Skip to main content
. 2023 Dec 6;13:21472. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-48462-1

Table 8.

Evaluation results of the pressure vessel design (SIs are statistical indicators and DVs are design variables).

PEOA RSA MPA TSA WOA GWO MVO TLBO GSA PSO GA
SIs Mean 5883.043 12,277.23 5941.73 6495.49 8366.765 6476.968 5906.445 31,739.83 23,227.89 40,801.07 31,420.31
Best 5882.901 7754.352 5941.73 5925.71 6331.27 5912.494 5888.455 18,534.82 15,456.32 19,543.95 10,111.52
Worst 5884.245 18,129.78 5941.73 7346.794 11,303.01 7229.541 6034.021 61,688.65 40,575.35 86,266.9 55,069.98
Std 0.316128 3043.911 8.53E−06 516.9775 1292.405 370.9219 31.59569 11,131.22 6880.321 16,575.37 12,939.3
Median 5882.903 12,673.37 5941.73 6369.186 8359.384 6416.483 5896.843 28,139.58 21,505.51 37,277.24 29,995.8
Rank 1 7 3 5 6 4 2 10 8 11 9
DVs Ts 0.778027 0.907016 0.778027 0.782743 0.900699 0.791713 0.779624 1.48344 1.474078 1.550955 1.256885
Th 0.384579 0.673856 0.384579 0.394416 0.429187 0.392455 0.386047 1.891043 1.218961 2.730243 0.734408
R 40.31228 40.65186 40.31228 40.49696 44.44714 41.00272 40.39207 57.20355 72.14816 43.36799 50.50276
L 200 200 200 197.6681 149.4709 190.6063 198.9133 84.2132 14.55677 168.629 116.7856