Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: Expert Rev Clin Immunol. 2023 Apr 10;19(6):613–626. doi: 10.1080/1744666X.2023.2198212

Table 3.

Pros and cons of interstitial lung disease screening modalities in systemic sclerosis

Modality Pros Cons
Current approach to screening HRCT at baseline
  • High-resolution

  • Standardized protocol for study performance and interpretation

  • Characterize and differentiate lung disease morphology

  • Radiation exposure

Pulmonary function test
  • Useful information on lung function

  • Inexpensive

  • Not a screening test

  • Has to be used in conjunction with HRCT

Autoantibody testing
  • Prognostication with anti-SCL70 positivity

  • Not a screening test

  • Has to be used in conjunction with HRCT

Newer innovations Low-dose CT scan
  • Comparable sensitivity and specificity

  • Low radiation exposure

  • Potential near miss

Computer-aided CT scans
  • Consistency in reporting for common findings – nodules, GGOs, fibrosis

  • Standardization in quantification

  • Not widely available

  • Comparability between software not known

PET-CT scans
  • Metabolic activity as indicated by FDG uptake could differentiate areas of inflammation from fibrosis

  • Gallium labelled protocols may indicate extent of fibrosis more accurately

  • Large scale studies needed to understand the role in screening

Lung ultrasound
  • Relatively inexpensive compared to CT

  • No radiation exposure

  • Comparable to CT as a screening tool although criteria need to be defined

  • Operator dependent

  • Potential confounders from other lung pathologies (e.g. pulmonary edema etc.)

Lung MRI
  • No radiation exposure

  • Certain sequences may differentiate between areas of active inflammation and fibrosis

  • Expensive

  • Cannot differentiate between patterns of ILD

Novel biomarkers*
  • Quick, less invasive, and potentially less expensive

  • Convenient

  • Variable sensitivity and low specificity

  • Large scale studies needed to understand the role in screening

E-nose
  • Convenient and quick

  • Can distinguish patients with ILD from healthy controls

  • Large scale studies needed to understand the role in screening

*

KL-6, SP-D, and biomarkers of lung epithelial cell dysfunction, aberrant immunity, and abnormal lung remodeling