Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 7;57(48):19532–19544. doi: 10.1021/acs.est.3c03999

Table 1. Advantages and Disadvantages of the Four NO2 Data Sets from This Study and Potentially Appropriate Applications.

NO2 data set strengths weaknesses potentially appropriate applications for policy-relevant end-users
monitors direct measurements sparsely and unevenly distributed monitoring attainment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards
  many monitoring sites have a long-term data record prone to biases based on measurement techniques ground-truthing satellite and model data sets
  relatively low technical barriers to the usage of data costly (>$10,000)  
satellites semiempirical observations retrievals are prone to interference from clouds and surface albedo characterizing relative differences in NO2 levels across population groups or regions when surface-level concentrations are not needed
  high spatial resolution (∼1 km) achieved through oversampling techniques temporal resolution sacrificed through oversampling guiding placement of future AQS monitors or measurement campaigns (e.g., targeted mobile measurements)
  valuable tool to understand recent shocks to air pollution (e.g., COVID-19 pandemic) measures total tropospheric columnar rather than surface-level concentrations, so satellite-derived NO2 cannot be used in conventional health studies identifying potential hotspots and new emission sources
  (for OMI only) record since 2005 enables long-term trend analysis technical skills need to preprocess and analyze data estimating urban NOX emissions
    presently most satellites are polar-orbiting, providing ∼one snapshot per day in the early afternoon  
    the spatial resolution of satellite instruments prior to TROPOMI (launched in 2017) is nearly 1 order of magnitude coarser than TROPOMI’s resolution  
photochemical and statistical models increasingly high spatial resolution (statistical models: 50 m to 1 km; photochemical models: 10 km) computationally expensive to generate reporting long-term trends
  estimates surface-level concentrations, useable for health impact assessments ability to model recent year(s) may be hampered by lag to acquire up-to-date model inputs estimating NO2-attributable disease burdens and associated disparities
  useful for assessing long-term trends technical skills need to preprocess and analyze data (for photochemical models only) quantifying source sector contributions to ambient NO2
    (statistical models only) driven by monitor placement