.05e+02 7.31e+02 8.51e+02 7.82e+02 7.49e+02 7.43e+02 7.55e+02 7.21e+02 7.42e+02 7.41e+02
Std 5.54e−01 1.04e+01 4.99e+00 3.22e+01 1.80e+01 1.46e+01 1.29e+01 4.96e+00 3.09e+00 7.70e+00 7.49e+00
Median 7.11e+02 7.93e+02 7.24e+02 8.13e+02 7.50e+02 7.27e+02 7.22e+02 7.47e+02 7.18e+02 7.30e+02 7.37e+02
Rank 1 10 3 11 9 5 4 8 2 6 7
C17-F8 Mean 8.01e+02 8.49e+02 8.13e+02 8.44e+02 8.34e+02 8.12e+02 8.16e+02 8.35e+02 8.19e+02 8.22e+02 8.17e+02
Best 8.01e+02 8.39e+02 8.09e+02 8.30e+02 8.19e+02 8.09e+02 8.11e+02 8.29e+02 8.13e+02 8.16e+02 8.14e+02
Worst 8.02e+02 8.53e+02 8.15e+02 8.60e+02 8.44e+02 8.16e+02 8.21e+02 8.41e+02 8.25e+02 8.28e+02 8.23e+02
Std 6.21e−01 7.19e+00 3.15e+00 1.45e+01 1.18e+01 2.94e+00 4.66e+00 6.77e+00 5.72e+00 6.26e+00 4.42e+00
Median 8.01e+02 8.52e+02 8.14e+02 8.43e+02 8.36e+02 8.12e+02 8.16e+02 8.34e+02 8.19e+02 8.22e+02 8.15e+02
Rank 1 11 3 10 8 2 4 9 6 7 5
C17-F9 Mean 9.00e+02 1.39e+03 9.06e+02 1.32e+03 1.31e+03 9.02e+02 9.12e+02 9.12e+02 9.02e+02 9.05e+02 9.06e+02
Best 9.00e+02 1.31e+03 9.00e+02 1.13e+03 1.05e+03 9.00e+02 9.01e+02 9.09e+02 9.00e+02 9.01e+02 9.04e+02
Worst 9.00e+02 1.52e+03 9.16e+02 1.57e+03 1.56e+03 9.04e+02 9.33e+02 9.17e+02 9.04e+02 9.11e+02 9.08e+02
Std 0.00e+00 9.51e+01 7.64e+00 2.03e+02 2.29e+02 2.63e+00 1.65e+01 4.22e+00 2.15e+00 4.46e+00 2.03e+00
Median 9.00e+02 1.38e+03 9.04e+02 1.29e+03 1.32e+03 9.02e+02 9.07e+02 9.11e+02 9.01e+02 9.05e+02 9.06e+02
Rank 1 11 6 10 9 3 8 7 2 4 5
C17-F10 Mean 1.01e+03 2.45e+03 1.54e+03 1.98e+03 1.97e+03 1.76e+03 1.72e+03 2.10e+03 2.19e+03 1.91e+03 1.71e+03
Best 1.00e+03 2.30e+03 1.41e+03 1.78e+03 1.48e+03 1.46e+03 1.53e+03 1.74e+03 1.95e+03 1.55e+03 1.45e+03
Worst 1.01e+03 2.75e+03 1.64e+03 2.17e+03 2.46e+03 2.19e+03 1.98e+03 2.38e+03 2.29e+03 2.29e+03 2.08e+03
Std 7.19e+00 2.20e+02 1.08e+02 2.37e+02 5.04e+02 3.66e+02 2.06e+02 2.91e+02 1.75e+02 3.28e+02 2.95e+02
Median 1.01e+03 2.37e+03 1.55e+03 1.99e+03 1.98e+03 1.70e+03 1.68e+03 2.14e+03 2.26e+03 1.89e+03 1.65e+03
Rank 1 11 2 8 7 5 4 9 10 6 3
C17-F11 Mean 1.10e+03 3.58e+03 1.13e+03 4.85e+03 1.15e+03 1.13e+03 1.15e+03 1.15e+03 1.14e+03 1.14e+03 2.21e+03
Best 1.10e+03 1.41e+03 1.11e+03 4.72e+03 1.13e+03 1.11e+03 1.12e+03 1.14e+03 1.13e+03 1.13e+03 1.13e+03
Worst 1.10e+03 5.72e+03 1.17e+03 4.92e+03 1.17e+03 1.14e+03 1.23e+03 1.16e+03 1.16e+03 1.17e+03 5.30e+03
Std 0.00e+00 2.10e+03 2.69e+01 9.61e+01 2.02e+01 1.66e+01 5.31e+01 1.29e+01 1.55e+01 2.03e+01 2.23e+03
Median 1.10e+03 3.60e+03 1.12e+03 4.89e+03 1.15e+03 1.13e+03 1.14e+03 1.15e+03 1.13e+03 1.14e+03 1.20e+03
Rank 1 10 2 11 7 3 8 6 4 5 9
C17-F12 Mean 1.35e+03 6.08e+08 6.71e+05 1.08e+06 2.21e+06 1.07e+06 1.40e+06 4.53e+06 1.06e+06 1.90e+05 7.04e+05
Best 1.32e+03 1.35e+08 2.30e+04 4.70e+05 3.44e+05 2.04e+05 4.50e+04 1.36e+06 6.51e+05 1.52e+04 3.94e+05
Worst 1.44e+03 1.06e+09 1.05e+06 1.34e+06 3.65e+06 2.79e+06 2.19e+06 7.99e+06 1.49e+06 2.98e+05 1.12e+06
Std 6.19e+01 5.07e+08 4.89e+05 4.42e+05 1.60e+06 1.26e+06 1.02e+06 3.71e+06 3.96e+05 1.33e+05 3.60e+05
Median 1.33e+03 6.17e+08 8.06e+05 1.25e+06 2.42e+06 6.41e+05 1.68e+06 4.39e+06 1.05e+06 2.23e+05 6.53e+05
Rank 1 11 3 7 9 6 8 10 5 2 4
C17-F13 Mean 1.31e+03 2.96e+07 6.02e+03 1.23e+04 7.87e+03 7.14e+03 1.02e+04 1.57e+04 1.00e+04 7.04e+03 4.82e+04
Best 1.30e+03 2.46e+06 4.06e+03 7.89e+03 4.18e+03 2.82e+03 6.46e+03 1.45e+04 5.63e+03 3.64e+03 8.72e+03
Worst 1.31e+03 9.83e+07 7.59e+03 1.82e+04 1.43e+04 1.20e+04 1.43e+04 1.77e+04 1.41e+04 1.58e+04 1.57e+05
Std 2.46e+00 4.96e+07 1.71e+03 4.73e+03 4.90e+03 5.27e+03 3.46e+03 1.51e+03 3.78e+03 6.30e+03 7.84e+04
Median 1.30e+03 8.84e+06 6.22e+03 1.16e+04 6.48e+03 6.85e+03 1.01e+04 1.54e+04 1.02e+04 4.39e+03 1.36e+04
Rank 1 11 2 8 5 4 7 9 6 3 10
C17-F14 Mean 1.40e+03 4.93e+03 1.99e+03 3.24e+03 1.62e+03 1.67e+03 2.34e+03 1.69e+03 5.11e+03 2.90e+03 1.15e+04
Best 1.40e+03 4.24e+03 1.44e+03 1.49e+03 1.48e+03 1.43e+03 1.46e+03 1.51e+03 4.17e+03 1.44e+03 3.42e+03
Worst 1.40e+03 6.15e+03 3.16e+03 5.02e+03 1.99e+03 2.37e+03 4.93e+03 2.05e+03 7.17e+03 6.10e+03 2.25e+04
Std 5.38e−01 9.45e+02 8.73e+02 1.90e+03 2.63e+02 5.05e+02 1.87e+03 2.66e+02 1.52e+03 2.37e+03 8.67e+03
Median 1.40e+03 4.66e+03 1.68e+03 3.22e+03 1.52e+03 1.44e+03 1.48e+03 1.59e+03 4.56e+03 2.03e+03 1.00e+04
Rank 1 9 5 8 2 3 6 4 10 7 11
C17-F15 Mean 1.50e+03 1.27e+04 4.19e+03 6.80e+03 6.13e+03 2.09e+03 5.78e+03 2.24e+03 2.14e+04 8.52e+03 4.69e+03
Best 1.50e+03 3.16e+03 3.25e+03 2.80e+03 2.64e+03 1.79e+03 3.55e+03 1.91e+03 1.06e+04 3.38e+03 2.50e+03
Worst 1.50e+03 2.71e+04 5.09e+03 1.13e+04 1.25e+04 2.24e+03 6.85e+03 2.45e+03 3.17e+04 1.36e+04 7.71e+03
Std 2.54e−01 1.14e+04 8.12e+02 3.95e+03 4.69e+03 2.23e+02 1.64e+03 2.58e+02 1.08e+04 4.60e+03 2.73e+03
Median 1.50e+03 1.03e+04 4.21e+03 6.55e+03 4.70e+03 2.17e+03 6.35e+03 2.29e+03 2.16e+04 8.54e+03 4.27e+03
Rank 1 10 4 8 7 2 6 3 11 9 5
C17-F16 Mean 1.60e+03 1.98e+03 1.69e+03 2.00e+03 1.92e+03 1.80e+03 1.73e+03 1.68e+03 2.02e+03 1.90e+03 1.79e+03
Best 1.60e+03 1.82e+03 1.64e+03 1.83e+03 1.76e+03 1.71e+03 1.62e+03 1.66e+03 1.90e+03 1.81e+03 1.73e+03
Worst 1.60e+03 2.21e+03 1.73e+03 2.16e+03 2.03e+03 1.87e+03 1.82e+03 1.74e+03 2.20e+03 2.03e+03 1.82e+03
Std 3.41e−01 1.83e+02 4.08e+01 1.66e+02 1.37e+02 7.15e+01 9.27e+01 4.28e+01 1.46e+02 1.08e+02 4.40e+01
Median 1.60e+03 1.94e+03 1.70e+03 2.01e+03 1.94e+03 1.82e+03 1.74e+03 1.66e+03 2.00e+03 1.87e+03 1.81e+03
Rank 1 9 3 10 8 6 4 2 11 7 5
C17-F17 Mean 1.70e+03 1.81e+03 1.74e+03 1.80e+03 1.83e+03 1.83e+03 1.77e+03 1.76e+03 1.84e+03 1.75e+03 1.76e+03
Best 1.70e+03 1.81e+03 1.72e+03 1.78e+03 1.77e+03 1.77e+03 1.72e+03 1.75e+03 1.75e+03 1.74e+03 1.75e+03
Worst 1.70e+03 1.81e+03 1.79e+03 1.81e+03 1.89e+03 1.94e+03 1.87e+03 1.78e+03 1.96e+03 1.77e+03 1.77e+03
Std 1.68e−01 2.87e+00 3.39e+01 1.46e+01 5.29e+01 8.46e+01 7.40e+01 1.64e+01 1.15e+02 1.23e+01 1.08e+01
Median 1.70e+03 1.81e+03 1.72e+03 1.80e+03 1.84e+03 1.81e+03 1.74e+03 1.76e+03 1.82e+03 1.75e+03 1.75e+03
Rank 1 8 2 7 9 10 6 5 11 3 4
C17-F18 Mean 1.81e+03 4.90e+06 1.21e+04 1.30e+04 2.26e+04 2.06e+04 1.97e+04 2.80e+04 1.09e+04 2.14e+04 1.36e+04
Best 1.80e+03 2.47e+05 4.41e+03 1.08e+04 6.83e+03 8.77e+03 6.27e+03 2.15e+04 6.78e+03 6.82e+03 7.30e+03
Worst 1.82e+03 1.42e+07 1.81e+04 1.48e+04 3.33e+04 3.29e+04 3.32e+04 3.30e+04 1.45e+04 3.63e+04 1.98e+04
Std 1.09e+01 7.00e+06 7.06e+03 1.88e+03 1.36e+04 1.13e+04 1.48e+04 5.59e+03 3.71e+03 1.80e+04 5.60e+03
Median 1.80e+03 2.57e+06 1.29e+04 1.31e+04 2.52e+04 2.04e+04 1.97e+04 2.87e+04 1.12e+04 2.12e+04 1.37e+04
Rank 1 11 3 4 9 7 6 10 2 8 5
C17-F19 Mean 1.90e+03 6.06e+05 5.53e+03 1.09e+05 3.06e+04 2.36e+03 5.34e+03 4.75e+03 3.55e+04 2.22e+04 6.03e+03
Best 1.90e+03 3.99e+04 2.28e+03 2.22e+03 7.09e+03 1.92e+03 1.94e+03 2.03e+03 1.13e+04 2.76e+03 3.70e+03
Worst 1.90e+03 1.30e+06 8.64e+03 2.16e+05 5.66e+04 3.44e+03 1.37e+04 1.10e+04 5.09e+04 6.64e+04 8.77e+03
Std 8.05e−01 6.15e+05 3.72e+03 1.32e+05 2.20e+04 7.87e+02 6.06e+03 4.58e+03 1.91e+04 3.23e+04 2.30e+03
Median 1.90e+03 5.42e+05 5.60e+03 1.08e+05 2.94e+04 2.04e+03 2.88e+03 2.98e+03 3.98e+04 9.76e+03 5.83e+03
Rank 1 11 5 10 8 2 4 3 9 7 6
C17-F20 Mean 2.00e+03 2.21e+03 2.10e+03 2.20e+03 2.20e+03 2.14e+03 2.17e+03 2.08e+03 2.24e+03 2.17e+03 2.07e+03
Best 2.00e+03 2.16e+03 2.08e+03 2.11e+03 2.12e+03 2.06e+03 2.13e+03 2.07e+03 2.18e+03 2.14e+03 2.05e+03
Worst 2.00e+03 2.27e+03 2.14e+03 2.29e+03 2.26e+03 2.23e+03 2.24e+03 2.10e+03 2.33e+03 2.19e+03 2.07e+03
Std 0.00e+00 5.60e+01 2.71e+01 8.21e+01 7.86e+01 7.49e+01 5.54e+01 1.31e+01 7.77e+01 2.14e+01 1.08e+01
Median 2.00e+03 2.21e+03 2.09e+03 2.20e+03 2.21e+03 2.14e+03 2.15e+03 2.08e+03 2.22e+03 2.17e+03 2.07e+03
Rank 1 10 4 9 8 5 7 3 11 6 2
C17-F21 Mean 2.20e+03 2.27e+03 2.26e+03 2.32e+03 2.31e+03 2.26e+03 2.31e+03 2.30e+03 2.36e+03 2.32e+03 2.30e+03
Best 2.20e+03 2.24e+03 2.26e+03 2.23e+03 2.23e+03 2.21e+03 2.31e+03 2.22e+03 2.34e+03 2.31e+03 2.24e+03
Worst 2.20e+03 2.29e+03 2.27e+03 2.36e+03 2.35e+03 2.31e+03 2.32e+03 2.33e+03 2.37e+03 2.32e+03 2.33e+03
Std 0.00e+00 2.78e+01 2.49e+00 6.57e+01 5.74e+01 5.70e+01 4.04e+00 5.99e+01 1.37e+01 7.53e+00 4.45e+01
Median 2.20e+03 2.28e+03 2.26e+03 2.35e+03 2.33e+03 2.26e+03 2.31e+03 2.33e+03 2.36e+03 2.32e+03 2.31e+03
Rank 1 4 3 10 7 2 8 6 11 9 5
C17-F22 Mean 2.30e+03 2.83e+03 2.31e+03 2.66e+03 2.32e+03 2.29e+03 2.31e+03 2.32e+03 2.30e+03 2.31e+03 2.32e+03
Best 2.30e+03 2.65e+03 2.30e+03 2.43e+03 2.32e+03 2.24e+03 2.30e+03 2.31e+03 2.30e+03 2.30e+03 2.31e+03
Worst 2.30e+03 2.97e+03 2.31e+03 2.84e+03 2.33e+03 2.31e+03 2.32e+03 2.33e+03 2.30e+03 2.34e+03 2.32e+03
Std 1.57e−01 1.43e+02 4.48e+00 1.97e+02 5.11e+00 3.56e+01 1.04e+01 8.84e+00 1.36e+00 1.96e+01 3.48e+00
Median 2.30e+03 2.85e+03 2.30e+03 2.68e+03 2.32e+03 2.31e+03 2.31e+03 2.31e+03 2.30e+03 2.30e+03 2.32e+03
Rank 2 11 4 10 9 1 5 8 3 6 7
C17-F23 Mean 2.60e+03 2.69e+03 2.61e+03 2.71e+03 2.64e+03 2.62e+03 2.61e+03 2.64e+03 2.77e+03 2.64e+03 2.65e+03
Best 2.60e+03 2.66e+03 2.61e+03 2.63e+03 2.63e+03 2.61e+03 2.61e+03 2.63e+03 2.71e+03 2.63e+03 2.63e+03
Worst 2.60e+03 2.72e+03 2.62e+03 2.75e+03 2.66e+03 2.63e+03 2.62e+03 2.65e+03 2.89e+03 2.65e+03 2.66e+03
Std 1.43e+00 3.07e+01 3.17e+00 5.58e+01 1.83e+01 1.01e+01 6.98e+00 7.94e+00 8.88e+01 7.82e+00 1.19e+01
Median 2.60e+03 2.68e+03 2.61e+03 2.73e+03 2.64e+03 2.62e+03 2.61e+03 2.64e+03 2.74e+03 2.64e+03 2.66e+03
Rank 1 9 3 10 7 4 2 5 11 6 8
C17-F24 Mean 2.63e+03 2.84e+03 2.65e+03 2.68e+03 2.76e+03 2.69e+03 2.75e+03 2.75e+03 2.75e+03 2.76e+03 2.73e+03
Best 2.52e+03 2.81e+03 2.63e+03 2.56e+03 2.73e+03 2.53e+03 2.72e+03 2.74e+03 2.54e+03 2.76e+03 2.57e+03
Worst 2.73e+03 2.89e+03 2.65e+03 2.80e+03 2.79e+03 2.76e+03 2.76e+03 2.76e+03 2.88e+03 2.78e+03 2.80e+03
Std 1.26e+02 3.90e+01 1.19e+01 1.44e+02 2.39e+01 1.17e+02 1.96e+01 1.23e+01 1.58e+02 1.33e+01 1.15e+02
Median 2.64e+03 2.82e+03 2.65e+03 2.68e+03 2.76e+03 2.74e+03 2.75e+03 2.76e+03 2.79e+03 2.76e+03 2.77e+03
Rank 1 11 2 3 9 4 7 8 6 10 5
C17-F25 Mean 2.93e+03 3.23e+03 2.92e+03 3.11e+03 2.91e+03 2.92e+03 2.94e+03 2.93e+03 2.92e+03 2.93e+03 2.95e+03
Best 2.90e+03 3.17e+03 2.91e+03 2.91e+03 2.79e+03 2.90e+03 2.92e+03 2.92e+03 2.91e+03 2.90e+03 2.94e+03
Worst 2.95e+03 3.30e+03 2.93e+03 3.56e+03 2.96e+03 2.94e+03 2.95e+03 2.95e+03 2.94e+03 2.95e+03 2.96e+03
Std 2.50e+01 5.57e+01 5.15e+00 3.29e+02 9.03e+01 2.35e+01 1.24e+01 1.99e+01 2.18e+01 2.38e+01 1.03e+01
Median 2.94e+03 3.23e+03 2.92e+03 2.98e+03 2.95e+03 2.92e+03 2.94e+03 2.93e+03 2.92e+03 2.93e+03 2.95e+03
Rank 6 11 2 10 1 3 8 7 4 5 9
C17-F26 Mean 2.90e+03 3.69e+03 3.04e+03 3.57e+03 3.19e+03 2.95e+03 3.26e+03 3.21e+03 3.78e+03 2.95e+03 2.94e+03
Best 2.90e+03 3.49e+03 2.90e+03 3.12e+03 3.05e+03 2.91e+03 2.97e+03 2.93e+03 2.84e+03 2.92e+03 2.74e+03
Worst 2.90e+03 3.95e+03 3.37e+03 4.11e+03 3.51e+03 3.03e+03 3.90e+03 3.87e+03 4.28e+03 3.00e+03 3.11e+03
Std 4.01e−13 2.29e+02 2.36e+02 4.91e+02 2.34e+02 6.03e+01 4.63e+02 4.78e+02 6.91e+02 3.99e+01 1.75e+02
Median 2.90e+03 3.65e+03 2.95e+03 3.52e+03 3.11e+03 2.92e+03 3.09e+03 3.02e+03 3.99e+03 2.94e+03 2.97e+03
Rank 1 10 5 9 6 3 8 7 11 4 2
C17-F27 Mean 3.09e+03 3.22e+03 3.11e+03 3.17e+03 3.18e+03 3.09e+03 3.12e+03 3.12e+03 3.21e+03 3.13e+03 3.15e+03
Best 3.09e+03 3.12e+03 3.09e+03 3.10e+03 3.18e+03 3.09e+03 3.09e+03 3.10e+03 3.20e+03 3.10e+03 3.12e+03
Worst 3.09e+03 3.38e+03 3.14e+03 3.21e+03 3.19e+03 3.10e+03 3.18e+03 3.16e+03 3.23e+03 3.18e+03 3.20e+03
Std 2.84e−13 1.21e+02 2.39e+01 5.27e+01 5.92e+00 4.88e+00 4.34e+01 3.33e+01 1.31e+01 3.89e+01 3.88e+01
Median 3.09e+03 3.18e+03 3.10e+03 3.19e+03 3.18e+03 3.09e+03 3.10e+03 3.10e+03 3.21e+03 3.13e+03 3.15e+03
Rank 1 11 3 8 9 2 5 4 10 6 7
C17-F28 Mean 3.10e+03 3.72e+03 3.23e+03 3.55e+03 3.29e+03 3.25e+03 3.34e+03 3.33e+03 3.43e+03 3.31e+03 3.26e+03
Best 3.10e+03 3.65e+03 3.17e+03 3.39e+03 3.18e+03 3.11e+03 3.19e+03 3.24e+03 3.42e+03 3.20e+03 3.15e+03
Worst 3.10e+03 3.77e+03 3.26e+03 3.74e+03 3.39e+03 3.39e+03 3.41e+03 3.39e+03 3.46e+03 3.37e+03 3.49e+03
Std 0.00e+00 5.55e+01 4.68e+01 1.94e+02 1.07e+02 1.59e+02 1.08e+02 7.11e+01 1.70e+01 8.24e+01 1.72e+02
Median 3.10e+03 3.72e+03 3.25e+03 3.54e+03 3.30e+03 3.25e+03 3.38e+03 3.34e+03 3.43e+03 3.33e+03 3.19e+03
Rank 1 11 2 10 5 3 8 7 9 6 4
C17-F29 Mean 3.13e+03 3.36e+03 3.21e+03 3.24e+03 3.34e+03 3.21e+03 3.26e+03 3.22e+03 3.33e+03 3.26e+03 3.24e+03
Best 3.13e+03 3.29e+03 3.17e+03 3.17e+03 3.24e+03 3.15e+03 3.19e+03 3.18e+03 3.23e+03 3.17e+03 3.19e+03
Worst 3.13e+03 3.42e+03 3.26e+03 3.29e+03 3.45e+03 3.29e+03 3.38e+03 3.25e+03 3.59e+03 3.33e+03 3.27e+03
Std 2.68e+00 7.80e+01 4.45e+01 5.50e+01 9.42e+01 6.13e+01 9.66e+01 3.21e+01 1.83e+02 7.66e+01 4.18e+01
Median 3.13e+03 3.36e+03 3.21e+03 3.25e+03 3.32e+03 3.20e+03 3.24e+03 3.22e+03 3.26e+03 3.28e+03 3.25e+03
Rank 1 11 3 5 10 2 7 4 9 8 6
C17-F30 Mean 3.42e+03 3.28e+06 4.77e+05 6.48e+05 9.72e+05 3.80e+05 9.24e+05 1.72e+05 7.92e+05 4.53e+05 1.43e+06
Best 3.39e+03 8.85e+05 1.80e+04 2.68e+05 1.35e+05 1.08e+04 3.32e+04 2.95e+04 6.91e+05 1.12e+04 6.23e+05
Worst 3.44e+03 4.99e+06 6.97e+05 1.12e+06 3.39e+06 1.17e+06 1.34e+06 2.42e+05 8.63e+05 8.30e+05 2.99e+06
Std 3.00e+01 1.87e+06 3.37e+05 3.94e+05 1.74e+06 5.73e+05 6.62e+05 1.05e+05 8.75e+04 4.53e+05 1.21e+06
Median 3.42e+03 3.62e+06 5.95e+05 6.02e+05 1.82e+05 1.73e+05 1.16e+06 2.09e+05 8.08e+05 4.85e+05 1.06e+06
Rank 1 11 5 6 9 3 8 2 7 4 10
Sum rank 35 295 100 252 214 107 174 176 212 168 181
Mean rank 1.21e+00 1.02e+01 3.45e+00 8.69e+00 7.38e+00 3.69e+00 6.00e+00 6.07e+00 7.31e+00 5.79e+00 6.24e+00
Total rank 1 11 2 10 9 3 5 6 8 4 7