Table 3.
Results of Wilcoxon’s rank sum test.
| Benchmark | Wilcoxon test Parameters |
GBAEF vs AEFA | GBAEF vs PSO | GBAEF vs FA | GBAEF vs MVO | GBAEF vs SSA | GBAEF vs TSA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F2 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F3 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F4 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F5 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
NAN 915 0 N.A |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F6 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
| F7 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
| F8 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
NAN 915 0 N.A |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F9 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F10 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
NAN 915 0 N.A |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
1.212 × 10−12 465 0 GBAEF |
| F11 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
| F12 |
p-value R+ R-Winner |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
3.019 × 10−11 465 0 GBAEF |
| Total | Superior/Inferior/N.A | 9/0/3 | 12/0/0 | 12/0/0 | 12/0/0 | 12/0/0 | 12/0/0 |