Table 3.
Published guidelines for imaging following a first febrile urinary tract infection
| Guideline | Ultrasound | VCUG | Late DMSA |
|---|---|---|---|
|
NICE 2007 [139] |
<6/12 Yes >6/12 atypical UTI |
No unless abnormal US or atypical UTI | Atypical UTI |
| AAP 2011 [7] | Yes | No unless abnormal US | No |
| ISPN 2012 [140] | Yes | No unless abnormal US or risk factors | Abnormal US and/or VUR |
| CARI 2014 [141] | No unless absent antenatal US, atypical UTI, mass, poor stream, slow response | No unless recurrent febrile UTIs or US suggestive of posterior urethral valve | No unless reduced kidney function |
| Canadian 2014 [142] | Yes | No unless abnormal US suggestive of obstruction or high grade VUR | |
| EAU-ESPU 2015 [143]a | Yes |
Yes consider after second febrile UTI in boys >1 year with option of a “top down” approach performing DMSA instead and VCUG if positive |
No DMSA if VCUG positive or VCUG if DMSA positive |
| Urology Section AAP 2012 [74]b | Yes | Yes | No |
aThe EUA-ESPU guidelines were updated in 2021 (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpurol.2021.01.037), restricting a VCUG to those with an abnormal ultrasound or atypical UTI. The EUA-ESPU guidelines remain referenced in the article as these were the guidelines quoted by authors in the publications reviewed
bThe Urology Section of the AAP published a dissenting view on the updated AAP guidelines regarding the investigation and management of a first febrile UTI, concerned that lack of a VCUG placed children with unrecognized VUR at risk of pyelonephritis and scarring
AAP American Academy of Pediatrics, CARI Caring for Australian and New Zealanders with Kidney Impairment, EAU-ESPU European Association of Urology – European Society of Pediatric Urology, DMSA 99mTc-dimercaptosuccinic acid scan, ISPN Italian Society of Pediatric Nephrology, NICE National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, US ultrasound, UTI urinary tract infection, VCUG voiding cystourethrogram