Skip to main content
. 2023 Nov 18;12(4):637–674. doi: 10.1007/s40119-023-00339-0

Table 2.

The pros and cons of natural hydrogels

Materials Advantages Disadvantages References
Alginate Non-thrombogenic, structure is similar to ECM, biocompatible, bio-inert Limited cell adhesion and needs modification for cell binding, limited stability in vivo [5, 6, 81]
Chitosan Good biocompatibility, non-immunogenic, can be conjugated with other molecules, low toxicity Uncontrollable mechanical properties [38]
Collagen Low immunogenicity, good availability, remarkable biocompatibility, biodegradability, provides sufficient mechanical stability, tensile strength can be modified by changing collagen amount and cross-linking, enhances stem cell engraftment and requires fewer cells to be transplanted, easy to change shape, can be 3D-printed Non-tunable mechanical properties, lack of mechanical robustness, gels with high weight fraction limit cell migration and nutrient diffusion [8, 13, 82]
Elastin Antibacterial, good cell–matrix interaction, good elasticity, biocompatibility, soft, stretchable Formation of aggregates or self-assembly above a specific temperature, insolubility, tendency to calcify, hard to purify, poor mechanical stability [83, 84]
Fibrin Good biocompatibility, biodegradability, mechanical properties, bioactivity, easy cross-linking for cells and in vivo experiments, can be injected into tissues in vivo, easily modified into many shapes, good drug delivery system, great extensibility Stiffness, rapid degradation [85, 86]
Gelatin Good biocompatibility, biodegradability, easy for isolation, solubility, thermo-reversible, low processing cost, nontoxic, safe, can be 3D-printed, ideal for drug delivery Prolonged existence in vivo [22]
Hyaluronic acid (HA) Excellent biocompatibility, biodegradable, non-immunogenic, proper viscosity, promotes angiogenesis Rapid degradation, poor retention of cells, poor survival of cells [20]
Matrigel Soluble, good attachment for cells, promotes cellular attachment, proliferation, and differentiation, angiogenesis, thermosensitive, provides many growth factors, cytoprotective, less invasive, myocardial-injectable Structural weakness, fast transition to solid at 37 °C, adopted for short-term analysis [29, 30]
Keratin Low cost, easy and wide availability, renewable, good biocompatibility, good biodegradability, tough biomaterial, high stability, no inflammatory or immunogenic response Insoluble, chemicals for increasing solubility are toxic [87]
Silk fibroin Wide availability from nature, low cost, incredibly robust mechanical and elastic properties, thermal and chemical stability, enzymatic biodegradability, nontoxic, drug stabilization, injectable, can be modified into multiple forms and used as 3D-printed material Mild immune and inflammatory response, difficult for chemical modification, degradation rate is dependent on processing [33, 34]

ECM extracellular matrix