Table 8.
Evaluation results of the pressure vessel design ( are statistical indicators and are design variables).
| PEOA | RSA | MPA | TSA | WOA | GWO | MVO | TLBO | GSA | PSO | GA | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean | 5883.043 | 12,277.23 | 5941.73 | 6495.49 | 8366.765 | 6476.968 | 5906.445 | 31,739.83 | 23,227.89 | 40,801.07 | 31,420.31 | |
| Best | 5882.901 | 7754.352 | 5941.73 | 5925.71 | 6331.27 | 5912.494 | 5888.455 | 18,534.82 | 15,456.32 | 19,543.95 | 10,111.52 | |
| Worst | 5884.245 | 18,129.78 | 5941.73 | 7346.794 | 11,303.01 | 7229.541 | 6034.021 | 61,688.65 | 40,575.35 | 86,266.9 | 55,069.98 | |
| Std | 0.316128 | 3043.911 | 8.53E−06 | 516.9775 | 1292.405 | 370.9219 | 31.59569 | 11,131.22 | 6880.321 | 16,575.37 | 12,939.3 | |
| Median | 5882.903 | 12,673.37 | 5941.73 | 6369.186 | 8359.384 | 6416.483 | 5896.843 | 28,139.58 | 21,505.51 | 37,277.24 | 29,995.8 | |
| Rank | 1 | 7 | 3 | 5 | 6 | 4 | 2 | 10 | 8 | 11 | 9 | |
| Ts | 0.778027 | 0.907016 | 0.778027 | 0.782743 | 0.900699 | 0.791713 | 0.779624 | 1.48344 | 1.474078 | 1.550955 | 1.256885 | |
| Th | 0.384579 | 0.673856 | 0.384579 | 0.394416 | 0.429187 | 0.392455 | 0.386047 | 1.891043 | 1.218961 | 2.730243 | 0.734408 | |
| R | 40.31228 | 40.65186 | 40.31228 | 40.49696 | 44.44714 | 41.00272 | 40.39207 | 57.20355 | 72.14816 | 43.36799 | 50.50276 | |
| L | 200 | 200 | 200 | 197.6681 | 149.4709 | 190.6063 | 198.9133 | 84.2132 | 14.55677 | 168.629 | 116.7856 |